Jair Barik
2011-08-22, 04:59 AM
Okay, so a creature with total concealment can be attacked by ranged or close combat attacks if they are targeted at the square the creature is in but these have a 50% chance to miss. I get that much, but I need some clarifications for some other aspects of it.
As I understand it if a spell has an area descriptor then it effects creatures with total concealment normally but if it has a targetted descriptor (confusion, magic missile) then it can't be used against a creature with total concealment, a ray can though as it isn't targetted it is a ray (miss chance still applies).
If the creature is invisible then spot checks can be made to see them but not if they just have total concealment right?
So what about Shadow dragons (Dracomnicon) and Spore bats (FF)? They have extraordinary/supernatural total concealment in any light conditions other than daylight. So does this mean they are effectively invisible but cannot be seen with a spot check? True seeing doesn't look like it would work as it doesn't pierce concealment. Now in the case of the shadow dragon that is dangerous but not impossible. A daylight spell will see it off and even without that you can still hear it and its size should help with targetting a square that it is filling but the sporebat is silent. Auto passing move silently checks as far as I can tell and only taking up a 5ft square. Now it has an awful save DC on its ability and weak attacks for its CR but without daylight it seems the only way to deal with it reliably is retreat. You can't locate it very easily so beyond spamming AoE's everywhere I can't see how you fight the things.
Is there something I'm missing here?
As I understand it if a spell has an area descriptor then it effects creatures with total concealment normally but if it has a targetted descriptor (confusion, magic missile) then it can't be used against a creature with total concealment, a ray can though as it isn't targetted it is a ray (miss chance still applies).
If the creature is invisible then spot checks can be made to see them but not if they just have total concealment right?
So what about Shadow dragons (Dracomnicon) and Spore bats (FF)? They have extraordinary/supernatural total concealment in any light conditions other than daylight. So does this mean they are effectively invisible but cannot be seen with a spot check? True seeing doesn't look like it would work as it doesn't pierce concealment. Now in the case of the shadow dragon that is dangerous but not impossible. A daylight spell will see it off and even without that you can still hear it and its size should help with targetting a square that it is filling but the sporebat is silent. Auto passing move silently checks as far as I can tell and only taking up a 5ft square. Now it has an awful save DC on its ability and weak attacks for its CR but without daylight it seems the only way to deal with it reliably is retreat. You can't locate it very easily so beyond spamming AoE's everywhere I can't see how you fight the things.
Is there something I'm missing here?