PDA

View Full Version : Herpestidae's Redwall Readthrough Revival!



John Cribati
2012-03-22, 05:07 PM
Old stuff:


Hey, All. It's Me. Livebloggin' Redwall. Well, not really, because I already read all of them (13th person in the state of New York to get a copy of Doomwyte, but that's largely irrelevant). However, the list of books I deemed worthy of more than one read-through is small. In fact, there are at least two that I downright despised.

Some notes before we begin:
The books are split into three sections, each with 20 or so chapters. Yeah, it's kind of thick for a kid's book
I'll be taking this three chapters at a time. Otherwise, we'll be here Forever.
The exception to this is this post, because just the Prologue has caused me to rant a lot.
I have never done this sort of thing before. Professionalism? What's that?

My commentary will run like so, while

Quotes from the book will go like so.
We cool?

__________________________________________________ _

Previous entries:
Redwall
Well, it opens with this:


Who says that I am dead
Knows nought at all.
I — am that is,
Two mice within Redwall.
The Warrior sleeps
’Twixt Hall and Cavern Hole.
I — am that is,
Take on my mighty role.
Look for the sword
In moonlight streaming forth,
At night, when day’s first hour
Reflects the North.
From o’er the threshold
Seek and you will see;
I — am that is,
My sword will wield for me.

This is one of the easier ones to figure out, but We'll get to that eventually. Here, I'll post a snippet of one of the later ones.


Tell me what we call coward (in at)

Then when you have worked out that,

You’ll find your heart’s desire,

By adding a backward liar.

You have no idea what that refers to, do you? I won't tell you. You'll have to wait 18 books for the answer.

Anywho, sidetrack. Our story begins:


It was the start of the Summer of the Late Rose. Mossflower country shimmered gently in a peaceful haze, bathing delicately at each dew-laden dawn, blossoming through high sunny noontides, languishing in each crimson-tinted twilight that heralded the soft darkness of June nights.
Redwall stood foursquare along the marches of the old south border, flanked on two sides by Mossflower Wood’s shaded depths. The other half of the Abbey overlooked undulating sweeps of meadowland, its ancient gate facing the long dusty road on the western perimeter.
From above, it resembled some fabulous dusky jewel, fallen between a green mantle of light silk and dark velvet. The first mice had built the Abbey of red sandstone quarried from pits many miles away in the north-east. The Abbey building was covered across its south face by that type of ivy known as Virginia creeper. The onset of autumn would turn the leaves into a cape of fiery hue, thus adding further glory to the name and legend of Redwall Abbey.

How deliciously Purple, amirite? Another thing about this: This was meant to be a oneshot, but once the money started rolling in kids realized that they loved violence, Jacques shifted the entire continuity to its own alternate universe... thing. That's the point behind the reference to Virginia Creeper. There's a bunch of other stuff, too, but We'll get to it soon... ish.



Chapter 1

The story proper begins with Matthias, the hero of this fine story, running down Great Hall in saandals and a habit that are too big for him. And he's not looking where he's going and trips. He drops his basket of hazlenuts and rolls. Luckily, he's stopped by the shins of Abbot Mortimer, who then gives him a lesson about walking with dignity and stuff. Yes. It's his fault he's dressed in clothes that don't fit. Mortimer takes Matthias away to talk, leaving the basket of nuts for the birds to eat... or not eat, as Jacques added a paragraph about a thrush who thought it was being stealthy, only to be outsmarted by shells. He uses "Twisters" as an expletive-type word.

Matthias and Mortimer head to the Great Hall (not my capitalization), where the tapestry is described in purple. It's apparently very old, and chronicles the history of Redwall. Matthias points out Martin, and Mort goes on about how Martin saved the day from foxes, vermin, and a great wildcat. Apparently, after one too many blows to the head, Martin stopped being a battle-hardened Warrior and became a Monk of Redwall.

One thing of note is that Matthias' entire backstory gets dumped in a single sentence:


You have been like a son to me, ever since you first came to our gates as an orphaned woodland mouse, begging to be taken in.

1: What kind of place is this that an orphan has to beg to be taken in?

2: Sounds like he's been here long enough for you to make habits and sandals for him so he isn't tripping over them. Gawd!

I also like this one:


All the mice took a solemn vow never to harm another living creature, unless it was an enemy that sought to harm our Order by violence.

That sounds a lawyer being really bad at adding a loophole to a contract. Anyway, Morty goes on to say that Redwall mice even get a free pass from predators. He wants Matthias to grow to be a respectable member of the Order, and knows he can do it, and other inspirational mish-mash. He then tells Matthias to go with brother Alf to fish in the pond (what happened to "never harm a living creature?"), because It's his Golden Jubille as Abbot. As Matthias flops off, Mortimer finally gets the clue that he should get some right-fitting sandals.


Chapter 2

Pardon me while I become a 12-year-old again:


The high, warm sun shone down on Cluny the Scourge.

Cluny was coming!

*snicker* This early in the morning? You need to pace yourself.

*Ahem*

Who is this Cluny, you ask? A giant rat who was so big and tough that he fought a pike for no reason. Cluny lost his eye, and the pike lost its life. Also, apparently, some creatures say that Cluny's from Portugal. The audiobook has him with a pitifully hilarious attempt at some sort of Hispanic/Greek/Italian accent. He calls himself "Cluny dee Scud-ooge" He's called "The Scourge" because he uses his tail as a whip. He's got 500 rats following him, and they're riding a hay wagon.



Redtooth, his second-in-command, carried a long pole. This was Cluny’s personal standard. The skull of a ferret was fixed at its top. Cluny had killed the ferret. He feared no living thing.

These last two sentences are unnecessary. I think a kid could figure out that a guy who he fought a pike and killed it wouldn't carry around a skull he found on the ground. Also, Pike are huge compared to rats.


Straight on the panicked horse galloped, past the milestone lodged in the earth at the roadside, heedless of the letters graven in the stone: “Redwall Abbey, fifteen miles.

They're on a horse. Also, Cluny expresses the desire to eat some baby rabbits that are at the roadside.


Cluny was a God of War!

Nah, he'd need two tails for that...


Chapter 3

We're back in Great Hall, where Matthias and Brother Alf have caught a giant grayling for the abbey feast. It's nearly two pounds in weight, which is apparently noteworthy. They had to get Constance the Badger to bring it inside. Badgers: the go-to source for scaring things off displays of strength. We're also introduced to the cook, Friar Hugo, a big fat mouse who holds dandelions in his tail.

Fabulous.

Sidetrack: Are Friars always cooks? I'm still not sure of all the titles you have in an abbey, but Friar sounds like "fry-er," so it sort of works, right?


"Bring the white gooseberry wine! Fetch me some rosemary, thyme, beechnuts and honey, quickly."

I now read Hugo as Leeron from the English dub of Gurren Lagann, and imagine him doing... things... with all that stuff.


"Fresh cream! I need lots of fresh cream! Bring some mint leaves too.”

You're not helping your case, Hugo. We also get this little tidbit:


... combing whiskers, curling tails, shining noses, and the hundred and one other grooming tasks that Redwall mice always performed in preparation for an epic feast.

I leave you to come up with something for that.

And now they open the gates of Redwall and allow all the woodlanders to come enjoy a feast, and we begin with one of Jacques' specialties: describing food. That's what these books are really about. Violence and food. In the interest of time, I'll just go on and list the names of everything:


Raspberry cordial
Peach and elderberry brandy
Apple and mint ice cream
Candied chestnuts
Acorn crunch
Cheddar cheese, plus ten other varieties
Celery
Tender freshwater shrimp garnished with cream and rose leaves (Shrimp are living creatures, too. WTH, Redwall?)
Devilled barley pearls in acorn purée
Apple and carrot chews
Marinated cabbage stalks steeped in creamed white turnip with nutmeg


You hungry yet? Meanwhile, we meet the Churchmouse twins, Tim and Tess, who feel Matthias up while giggling. They had something called "tail rickets" three months ago, and Matthias was involved in curing them. Seriously, it takes three months to make a habit and some sandals?

The abbot accepts gifts from the woodlanders, and quizzes Hugo to make sure they've got enough for the huge crowd. A bunch of otters put on a show for the little ones. Also, what the hell is a sultana? Then we meet Ambrose Spike, a hedgehog magician who pulls stuff out of creatures' ears, makes tails dance like snakes, and pulls shells from the mouths of infants. No I did not make that last one up.


Was it magic?

Of course it was.

I like that line. I really do.

Anyway, at eight o-clock, The feast officially starts. The Abbot says one of the few prayers in the series.


Fur and whisker, tooth and claw,
All who enter by our door.
Nuts and herbs, leaves and fruits,
Berries, tubers, plants and roots,
Silver fish whose life we take
Only for a meal to make.

Who are they praying to? the fish? And what's with the first four lines? Just listing stuff? Color me confused.


