Vote up an RPG system

[Howler Dagger]

The purpose of this is to make a full-fledged RPG system, which could be used in real games.
Voting works like this: you get 3 votes, two of which add 1 to an option, and the other subtracts from an option
Round One: Genre
Sci Fi is the winner!
Round Two: Dice rolling mechanics
d12 and Dicepool B ( certain numbers are successes, each tasks requires one or more success) are the winner!
Round Three: Success Number
Now we are voting for what number (or higher) will be a success.
12
11
10
91
8 1
7
6 -2
Voting will end October 1st, 12:00 GMT

Tell me if you think i should include any lower numbers, and feel free to suggest gameplay mechanics or fluff bits.

[Zeta Kai]

For Modern & Sci-Fi.

Against Fantasy.

[TravelLog]

For Cyberpunk and Sci-Fi

Against Fantasy

[The Underlord]

For horror and Fantasy
Against Sci-fi

[Zale]

I vote for Cyperpunk and Universal.

Vote against.. Horror, I guess.

[Lizard Lord]

For Sci-Fi and Fantasy

Against Modern

[Epee Assassin]

Cyberpunk and Fantasy, definitely.
Against Sci-Fi :roach:

[DualShadow]

For: Universal & Sci-Fi
Against: Horror

Tired of fantasy but yet not against mixes of fantasy and technology.

[Fera Tian]

nevermind, delete

[Ilorin Lorati]

For Horror and Universal

Against Fantasy

I generally think that setting should be removed from core system crunch, but it's hard to have a good horror without it being a core aspect.

[IcarusWings]

For Cyberpunk and Sci-Fi

Against Fantasy

[Bearpunch]

For Sci-fi and Horror.

Against universal.

[Lord Loss]

Vote for Horror and Sci-Fi and against Cyberpunk

[Grod_The_Giant]

For Sci-Fi and Horror, against Fantasy.

[137beth]

+1 to universal and fantasy,
-1 to sci-fi

[SlashRunner]

Horror and Cyberpunk
Against Sci-Fi

[Dreadn4ught]

For Sci-Fi and Modern.

Against Cyberpunk.

[Imbasel]

For Sci-Fi and Fantasy
Against Cyberpunk

[Siosilvar]

Let's see if we can do Sci-fi Horror without getting Cyberpunk mixed in.

[Tesla_pasta]

For Cyberpunk and fantasy against Universal

[Devmaar]

For Cyberpunk and Fantasy

Against Horror

[Airanath]

Sci-fi and horror, don't give me cyberpunk

[B!shop]

+1 Modern & Fantasy
-1 Horror

[Howler Dagger]

Sci Fi is the winner! now moving on to part 2

[SlashRunner]

d6 and d12 (yes, I dared), against d20
Dicepool B and Dicepool A, against X vs. DC

[Knaight]

+1 to D6, 4dF
-1 to d20

+1 to Dicepool B, x vs DC
-1 to Roll Under

[Brogen]

For d10 & d12
Against d4

For Dicepool A & Dicepool B
Against Roll Under

[IcarusWings]

For d10 and d6, against d20.

For Dicepool B and Roll under, against X vs. DC

[137beth]

Part 1: d4 and d8, subtract from d6.
Part 2: Dicepool A and B, subtract from Roll Under.

[Devmaar]

Part 1
For d10, d12 Against d4

Part 2
For Dicepool B, Roll Under Against X vs. DC

[TinyMushroom]

For D12 and D8
Against D20

For Roll Under and Dicepool A
Against X vs DC

[SlashRunner]

Ok, this just makes me want to build a system based on d12's...
Get them some love...

[Howler Dagger]

Round 2 is over! d12 and Dicepool B are the winners! Now we are voting on success number.

[IcarusWings]

For 8, against 6

[CarpeGuitarrem]

For 9, against 6.

[Howler Dagger]

you both get one more positive vote.

[SlashRunner]

9, against 8

I don't really like anything but 9.

[Knaight]

For 8, 6
Against 9

9 is pointless. It gets 4 out of the 12 possibilities, and as such is equivalent to 5 on a 1d6 (2 out of 6), or 3 on 1d3. 8, meanwhile, is 5 out of 12, and actually takes advantage of the die in question, as the probability can't be mirrored with a smaller die. 6 is similar, getting 7 out of 12.

[137beth]

+1 to 7 and 8,
-1 to 9.

[Lizard Lord]

For 8, 6

Against 9

[abk108]

9+ = Success
6- = Failure

a roll of 7-8 is a not a success but doesn't have any dire consequence, like a failure would, and usually allows a reroll on a subsequent turn.

[TheLonelyScribe]

For 8, 7

Against 9

Also for abk108's system but with success 8+, failure 5-.

[Dreadn4ught]

For 8 and 7

Against 12

[TinyMushroom]

For 9 and 12
Against 8

[Lord Loss]

For 9 and 12

Against 7

[Knaight]

Guys, this is a dead project. The success number vote was supposed to end weeks ago, to be replaced by another.