Matthias found himself next to Tim and Tess on one paw, and Cornflower Fieldmouse on the other. Cornflower was a quiet young mouse, but undoubtedly very pretty. She had the longest eyelashes Matthias had ever seen, the brightest eyes, the softest fur, the whitest teeth…

Say it with me now: Love interest.

The Abbot wholeheartedly praises Hugo's labor of love, and


Any further speech {i}s drowned by hearty cheers.


Chapter 4
We start with Cluny in a foul temper, because the horse stopped moving. Jacques notes that Cluny is both violent and unpredictable. He calls up Skullface, the expendable mook of the chapter, to bite the horse on the ass to get it moving again. Whan Skullface mentions that that would be, oh, I dunno, suicinde, he gets whipped.


“Mutiny, insubordination!” Cluny roared. “By the teeth of hell, I’ll flay you into mangy dollrags.”

There is also mentioned a Drivers' seat, another remnant of the pre-continuity drift era.


Skullface performed a frantic leap. He landed on the horse’s back. The terrified animal did not wait for the rat to bite. As soon as it felt the loathsome scratching weight descend on its exposed haunches, it gave a loud panicked whinny and bucked. Spurred on by the energy of fright it careered off like a runaway juggernaut. Bitch!

Sorry. Anyway, Skullface falls to his doom. See? Expendable mook.


“Tell the devil Cluny sent you, Skullface!”

That's two mentions of the devil (one I didn't include) and one mention of hell.


Chapter 5


Down in Cavern Hole the great feast had slackened off.

So had a lot of belts!

Doh-Ho-Ho!

Mortimer sends Hugo to discreetly deliver some food to the Churchmouse family. Who apparently live in poverty in the woods when they'd totally be allowed to live at Redwall till they and have all the food they want till they die.

Cornflower and Matthias hit it off, largely because Tim and Tess are really cute. No, seriously. Colin Vole (who I remember being very annoyed at) remarks that they act like a married couple.


Brother Alf reprimanded him sharply. “Here now, you keep a latch on that silly tongue of yours, Colin Vole! Don’t you know that someday Matthias will be a Redwall mouse? And don’t let me hear you slandering young Cornflower. She’s a decent mouse from a good family. Mark my words, Master Vole, I could say a thing or two to your mum and dad. Only last evening I saw you playing ‘catch the bulrush’ with that young harvest mouse. What was her name now?”

So... Not only does he say that Matthias can't get married and be a mouse of Redwall at the same time. He says that Cornflower is not a slut, and mocks Colin for playing with a girl? Logical progression? What's that? How did I understand this when I was little? Sorry for the Sidetrack.

Mortimer calls Matthias over, hands him a staff and asks him to go with Constance to escort the Churchmice home.


The young mouse needed no second bidding. Drawing himself up to his full height, he saluted in a smart military fashion. “Leave it to me, Father Abbot. Old Constance is a bit slow-thinking. I’ll take complete responsibility.”

The Abbot shook with silent laughter as he watched Matthias march off with a soldier-like swagger.

Flip flop, flip flop; he tripped and fell flat on his tail.

What can possibly go wrong? Also:


Fancy Cornflower’s family living so close to the Churchmouse brood! Matthias was only too glad to offer them a lift home.

Would Miss Cornflower like to sit next to him?

She most certainly would!

So he's going to guard the cart from the inside. Makes perfect sense.


Cornflower’s parents sat inside the cart, her mum helping Mrs. Churchmouse with the little ones, while her dad chatted away with John Churchmouse as they shared a pipe of old bracken twist.

Smoking? Srsly? This is now a YA book.

Hugo gives Mrs. Churchmouse a big sack of "tablecloths" that she "loaned" the abbey. Hey, Jacques can be subtle when he wants to be. Constance pulls the cart along, and Matthias waves to Methuselah, who as his name implies, is remarkably old. What, could his parents see the future or something? That's 4 male mice whose names begin with M. This will not go away anytime soon, I assure you.

We actually get a glimpse into Cornflower's head, while she dozes on Matthias' shoulder and considers what this "Summer of the Late Rose" means.


Normally it was in full red flower by now, but this year, for some unknown reason, it had chosen to flower late. It was covered in dormant young rosebuds, even now, well into June — a thing that happened only infrequently, and usually heralded an extra-long hot summer. Old Methuselah could only remember three other such summers in his long lifetime.

History. I hate it, but I just got reminded of something that I'll keep shut up for now. I'll just say that having read all of the books, I can tell he was obviously planning to continue.


The old cart rolled on gently, down the long dusty road. They were now over halfway to the ruined Church of St. Ninian where John Churchmouse lived, as had his father, grandfather and great-grandfather before him.

Ditto this.


Matthias had fallen into a deep slumber. Even Constance was unable to stop her eyelids drooping.

Hey, don't sleep and... pull carts.


Suddenly, and without warning, they were roused by the thunder of hooves.

A horse!? Oh dear...

Luckily, she finds a hole in the hedge (there was a hedge?) to push the cart into, while Matthias gets a good look at Cluny laughing madly as the cart thunders by.

Also:


“What in heaven was it?”

“What in hell, more like.”

Mentions of Heaven et. al: 1

Mentions of Hell et. al: 4


"Aye, and that one on the back! He looked like the Devil himself.”

Mentions of Hell et. al: 5

They decide to head back to the Abbey instead of continuing after the cart.


Chapter 6


The horse had gotten away safely.

... never to be seen again. What happened? Well:


Bolting recklessly from side to side down the road, the blinkered animal failed to see the twin stone gateposts on its right — skidding crazily, the cart smashed into the uprights. There was a loud splintering of shafts as the horse careered onwards, trailing in its wake reins, tracers and shattered timber.

Note that Cluny leapt straight over the ditch, while the cart falls in.


“Redtooth! Darkclaw! Report to me or I’ll have your skulls for skittles.”

Taste the Rainbow (is shot)

The two he calls come and give a status report. A bunch of people died, some are injured and...


“Old Wormtail has lost a paw."

Lol Jacques can see the future! Anyway, Cluny cares not and calls for an assembly.


“Right, [forum inappropriate word that means "chicken"] your lugs up and listen to me,” Cluny snarled. “First, we’ve got to find out where we have docked. Let’s take a bearing on this place.”

Where'd Cluny learn to speak Facebook Pirate?


"Cheesethief!”

... There's a rat named Cheesethief.

He also sends a crew of fity to recruit more soldiers for his cause.


Take fifty soldiers and see if you can round up any rats that know the lie of the land... don’t stand for arguments. Smash their dens up so they won’t have homes to worry about. If any refuse to join up, then kill them there and then. Understood?

Cluny does not screw around.


Chapter 7


Matthias had never stayed up all night in his life. He was just a bit tired, but strangely excited. Great events seemed to have been set in motion by his news.

That's how it is when you're the main character, kid. Get used to it.

The Abbot calls a meeting of elders, and lets Constance and Matthias relate their tale. Constance's grandfather apparently knew a sea rat, and she deduces that those rats were as well. There's also this:


"My badger senses told me right off that these were very bad and evil rats."


The badger’s statement caused uproar and shouts of "Nonsense. Pure speculation" and "That’s right! Give a rat a bad name!"

Make your own Spider-Man joke. I also find it interesting how that was received. Nowadays, The Redwallers are convinced that all rats are of the "lolmurder" mentality until proven otherwise.

Matthias defends Constance, saying that one of them had a ferret's skull on a pole, and that gets Mortimer's attention. He asks Matthias to describe the rat and deduces that this was none other than Cluny the Scourge. Everybody laughs because Cluny is just a legend, the kind of boogeyman who "gets" kids that misbehave. Mortimer is not pleased, and we get this line that I chuckled at:


Sister Clemence stood up smiling. She spread her paws wide. "Perhaps Cluny is coming to get us for staying up late."

Everyone loses it, and Constance has to scare them all back into seriousness.


"I’ve never seen such a pack of empty-headed ninnies. You should all be ashamed of yourselves, giggling like silly little otter cubs that have caught a beetle. I never thought I’d live to see the Elders of Redwall acting in this way. Now you listen to me. Take heed of what your Father Abbot has to say. The next creature who utters one squeak will answer to me. Understand?"


The badger bowed low in a dignified manner, gesturing with her massive blunt paw. "The floor is yours, Father Abbot."

I love you Constance. Never change.

Oh, before I continue, I should tell you that in there was a Redwall cartoon, which, despite its faults and a bit of deviation from the book, actually gave Matthias a backstory; Cluny and crew attacked his village and killed everyone except him and his sister, and she dies by falling over before they can enter Redwall. But that was all worthless in the long run, because that plot point was never brought up again in the TV series anyway.

Aaanywho.... Mortimer sends for Brother Methuselah, and Matthias again considers being the protagonist.


All in the space of a night events had moved from festivity to a crisis, and he, Matthias, had taken a major role in both. First the big grayling, then the sighting of the cart; large happenings for a small mouse.

Methuselah Arrives with a book of history that he recorded.


"Hmm, hmm, me Lord Abbot Cedric. It is Cedric, isn’t it? Oh botheration, you’ll be the new Abbot, Mortimer, the one who came after Cedric. Oh dear me, I see so many of them come and go, you know."

It's funny because he's old.

There are a ton of stories of the stuff that Cluny did. Collapsing mines, burning down farmhouses, eating piglets alive (this one is actually pretty scary) , and spreading disease. A dog told him that he caused a stampede of cows. We never hear of cows, pigs, or dogs again. Everyone starts to panic now, and when someone asks the obligatory "What are we gonna do?"


Matthias sprang to the middle of the floor brandishing his staff in a way that surprised even him.

"Do?" he cried. "I’ll tell you what we’ll do. We’ll be ready."


Chapter 8


Cluny the Scourge was having nightmares.

Oh, I remember this...


The Warlord thrashed about, killing, conquering and laying waste to all in his dream.


Then the phantom figure appeared.... Cluny went like a bat out of hell.

Mentions of Hell et. al: 6

Cluny's dream continues, and eventually, the phantom chases Cluny about and stabs him in the back with his giant manly drill wang sword.


Bong!


The loud toll of the distant Joseph Bell brought Cluny whirling back from the realms of nightmare to cold reality.


He shivered, wiping the sweat from his fur with a shaky paw. Saved by the bell.

It's alright.

The scavenging party proves how idiotic they are by comes back with... Just look that this:


A few dead beetles, two large earthworms, some unidentifiable vegetation and the pitiful carcass of a long-dead sparrow.

Naturally, Cluny is perfectly forgiving. It's not like they know the lay of the land or anything. He can't really fault them.

...

Nah, he's pissed.


Cluny bashed their heads together... "Get me meat. Tender, young, red meat! Next time you bring me rubbish like this, I’ll spit the pair of you and have you roasted in your own juice. Is that clear?"

Apparently, I am still a twelve-year-old, because I took that entire thing out of context.

Frogblood and Scumnose come back with the new recruits, and Cluny is genuinely pleased. He has them rank up and Redtooth reads them their terms. When Redtooth gets to this line:


"Now, if any one, two, or a group, or even all of you together want to try and beat Cluny and lead the horde, this is your chance."

Cluny all-out attacks the group of them just to show them who's boss.


"No guts, eh? Ha, it’s just as well! I don’t want dead ’uns on my claws before I find a proper battle for you to fight. And make no mistake, when the right time comes I’ll see you fight, aye, and die too. Now, raise your weapons and let’s see if you know who your master is."


A motley collection of evil-looking implements was framed by the cloudless sky as wild cries rang out from the newly-inducted recruits.


"Cluny, Cluny, Cluny the Scourge!"

It's about to get real up in here.


Chapter 9

Mortimer and Constance, walk through the grounds in contemplative silence, considering the safety of Redwall. Jacques devotes a paragraph to talking about the kinds of stuff they grow at Redwall. Boring. Mortimer mentions how Deus Ex Machina has saved Redwall in the past, but Constance remains cynical about the whole thing. Oh, come on, don't you know what kind of world you live in? Oh wait, this is pre- continuity drift. Carry on.

Meanwhile, Matthias is eating a breakfast of nutbread, apples and goatsmilk. We never hear of goats again. Cornflower's still asleep. That either means she's asleep in Cavern Hole, or Matthias brought his breakfast to Cornflower. Otherwise there's no real reason to mention that she's around sleeping. Jacques even notes that this was a early breakfast, meaning that most everyone is asleep anyway. He spends even more time considering what it means to be the hero, when Methuselah ninjas his way there.


“Eat heartily, Matthias. No point in facing trouble on an empty stomach. Feed the body, nourish the mind.”

I have to give Matthias props here; he knows that the borderline-senile always give good advice, and seeks Methuselah's counsel. Methy notes that fighting is the only sensible thing to do if Cluny makes his way to Redwall.


“It is written in the great chronicle of Redwall that Martin was very young to be such a warrior. He could have been the same age as yourself, Matthias. Like you, he was impulsive and had a great quality of youthful innocence about him when he first came to our Abbey.”

There's a grating historical inaccuracy here, which will be obvious once we get to "Mossflower".


“Why do you tell all this to me, Brother Methuselah?”


“Because, Matthias … because he was very like you!”

Foreshadowing....


Before the young mouse could question the old one further, the Joseph Bell tolled out a warning.


Sandals flapping,

No comment.


Matthias dashed out into the grounds, nearly colliding with the Abbot and Constance, who, like everyone else, were heading for the gatehouse.

What's the issue? Apparently, Brothers Rufus and George had a run-in with one of Cluny's rats, who pretended he was injured to try to get in, later on requesting aid to his buddies trapped underneath a cart. Being not born yesterday, Rufus and George ask how many he was traveling with.


“Oh, a couple of hundred,” came the glib reply.

Rats are stupid.

Showing intelligence not usually available to NPCs, they wondered if all two-hundred were trapped in this cart. The rat changes the subject and asks to come in for food. He almost gets let in, but when they ask for him to surrender his weapon, he goes for the sneak attack only for Rufus to prove himself among the most badass NPCs ever written. Then, seeing as he's up against two competent mouse fighters (they're fighters? I guess they teach you the quarterstaff once you become a mouse of Redwall \o_O/), he curses them out, announces that he has a whole army waiting, and says he's going to get Cluny. This can only end well.

Naturally, Mrs. Churchmouse, the only old married woman worth noting, begins to cry, because he house has been taken over by rats. Her husband says that at least they're safe at Redwall, and Matthias questions the safety of everyone else living in the woods. Ambrose Spike is sent out out to go warn everyone.


"Spike’ll come to no harm. Once he curls up, there’s nothing can touch him.”

Constance just Jinxed it, didn't she >:|

Mortimer tells everyone to head inside, but Matthias suggests to put a guard on the walls. Sister Clemence, old church lady that she is, tells Matthias to respect his elders, but Mortimer shows common sense, noting that "none of us too old to learn,” and goes with Matthias' plan.

Anyway, John Churchmouse rings the bell to tell everyone to come in to Redwall (so why bother send out Ambrose then?) Brother Methuselah, who apparently only got his 17th level of monk late in life, translates for everyone that enters the Abbey who doesn't speak... Common, I guess? Meanwhile, Matthias and a few others are on Guard Duty.


Despite the heat, Matthias had ordered all the mice to put on their hoods. It served a double purpose, to shield their eyes from the sun and create a camouflage effect.

... What?


The first mice had built the Abbey of red sandstone....


dark greeny-brown of the order....


lighter green of a novice....


camouflage effect.

No, sorry. Try again.

Constance notes that the birds have stopped singing. No grasshoppers or anything. And the Joseph Bell rings out.


John Churchmouse shouted from his position high in the belfry, “They’re coming, down the road! I can see them. I can see them!”


Chapter 10

Cluny's army is here. Fangburn, the rat who Rufus and George encountered, tries to lighten the chief's modd, but gets called out for the idiot he is for loseing them the element of surprise. So now they need a show of force.


His long ragged black cloak was made of batwings, fastened at the throat with a mole skull. The immense war helmet he wore had the plumes of a blackbird and the horns of a stag beetle adorning it. From beneath the slanted visor his one eye glared viciously out at the Abbey before him.

Every evil warlord needs his Badass Armor.

Redtooth acts as Cluny's mouthpiece again, asking for a parley. Redtooth and Cluny get selected to enter, provided they drop their weapons and Cluny tie his tail around his middle. Also, Cluny has a poison spike on the end of his tail, just because it's awesome. Redtooth shows concern about the badger.


Cluny answered quietly out of the side of his mouth, “Don’t worry, I’ve been watching her. A real big country bumpkin."

After they enter, Matthias says they don't need too many guards, but the Redwall mice don't listen, so Cluny has to scare them off.

They head to Cavern Hole to have their chat, and Cluny misunderstands Matthias' protagonist power.


Cluny could sense hostility emanating from the young mouse who flip-flopped behind him in overlarge sandals.

~sigh~


Strange for one so young to be counted as a captain, he thought.


He allowed himself a peek at the future. One day this would be called Cluny’s Castle. He liked the sound of that. Secure from attack, living off the fat of the land, in his mind’s eye he saw it all: those mice and the woodland creatures enslaved, living just to serve him. He would hold sway as far as the eye could see; power; an end to his rovings; a dream come true; King Cluny!

Cornflower comes in with Drinks, and Matthias shoos her off.


Redtooth nudged Cluny. “Cornflower, eh. Satan’s nose, she’s a pretty little one for you!”

Mentions of Hell et. al: 7


Cluny remained silent. He stood insolently watching Cornflower set the table in Cavern Hole. A pretty one indeed!

She's the equivalent of a thirteen-year-old girl. Furthermore, rats and mice are genetically incompatible. That's two kinds of wrong straight off the bat.

Mortimer asks Cluny his business, and Cluny responds tells them to surrender. Matthias rightly tells him to GTFO. Mortimer apologizes about Matthias and then tells them that he's willing to provide food, clothing, and medical attention. Cluny interrupts and tells Redtooth to read them the articles.


“These are the articles of surrender to be obeyed by all creatures who come under the claw of Cluny the Scourge or any of his commanders.



One: surrender will be total and unconditional.


Two: Cluny will execute the leaders of all who choose to oppose him.


Three: all property conquered will belong solely to Cluny the Scourge. This includes homes, food, crops, land and additionally all creatures dwelling on said property: they shall be owned by Cluny—”

He's interrupted by Matthias' staff destroying the scroll. He goes after Matthias, but Constance smacks him out of midair. Mortimer asks her to let him up, reminding her of the law of hospitality.

Then he gets mad.


“I will not need until tomorrow, rat. You can have my answer now. How dare you come here with your robber band to read articles of death and slavery to me? I tell you that neither you nor your army will ever set paw or claw inside Redwall, not while I or any of my creatures have breath in our bodies to fight and resist you. That is my solemn word.”

Mortimer, I will love you when Matthias finally gets some proper slippers.


Cluny sneered and turned on his heel. Followed by Redtooth, he stamped out. On the stairs between Cavern Hole and Great Hall he stopped and turned, his cold voice echoing between both chambers, “Then die, all of you: every male, female, and young one. You have refused my terms. Now you will suffer the punishment of Cluny. You will beg on your knees for death to come swiftly, but I shall make your torment loud and long before you die!”

Constance doesn't like that:


Exerting the full strength of a female badger, she lifted the massive Cavern Hole dining table. It was a huge solid oaken thing that no dozen mice could even move. Dishes clattered and food spilled as Constance heaved the table above her head. Her voice was a roar.


“Get out, rats! Leave this Abbey! I’m weary of your voices. Hurry before I break the laws of hospitality and ask the Abbot’s pardon later. Go, while you still have skulls.”

I love you Constance.

On his way out, Cluny notices Martin on the tapestry. and Matthiasgives him a history lesson.


“This is Martin the Warrior. He founded our Order, and I’ll tell you something else, rat. Martin was the bravest mouse that ever lived. If he were here today he’d just take up his big sword and send you and all your bullies packing. Those of you he didn’t chop up into crow meat.”

I don't even know what to say to this. It's just... ugh. I don't like it. Anyway, Cluny leaves without giving any more problems, noting that Martin the Warrior is the mouse raped attacked him through his nightmares. Constance continues to be awesome by tossing the scroll of articles- filled with rotten food, too- right into Redtooth's face and then disappearing like a shadow.


Chapter 11

Late at night, Brother Alf sees something in the bushes. Matthias recognizes it as Ambrose Spike. He got needlessly injured because they sent him out there when they were already rigning the bell to tell everyone that s**t was about to go down. Constance pulls an Ackbar and says that they should be wary of traps. Matthias gets an idea of how to get Ambrose in.


Brother Alf watched the little figure flip-flopping off.

Would someone like to count how many times it's been referenced that Matthias' sandals are too big? Because I'm getting tired of reading it.

Anyway, Matthias comes back with... MOLES!!!! They are awesome! With their accents and their common sense and their accents and their diggin rhymes and their accents and... their accents...


Their leader glanced out at the hedgehog. He scratched some hasty calculations on the wall with his claw.


“Oi I think we can get yon ’edgepig back, sur. You’m get us outen the gate and stan’ watch.”


Turning to his team, the Foremole (for that was his official title) began discussing tunnel width, coupled with reverse prickle drag, forward traction and all the other specialist details that are routine to the average qualified tunnel-mole.

MOLES DO MATH!!!

They stand guard outside the gate while one mole goes under to see about the soil.


“Harr, he’m be noice an’ soft, sur. Baint no rock nor root to stop us’ns, straight furrer we’m a-thinking.”


“Oi’ll dig ahead, you’m woiden workin’s. Gaffer and Marge, foller up a-shorin.” He tugged his snout respectfully to Matthias and Constance. “You’m gennelbeast bide by ’ere ’til us back.”

I am twelve again, and not in the perverted way.


They watched the ground humping...

Okay, now I'm twelve again in the perverted way. The moles come up right under Ambrose and drag him in through the underground. Matthias tries to help, but Foremole brushes him off.


“Nay, nay, you uns on’y get yer paws durted.”

Ambrose is brought to the infirmary and attended by Mortimer.


A hasty diagnosis revealed that the hedgehog was suffering from a long jagged wound that ran from the back of his ear to the tip of his paw.

... "Diagnosis?" In this context, that seems like too much. But still... ouch.


“D’you think he’ll live, Father Abbot?”


The Abbot chuckled quietly. He cleaned the long ugly wound and applied a poultice of herbs.


“No cause for alarm, Brother Alf. Ambrose Spike is made of leather and needles. Tough as a boulder, this old ruffian is. Look, he’s beginning to come around already.”

He does, and the first thing he asks for? Liquor. Can't blame him. Anyway, he recounts his tale:


“It must have been near noon when I stopped at Vole Bank. I told the Voles the bad news, and blow me if that little ninny Colin Vole didn’t go to shrieking and screaming all over the place as to how they’d all be murdered in their beds."

That's why I said I didn't like Colin. His screams alert some foraging rats, and they take Colin and his family captive, stab Ambrose with a churchyard spike railing... thing... and leave him to die because he's too spiky to eat.


"Er, is there any more left in that jug? This wound’s giving me jip. I need ale for medicinal purposes, Father Abbot.”

Once again. Can't blame him.

Matthias is about to mount a rescue mission, but the Abbot reads his mind and straigh-up say "no." Once again, Matti sees that they're right and he was being stupid. But he still feels bad because he can't do anything about Colin. He can't sleep that night, so wanders off to talk to Martin.


“Oh Martin, what would you have done in my place? I know that I’m only a young mouse, a novice, not even a proper Redwall member yet, but once you were young too. I know what you would have done. You’d have buckled on your armor, picked up your mighty sword, gone down to that church and battled with the rats until they released the Voles or perished beneath your blade. But alas, those days are gone. I have no magic sword to aid me, only the advice of my elders and betters, to which I must listen.”

Wow. I never remembered Matthias being so... balanced. Most of the other main characters throughout the books are all bravery and badass, but he shows wisdom and humility at the same time.


Looking back down to himself in his baggy green robes and oversized sandals,

~sigh~


Matthias felt hot tears of shame and frustration spilling from his eyes and dripping on his young whiskers. Unable to stop himself, he wept freely. The soft touch of a gentle paw on his back caused him to look around. It was Cornflower.

Oh, balls. Luckily, Cornflower isn't there to laugh, but to give him a pep talk that I just have to quote.


“Matthias, don’t be ashamed, I know why you cry and grieve. It is because you are kind and good, not a hard-hearted pitiless rat like Cluny. Please listen to me. Even the strongest and bravest must sometimes weep. It shows they have a great heart, one that can feel compassion for others. You are brave, Matthias. Already you have done great things for one so young. I am only a simple country-bred fieldmouse, but even I can see the courage and leadership in you. A burning brand shows the way, and each day your flame grows brighter. There is none like you, Matthias. You have the sign of greatness upon you. One day Redwall and all the land will be indebted to you. Matthias, you are a true Warrior.”

Then, she takes off her headband- Yellow, with blue cornflowers on it- and ties it about his arm.

*squee*


Chapter 12

We're back at St. Ninian's church, where Cluny mulls about planning, paying no attention to the Voles.


What thoughts occupied the dark devious mind of Cluny the Scourge?

He obviously wants Martin to come by with his great throbbing... sword.


“Go and get Shadow. Bring him here to me.”

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2171/2533427433_0b03716c68.jpg

I am silly.


The Chief had a plan. Like all of his schemes it would be cunningly simple and wickedly brilliant. There was no better general than Cluny when it came to strategy.

I haven't read this book in a while, but I have the feeling that I'll have to sarcastically quote this line several times before I finish this book.


Shadow had been with Cluny for many years. Nobody was sure if he was rat or weasel, or even a bit of both.

*Goes to check Wikipedia*

Yeah, That's not possible.


He was very lithe and wiry, and his long sinewy body was covered in sleek, black fur. There was no hint of another color in his coat; it was blacker than moonless midnight. His eyes were strangely slanted, black without any brightness in them. The eyes of Shadow were like those of a dead thing.

I wish I had something witty to say to that.

Cluny says he wants Shadow to climb the Abbey walls, and proceeds to give him perfect directions to Great Hall.


"... Walk in, turn around, and on the left wall facing you is a long tapestry covered in pictures and designs. Now listen carefully. In the bottom right- hand corner of that tapestry is a picture of a mouse dressed in armor, leaning on a big sword. I want it! Cut it, rip it, or tear it out, but get it for me. I must have it! Don’t come back without it, Shadow."


...


Fangburn whispered to Cheesethief, “What use is a picture of a mouse to the Chief?”

Remember what was he doing his entire introductory chapter? He probably goes through a lot of cloth. Just sayin'.


Cluny heard. He came to the edge of the pulpit. Grasping the sides of the lectern he surveyed his small congregation like some satanic minister.

Mentions of Hell et. al: 8


"Ah, Brother Fangburn, let me explain. I will tell you why it is that you and all your kind will forever remain servants, while I shall always be the master. Did you not see the faces of those mice today? The mere mention of Martin the Warrior sends them into ecstasies."

I've made far too many sex jokes at this point in the review, so I'm leaving this one alone.


"Martin is some sort of angel; I’m the opposite."

Mentions of Heaven et. al: 2

Mentions of Hell et. al: 9? Okay, 8.5

So now it's pretty obvious what's up: Cluny's going to attack Redwall's morale by stealing Martin away.

Cluny’s tail banged down on the rotting lectern, smashing it into several fragments.


“Bring that picture back here to me. Do this, and your reward will be great when I sit on the Abbot’s chair in Redwall Abbey. But fail me, and your screams will be heard far beyond the woodland and meadows!”

That would have been a lot more threatening if it didn't involve "woodland and meadows."



Chapter 13

Back at Redwall, everyone's taking stock of the food stores. Ambrose reflects on the mice not letting him drink himself into a stupor, and is interrupted by baby moles who ask him where to put stuff. Padding!

Matthias and Constance are busy training the woodlanders, who all have certain skills that they're used to. Otters are slingmasters, and fieldmice have mad arrow skillz. Matthias decides to teach some of the Redwall mice how to use the quarterstaff.


He had discovered in himself a natural skill with the long ash pole.

My personal theory is that Matthias had levels in Monk. I mean, in the animated series, Matti had mad hops.

Of course, that doesn't stop him from harassing the n00bs into attacking him.


“Keep that head guarded, Brother Anthony!”


Thwack!


“I warned you, Brother! Now look out, I’m coming after you again.”

But the harshness pays off... sort of.


“No, no! Don’t just stand there, Brother! Defend yourself! Hit out at me.”


Thwack, crack!

And down Matti goes. Anthony gets recruited for Constance's cudgel and wrestling class. There's also a discussion of the lack of lethal weapons in the Abbey.


“Yes, he’s very strong, but I do wish that we had some real weapons of war — swords and daggers and such like. We won’t kill many rats with wooden staves.”

“Maybe not,” the badger replied. “But you must remember that we are here to defend, not to attack or kill.”

Matthias threw down his staff. He took a dipper of water from an oaken pail, drinking deeply, then splashing the remains over his aching head.

“A wise observation, Constance, but you try telling that to Cluny and his horde. See how far you get.”

At lunch, Matthias bugs Cornflower for a bit before heading over to bond with Methuselah some more. Methuselah, not being an idiot, knows that Matthias wants to find Martin's tomb, because that's where the sword is likely to be.


“That is a thing no creature knows. For many long years now I have puzzled and pored over ancient manuscripts, translating, following hidden trails, always with the same result: nothing. I have even used my gift of tongues, speaking to the bees and others who can go into places too small for us, but always it is the same — rumors, legends and old mouse tales.”

Matthias is about to give up hope, when Methuselah relates an old tale about a sparrow-hawk who claims that the Sparrows stole "something" from the mice of Redwall. Problem: the sparrows live at the top of the Abbey, and as such, it would be necessary to climb up the walls. Which begs the question of how the abbey was built, without steps that led to the top, but whatever, plot is plot.


Chapter 14 and the update will be in the next post, because there's too many characters in this post right now.

John Cribati
2012-03-22, 05:18 PM
Chapter 14

Back to Cluny, who's heading to Redwall with Ragear and Shadow. Ragear's proud that he's been selected, but we're told that Cluny just needed a fall guy in case things went bad. Cluny goes off to do something, leaving Ragear and Shadow alone. And it's...


“Nice drops of rain, eh, Shadow? Good for the grass. Blow me, these walls are pretty high. I’m glad it’s you climbing them and not me. I’d never make it. Too fat, hahaha.”


Ragear’s voice trailed off. He fumbled with his whiskers, wilting beneath the basilisk stare of Shadow’s dead black eyes. He shuddered and fell silent.

Awkward.

Anyway, Cluny returns, having discovered that the mice on sentry duty are all fast asleep. Shadow gets to climbing the wall. When he gets to the top...


Friar Hugo mumbled gently in his sleep, and moved his head so that his cowl slid off. Drizzle fell upon the fat friar’s face, threatening to wake him. Gently as a night breeze, Shadow replaced the hood.

Ain't that cute?

...

BUT IT'S WRONG!!!!

What is my problem?

Shadow makes his way into Great Hall, slamming the door by accident, but thankfully not waking anyone. He finds the tapestry, and Jacques gives us this...


So this was the picture of the warrior mouse that Cluny lusted after.

See? Even he realizes all of this homoerotic subtext between Martin and Cluny. He did it on purpose.

Shadow starts biting Martin out of the tapestry.


Matthias tossed and turned in his bed, exhausted, but unable to sleep. His mind revolved around a host of problems and schemes: the sword, Martin’s grave, defense of the Abbey, Cornflower.

Wet Sweet dreams, Matti.


He was somewhere in a long deserted room, not unlike Great Hall. A voice called to him, “Matthias.”


“Oh, go away,” the young mouse muttered drowsily. “Get someone else. I’m tired.”


But the voice persisted, boring into his mind. “Matthias, Matthias, I need you.”

... The depths to which my mind is willing to sink.

Of course, it's Martin, trying to get Matthias to stop Shadow from stealing him. When Matthias figures this out, he heads there, tripping down the steps and getting up just in time to see Shadow make off with Martin.


Bowling his body into a forward roll, he knocked Matthias down like a skittle.

Shadow used Rollout! It's Super Effective!

Matthias shouts a warning, and Constance blocks off one section of the stairs to the ramparts, forcing Shadow to waste time changing direction. Then he grabs Shadow's legs, preventing him from climbing the steps... And Shadow kicks him in the head several times, knocking him out.


“Surrender, rat, I’ve got you,” cried Mr. Fieldmouse as he grabbed hold of the thief. But, rummaging in his pouch to free the rope, Shadow’s claw had closed on the handle of his dagger.

Shadow had a dagger, but chose to cut the tapestry out with his teeth. Yeah.


He drew it out swiftly and drove it twice into the fieldmouse’s unprotected body.

Constance comes in and Shadow faces her, but she disarms him in a single blow. Right over the wall and outside of the Abbey. Good work.


“Cluny, I’m hurt, help me,” he gasped.


The piece of tapestry lay upon the road. Cluny snatched it, up eagerly. Behind him he could hear the gatehouse bolts being withdrawn amid the shouts of angry mice. Ruthlessly he kicked at Shadow’s broken body.


“Get up and run for it or stay there, fool. I don’t carry cripples or bunglers.”

Dude... Not cool.

Cluny gets away, naturally, Ragear isn't so lucky. There's a ditch that he can't leap, and so he has to go a different way. Matthias doesn't even know what happened. He thinks Shadow still has the tapestry.


His flat black eyes clouding over, Shadow watched Matthias. Laconically he spoke. His voice was strangely calm. “Too late, mouse. Martin is with Cluny now.”


It was the last thing Shadow ever said. He gave one final shudder and lay dead.

Good riddance.


Chapter 15

Morty's in a pretty bad mood due to last night's events. But he realizes he's being too harsh and settles down again. Matthias comes in with good news: Cornflower's dad is alright. Matthias's own injuries are mentioned (IE, he was kicked repeatedly in the face by a rat, and logically speaking must have only narrowly escaped getting his neck snapped), but he shrugs it off to put on a brave face for everyone else. Methuselah sees through his charade, and the two of them spend a bit of time staring at the place in the tapestry where Martin used to be. He goes off to bed, making small talk with Cornflower on the way. When he finally gets to his room:


Matthias staggered weakly into his room — but the moment he closed the door he became a different mouse. With bright eager eyes he groped under his bed and brought forth the waist pouch that had belonged to Shadow. Tucking the long dagger into his belt, he wrapped the climbing rope around his shoulder and said aloud to himself, “Right, Cluny, you and I have a score to settle.”

So... if I get this right. He was actually feeling good all along, but pretended that he was feeling bad and pretending to feel good. Yo dawg.

He rappels down the wall with Shadow's rope and dagger.


He had imagined the descent would be very difficult, and surprised himself by handling it with ease, his confidence growing as he slid swiftly and noiselessly to the fern-covered ground.

In a non-magical world, Monks are kind of awesome.


Chapter 16

Meanwhile, at Cluny's camp, preparations were being made. Sharpening weapons, pulling up planks to build things, collecting slingstones and...


while some coiled ropes about their bodies.

I'm sure that this serves some sort of purpose. I just can't see what it is.


Inside the church Cluny sat up in the choir loft, the image of barbaric authority. He held the scourging tail in one claw, while gripped in the other was his

O_O


war standard,

Oh. Okay.

Cluny's got the Voles tied up and at his mercy, gloating to them about how great he is now that he's got Martin's power behind him. And no, I will not stop with the Martin x Cluny jokes. Because they're too much fun.

Mrs Vole comes up with a Proto-Kamina speech about Cluny never being able to enslave the Spirits of the Redwallers; Cluny responds that he intends to kill them. He has the voles dragged off and Redtooth comes in to say the army is ready. I want to note how Jacques describes the different critters:


black rats, brown rats, grey rats, piebald rats, skulking weasels, furtive stoats and sinuous ferrets

... what the hell is piebald?

Anyway, after a scene that makes me imagine that there's a cheerleading section in this army, they begin marching on to Redwall.


Chapter 17

Meanwhile, Ragear is lost. Because rats are stupid. He sees Matthias out in the woods and starts tailing him (badly; Matthias is almost instantly aware that he's being followed), making up a story to tell Cluny.


“There was six of ’em, Chief, they tried surrounding me, but I fought like a devil! Then I says to meself, Ragear, says I, you’d better capture this last one and fetch him back for the Chief to question.” Then Cluny’ll say to me, “Ragear, good old Ragear, I knew I could depend on you. Why d’you suppose I took you along in the first place? Mangefur, bring food and wine for my old pal, Ragear the Brave.” Ha, yes, then I’ll pat the Chief on the back and say, “By Satan’s whiskers, you old rodent! Have you never thought of retiring and letting me lead the horde? Why, with a gallant warrior like me in comm—”

Mentions of Hell et. al: 10.5

Thankfully, Matthias interrupts Ragear's fanfic with a tree branch to the head. He ties up the unconscious rat and moves on.


Humming a tune beneath his breath, he strode out with a will, almost breaking from the cover of the trees straight out into the flat meadowland.

I'd bet he was humming This Tune (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u0G12EBW4KY).

Anyway, Matthias reaches the church yard, where there are rats about patrolling.

And speaking of Trolling, this is where one of my all-time favorite characters shows up:


The young mouse spoke his thoughts aloud. “Hmm, this could present a little problem.”

A strange voice answered him. “Problem, a little problem? Well at least it’s not a fully-grown adult problem.”

Matthias squeaked aloud with fright. Whirling about, he looked for the source of the mystery voice.

There was no one about. Taking a grip of himself, he squared his shoulders and called out boldly: “Come out here this instant and show yourself!”

The voice answered. It seemed to come from directly in front of him. “Show m’self indeed! How many pairs of eyes d’you want, young feller, eh, eh? Fine state of affairs, bless m’soul! What, what!”

Seriously, the guy is essentially a walking trollface.


“Basil Stag Hare at your service, sir! Expert scout, hindleg fighter, wilderness guide and camouflage specialist, ahem, liberator of tender young crops, carrots, lettuce and other such strange beasts. Pray tell me whom I have the pleasure of addressing, and please state the nature of your little problem.”

We also get a description for virtually every other hare in the series:


Matthias decided the peculiar hare was either slightly mad or tipsy.

Basil finds Matthias' name rather odd, and Matthias shoots back with what is essentially "I'm rubber, you're glue." In response:


“Ah well, Hare’s the family name, don’t y’know. My parents named me Basil, though the old mater wanted me to be called Columbine Agnes. Always longed for a young lass, she did.”

...

“Did I ever tell you I wanted to be one; a magnificent royal stag with great coathanger antlers? So, I went down to the jolly old river one night and christened m’self Stag! Had two toads and a newt as witnesses, y’know. Oh yes.”

And then they have a picnic while Matthias infodumps. Eventually, they formulate a plan to get the tapestry back; Basil will create a distraction while Matthias infiltrates. Basil uses Aid Another to help Matthias with his Hide and move Silently checks, and then starts trolling the sentries as hard as he can. I specifically like this line:


Adding insult to injury, he danced around the fallen sentries, sprinkling them with daisies until they arose, cursing him, to continue the chase.

That is simply the greatest thing.

Matthias gets inside and sees no army, not Cluny, and no tapestry. It takes him a second to figure out that Cluny had already left. He turns around to get a warning back to Redwall, when he hears Abram Vole locked in a toolshed and sets about freeing the family.


Forcing the spike in the hoop of the lock, Matthias levered away.

I'm 12.

After being angered by Colin's constant bitching, Matthias gets the strength to send the spike straight through the wall and breaking the door off. Or maybe he broke the lock off of the door entirely, rather than just breaking the lock. It was oddly described.

He cuts them free and starts to escape with them. Right into the middle of the rats.

Blue Ghost
2012-03-22, 05:43 PM
It's back! :smallbiggrin:

Basil Stag Hare is awesome.

Looking forward to reading ALL THE BOOKS!

hamishspence
2012-03-22, 06:10 PM
... what the hell is piebald?

Black-and-white. Normally only occurs in domesticated rats in real life.

LaZodiac
2012-03-22, 06:11 PM
This was pretty funny. Can't wait for more :smalltongue:

Reverent-One
2012-03-22, 06:38 PM
Out of curiosity, which books did you find worthy of a second read-through and which did you despise (if you don't mind sharing that now instead of when you get to them)?

John Cribati
2012-03-22, 06:50 PM
The only books I've (intentionally) not read more that once are Pearls of Lutra and The Legend of Luke. They aren't the bad ones, though; it had more to do with me growing up and seeing past all the childishness the books contained than with the actual quality of the books themselves (There were problems with The Legend of Luke, but we'll burn that bridge when we get there). Pearls was just forgettable; I could name at least 5 characters from any of the other books, beyond the main character and the bad guy. Pearls? not so much.

The ones I didn't like at all are Eulalia and Triss. Triss because even though that story is one of the better ones, none of his jokes work at all. None. And the book is almost 30% jokes. Eulalia was the first book that made me just not want to continue reading at all; it wal badly written in pretty much all respects.

I've read Loamhedge more than once, but I admit it's mediocre in many respects.

LaZodiac
2012-03-22, 06:58 PM
It's been a long time since I've read them, but I don't recall Eulalia being that bad.

Also, if Loamhedge has the lady in a wheelchair, I think I know what scene is going to get the most hate :smallamused:

Reverent-One
2012-03-22, 07:07 PM
Eh, Loamhedge, that one is undoubtedly my least favorite. Yes LaZodiac, that's the one with the wheelchair.

Gwyn chan 'r Gwyll
2012-03-22, 07:16 PM
I was amused. AMUSE ME MORE!

Blue Ghost
2012-03-22, 07:41 PM
Yeah, Loamhedge was rather bleh. But it had the best songs, IMO.

Gwyn chan 'r Gwyll
2012-03-22, 08:06 PM
I admit, I can hardly remember ANY of the many Redwall books.

MCerberus
2012-03-22, 08:12 PM
Oh wow Redwall. That brings me a lot of nostalgia from middle school. I loved it at the time, but it was the first series that taught me the jaded lesson that media loves recycling plots nearly ad-nauseum.

Saph
2012-03-23, 11:53 AM
This was a trip down memory lane. Loved these books as a kid. More please. :smallbiggrin:

John Cribati
2012-03-26, 08:00 PM
Chapter 18

Cluny's main front is on the ditch acroos the road from the Abbey. Good for him, because he's out of range of anything that the Redwallers could launch at him. Bad for him because rats suck at bowmaking. Meanwhile the front lines are getting annoyed (yes, annoyed) by arrows from the wall. He gets the slingers to throw up some cover fire while another group rushes the wall with ladders and grappling hooks. Unfortunately, the Redwallers have a large pile of rubble that they use to knock all the climbers off.

Seeing that his troops just got pwned off of the walls, he sees a remaining grappling hook and tries to clim it and get into Redwall himself. With no backup.


There was no better general than Cluny when it came to strategy.

I knew that would come in handy.

Cluny's a good distance up the wall when the only beaver at the Abbey (and in the rest of the books, for that matter) chews through the rope and knocks him on his ass. He calls a swift retreat, and since he's nothing if not a bad sport, he lets them celebrate, only to launch a final volley as they stand up.

Speaking of biting through ropes, Ragear has awakened and is now escaping Matthias. He plans to join the battle again and maybe distinguish himself a bit so Cluny won't be too mad.

Of course, this is where things go horribly, horribly wrong.

I'll let the scene speak for itself (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=blrFyj6vpj4&feature=player_detailpage#t=354s), yeah?

*shudder*

Back to less scary things: Cluny's making a new plan; Redtooth dresses as Cluny and continues attacking the Main gate, while Cluny and another group goes around to the forest side to find a close-enough tree that they can climb it to get over the walls. He sends a scouting party out to find the right tree, and Cheesethief and a ferret named Killconey come back with news of Ragear's encounter with... the thing. I also want to note Killconey's accent.


“Do ye not know? ’Tis the dreaded name of the divvil himself, sir,” wailed the ferret. “I know because me ould mother told me so, and she always said never to look a serpent in the eye.”

Mentions of Hell et. al: 11.5

A weasel named Scragg comes up with news that's actually helpful to Cluny; there's a conveniently placed tree near the wall that's conveniently tall enough that they can use a conveniently-sized plank to bridge the gap between it and the wall. And then they start climbing.


Chapter 19

When we last left Matthias, he walked right into the middle of some sentries while rescuing the vole family. Colin and his mother get grabbed, and Mattie tells Abram to run away; he's just a Commoner, after all. Matthias happens upon a branch that he uses as an improvised weapon, swinging it around and calling for Basil to see if he's still around. And Basil does not disappoint.


He came bounding up, for all the world as if he were on a Sunday School picnic, grinning from ear to ear.

In my head, he was skipping his way over and had a bunch of flowers in his ears to boot. Where was he, by the way?


“Sorry about that, Matthias, my old lad. When these chaps gave up chasing me, I scooted back to my den. Spring cleaning, y’know. A bit late, but I’m only a bachelor in single quarters, what!”

This starts a round of banter between them as they fight off the rats together. It's done rather well; I still chuckle at it today, especially at the invitation to the (very bemused) Voles to afternoon tea, the fact that Basil's table can only seat 4. Also, the "I am 12" running gag continues with this line.


“Why, of course you will, Mr. Hare. What a bore you must think me. I’ll probably sit around on the common here and teach the rats to make daisy chains.”

Because I hope to Raptor Jesus that in 1989 England, "daisy chain" didn't have its urbandictionary meaning yet. Actually, I hope it did. Because that would make Jacques even more awesome.

They part ways, Basil taking the Voles into hiding until the battle is over, while Matthias heads straight to Redwall to join in said battle however he can.

Except he gets lost. And then sidetracked by his stomach and goes foraging. And then "the itis" sets in, and he falls asleep. Our hero, ladies and gentlemen!


Chapter 20

Meanwhile, Cluny and his squad are up a tree, waiting for the evening when they can cross over to the wall under cover. And before I continue, I have to bring up something weird that keeps bugging me.


Some of the rats were really hopeless climbers in Cluny’s estimation.... as for that idiot Cheesethief, imagine waiting until you were six yards above ground to find out that you were afraid and had no head for heights.

What is the scale like in this world, to be completely honest? A 2-pound fish can feed everyone in the Abbey (plus whoever they invited in from the forest) with Leftovers. And yet it was all cooked at once in an oven; How high off the ground is 6 yards? Is it 6 yards as the average rat would see it (So, 4-5 times their own height), or 6 actual human yards (40-50 times their height)? And don't get me started on the sizes of the creatures themselves. I guess it's best not thought about and move on.

Cluny bemoans the fact that he doesn't have enough mustelids in his horde. As for the plank plan, they're high enough to reach the wall from the tree, but the plank would slope upwards. The new plan is to wait till nightfall and then catch the Redwallers off-guard. He unofficially puts Scragg in charge of a squadron, and the weasel responds with the exact idea that Cluny had a moment ago about the plank situation. Seeing that Scragg is marginally intelligent, Cluny hints that a captain spot might open up soon. Cheesethief somehow hears this despite being on a lower branch and Cluny being right next to Scragg whispering. Meh. He starts plotting against Scragg.

Meanwhile, Mortimer and Constance have their Shipping Goggles on as Cornflower goes about feeding the troops. They also talk about the Missing Matthias.


“I’m certain that he is helping our cause, so we’ll just have to await his return and trust to Matthias’s judgment and good sense.”

...


Gathering a bunch of tender leaves and buds, [Matthias] made his way back to the sun-warmed sandstone and stretched out on his back, nibbling dandelions and gazing up at the cloudless blue June sky through the treetops.

Dramatic irony FTW.

Anyway, Foremole and Winnifred the Otter launch a boulder with a children's seesaw, and the world is very lucky that e-books have no physical presence, and thus cannot be thrown.

In other news, the rats have a new weapon in their arsenal.


Some inventive rat had devised a fearsome weapon: chunks of iron grave-railings from the churchyard, strung to lengths of cord.... The missiles sped upwards, two or three times higher than the wall... then they would plummet downwards... to burst on the ramparts. Any defender struck by a missile was either instantly killed or horribly maimed. Even if the iron missed its target, the stones and shattered metal fragments ricocheted about dangerously.

That's pretty much a bomb without the explosion. Luckily, if they're aimed wrong, they could come back down on the rats, so it's pretty even, I guess.

Inside the Abbey, Methuselah is looking at the space where Martin used to be, wondering where Martin's grave would be, thinking about how long he's searched for it. He's about to move off, when he stumbles a bit (My headcanon is that Martin's ghost tripped him), and when he puts his hand to the wall, it finds writing carved into the stone, directly behind the place where Martin's portrait was.

LaZodiac
2012-03-26, 09:42 PM
Assuming its safe to post now (I'm not sure, never expieranced one of these before) I'd just like to note you've probably given my subconcious night terrors by showing that scene.

That crunching sound.

Blue Ghost
2012-03-31, 06:50 PM
o_O
Asmodeussss....

*shudders*

John Cribati
2012-04-26, 03:36 PM
So. My Hard Drive is down for a while and all my important files are inaccessible. Getting a new one in a couple of days, but in the meantime, you'll be able to do all sorts of tumblrish (http://redwallreadthrough.tumblr.com/) things.

Blue Ghost
2012-04-26, 05:54 PM
Oh dear. Losing a hard drive is a pain. Be well, and we're looking forward to your return!

Riverdance
2012-04-27, 11:26 AM
Oh wow Redwall. That brings me a lot of nostalgia from middle school. I loved it at the time, but it was the first series that taught me the jaded lesson that media loves recycling plots nearly ad-nauseum.

Yeah it could be somewhat formulaic at times: Things are great, bad guy shows up, things are crap, lots of fighting, major character dies (but not the main character), bad guy dies, things are all right again.

Not that that stopped me from reading them all. I used to love them when I was little, and I had a poster of all the major characters up to Lord Brocktree on my ceiling until I was 15 or 16.

John Cribati
2012-05-14, 07:42 PM
Note: in honor of this being my first update written after the airing of The Legend of Korra (coughakathereasonitooksolongtogetthisdonecough), all images in this post will be GIFs from that show, or its prequel, Avatar: the Last Airbender. They will show up whenever I deem them most appropriate. I am not sorry.


Book 2: Chapter 1

Matthias wakes up from his nap and revels in that "I just had the best sleep ever" feeling for all of one second before he realizes he's an idiot. He's lost and alone in the forest, and goes off to hide under a tree because forests are scary in the dark. Seeing how pitiful a figure he must look, he tries to gain some man points back by challenging the standard creepy forest sound that he hears. And it's a baby squirrel, sucking on his paw. Matti finds some kind of dark humor in the fact that he was essentially about to stab an infant in the face.

The squirrel doesn't talk, so Matthias has to communicate in "Yes or no" questions, and he eventually gets the little guy to lead him back to Redwall.

Yes, that's all that happens in this chapter.

No, I have nothing funny to say about it.


Book 2: Chapter 2

Morty is in the courtyard with other relieved defenders, I guess in some gesture of camaraderie, when Methuselah comes over and they talk about being old.Then Methuselah points out that there's a tree that's moving about in an odd manner, and Constance is called to check on it.

The rats are having trouble with the plank, and Cheesethief makes the cardinal sin of looking stupid in front of Cluny.


[I]Cluny aimed a kick at him as the efficient weasel took his place. “You just sit there and be still,” Cluny snarled. “And try not to make enough noise to waken the entire Abbey.”

Scragg gets the plank steadied, and Cluny is the first to try to run across.

And then Constance comes out of nowhere and knocks the plank clear off the wall. And Cluny falls the whole way.


Scragg still held one end of the plank. He leaned precariously out from the elm to see where Cluny fell.

Seizing his opportunity for revenge, Cheesethief shoved Scragg hard in the back. The weasel dropped like a stone with the plank on top of him.

That's kind of a terrible way to go.

Cheesethief's next move is to check if Cluny's alive, and when it turns out that he is, he starts ass-kissing to get back into Cluny's good graces.


Tenderly he lifted the dangling tail and arranged it gently alongside his leader. “Try not to move, Chief. Lie still, we’ll soon get you back to camp.”

And thus a million and a half Cheesethief/Cluny slash fics burst from the reproductive organs of furries and fangirls (and furry fangirls) everywhere.

Scragg, too is also alive, and after he orders the able-bodied to hoist Cluny to base, Cheesethief doubles back just as Matthias and Sam get close enough to watch.


Cheesethief cocked a mockingly sympathetic ear. “What’s that, Scragg, my old mate? Tired, are you? Yes, you must be, lying there like that. Tell you what, I’ll help you to go to sleep, shall I?”

The rat placed his foot on the weasel’s throat and began pressing down. Scragg struggled feebly, fighting for breath, unable to stop his tormentor. Cheesethief took malicious pleasure in his revenge.

Cruelly he leaned his full weight upon the weasel’s rasping throat. “Hush now. Go to sleep, Scragg. Dream of the command you never had.”

Scragg made one final gurgling whimper and lay still.

Cheesethief slunk off chuckling with satisfaction.

Children read this book.

After a bit of a narmy reaction (by the narrator no less), this happened.


[T]he tiny creature raced up the trunk of the old elm. Reaching the thin branches above the parapet, he ran out along one. Using it as a springboard, he bounced nimbly on to the ramparts and vanished

An infant has managed to perform by himself what it took an entire army to fail at.


sucking fiercely at his paw.

One-handed.

My Suspension of Disbelief cracked just a little bit.

Anyway, he gets Constance to open the door, and she carries Matthias to the main gate to watch the army retreat. Redtooth is trying to put on a good show of being Cluny, but it fails, mostly because the real Cluny is on a stretcher near him. Covered or not, who else is important enough that to be carried like that? Why they couldn't take him on a route through the woods is anyone's guess.

Mortimer, good sport that he is, orders that nobody fire at them while they're retreating. It's not met with unanimous support, but his word is law.


Dispirited and battleworn, carrying their fallen leader, the maimed and wounded hobbled painfully along at the rear, the bitter ashes of vanquishment and defeat mingling with the dust from their stumbling vanguard.

http://28.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lpfu1gu1R71qfb6wbo1_500.gif

Sorry.

Oh, wait. No I'm not.

Anyway, we get another love-interest-ish moment with Cornflower. It was almost cheesy, but this line saved it.


“I’m like an old bad penny, I always come back,” Matthias whispered.

Maybe because I know firsthand that it works. Sometimes. At all other times, you get slapped.

Also, Cornflower's daddy is alright. There's like two lines devoted to it, and the knowledge is ultimately pointless in the scope of things, but hey, if Matthias hadn't asked, he'd have come off as a selfish idiot.

The Abbot pulls him away for a council of war, where he introduces Matthias properly to Silent Sam, the squirrel who led him back. His parents actually let him wander around Mossflower alone (And the award for worst parents ever goes to... Okay, Ozai and Darth Vader still have them beat), and will be around to pick him up soon. Basil will be on his way back as well, presumably by lunch.

After he gets a brief of what was happening while he was gone, the subject turns to Cluny. Mortimer, wise as he is, is naive (or trusting in the goodness inherent in the hearts of every creature, so same thing, basically) enough to think that Cluny's gone for good. As Constance points out, he isn't. He can't let the word spread that he got owned by a bunch of mice in an abbey, so he has no choice but to try again.

This convinces him, and he declares Constance, Matthias, Winifred, Ambrose and Foremole de facto leaders in case of another assault by Cluny, and then tells Matthias that Methusaelah wants to talk to him.


Book 2: Chapter 3

Back in Cluny's camp, his captains are standing guard and taking stock Cluny's many injuries.


a broken arm, a broken leg, numerous cracked ribs, a fractured tail, smashed claws and other hurts not yet diagnosed.

It's a nice touch that they're completely terrified of putting him out of his misery right there because he might just be testing them. No, think about this for a second. Their leader is grievously injured, and they're half-convinced that he could still take on the five of them if he wanted to, and he was just faking to see what they'd do if he was at their mercy, because they think he's just that tough. That's an incredible feat of showing instead of telling that I have to applaud because it's actually one of Jacques' weakest areas in writing in his later books (I remember one character who literally walked with a letter that pretty much said "This guy is annoying because of XYZ. Take him off my hands for me, yeah?").

Anyway, Cluny continues to have homoerotic dreams about Martin.


He tried to twist away from them as he fell, but, however much he swerved and tried to change direction, Cluny had only to look down and see the fierce-eyed warrior mouse — waiting, always waiting, the sword held point upwards for him to be impaled upon. Cluny tried to cry out, but not a sound came; it was as though his throat were being squeezed tightly. He felt the sharp sword pierce his

O_O


chest.

Oh.


Bong!

Once more the sound of the Joseph Bell tolling out across the fields from Redwall wakened the Warlord. Fangburn, who was trying to extract a piece of elm branch from his Chief’s chest, leaped backwards in fright as Cluny’s eye snapped open inches from his own.

It's the Sharptooth eye all over again.

Cluny calls for the new recruits who lived in the area to see about finding a healer for him. Killconey (did I mention how awesome that name is? Because really) suggests The vixen Sela and her son Chickenhound. Cluny grabs him with his (broken, I may add) tail and starts choking him, demanding that he bring them by any means necessary).


Killconey’s throat bulged as he tried nervously to swallow. “Glug! I will indeed, if you’ll just let go of this pore ould ferret’s neck, sir, I’ll go as fast as if the divvil himself was chasin’ me. You lay back now and rest your noble self, sir.”

It's moments like this that make Killconey one of my favorites. His voice. I hear it in my head. It is perfect. Also: 11.5 references to hell.

Cluny then starts formulating a new plan, ordering Redtooth to find something to act as a battering Ram.


The mice might have won a battle, but Cluny had not yet lost the war, by the claws of hellthunder! Those Abbey mice were going to pay with blood for what they had done to Cluny the Scourge.

12.5 references to hell.


Book 2: Chapter 4

We're back to Methuselah and Matthias, who are using ink to highlight the words that were etched into the wall behind Martin's picture. It takes them an hour, which I really don't understand.

It's the same rhyme from the prologue-ish... thing.

Who says that I am dead
Knows nought at all.
I — am that is,
Two mice within Redwall.
The Warrior sleeps
’Twixt Hall and Cavern Hole.
I — am that is,
Take on my mighty role.
Look for the sword
In moonlight streaming forth,
At night, when day’s first hour
Reflects the North.
From o’er the threshold
Seek and you will see;
I — am that is,
My sword will wield for me.

According to Microsoft Word, that's 75 words and 350 characters. If the counter ignored blank space, and with 3600 seconds in an hour, that means it took more than 10 seconds to fill in each letter; Methuselah had started working on it before Matthias even got there. Unless the letters are really huge, there's no way it would take that long.

But that's just me. Cornflower comes in with some food for them.


She was about to strike up a conversation with Matthias when Methuselah sent her packing.

“Shoo! Away with you, little fieldmouse. I need Matthias with a clear brain to help me solve an important problem, so run along.”

http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lby9z1gDoD1qceiz6o1_400.gif

That's not even the worst part of this, mind you:


Matthias watched her go until Methuselah tweaked his ear.

http://27.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m2wr0zCtDu1rsww0oo1_500.gif

So basically, the whole riddle-solving moves along like this:


Who says that I am dead
Knows nought at all.

Martin is still alive


I — am that is,
Two mice within Redwall.

The dash seems to indicate some sort of separation between “I” (Martin) and “am that is.”

“Am that is” is an anagram for “Matthias.”


‘ The Warrior sleeps

’Twixt Hall and Cavern Hole.

I — am that is

Take on my mighty role. ’ "

Very straightforward here. Between the Great Hall and Cavern Hole, there's a flight of seven steps, with the name “Redwall”carved into the walls going up and down, one letter per step. As “W”is in the middle, and “M” is an upside-down “W,” they figure that it's this one step that's the answer.

And that means moles.

And that means transcribed accents:


“Yurr moles, get outten th’ loight. Let’n um dog at bone thurr.”

“Ummm, worra you’m gennelbeast know abouten this yurr step?” he asked.

“Arr, fourth’n uppards, same down’ards. Yurr, Walt, ’ark, Doby. B’aint that same as your grandmum do foind when she’m rooten about olden toim fortications?”

Methuselah translates, even though the only necessary thing he needed to say was that “fortification” is an old word for “castle.” Any eight-year-old could probably parse the rest.

And ever since I grew to understand Kelly from Misfits, I've had no trouble parsing any accent at all, so long as they were speaking English.

So, the moles find a crack in the joint of the step, and flip the stair over with a crowbar and some good old mole elbow grease.


“Hurr she come, if’n you please,

Movin’ bowlder, sloid on grease.”

To the astonishment of the watching mice, the step slid smoothly outwards on the greased stone. It turned completely over to reveal a dark opening with a downward flight of stairs running off into the blackness below.

LaZodiac
2012-05-14, 07:56 PM
Ah, quite enjoyable, this. Glad to see it back. And yay Avatar, gotta watch more of that.

Yes...I...did not recall that these books could get THAT gruesome. Cheesethief just killed a man slowly.

Also, one handed tree climbing is childs play for a squirrel. Not surprised they can outperform a bunch of gangly ferrets/rats/weasels/assorted vermins.

Maybe its because I haven't read this book in forever, but I never noticed that yes, Cluny is in a position where they could easily betray him...and they don't. His reputation clearly procedes him.

John Cribati
2012-05-26, 06:55 PM
... At the rate I'm going, I'll be almost thirty before I finish this.

So I'm doing a thing right now. An experiment.

Audio posts instead of text.

So that tumblr I liked is going to be a lot more important.

I'm editing right now.

John Cribati
2012-05-26, 09:24 PM
Audiopost 1 is up! (http://redwallreadthrough.tumblr.com/post/23835691267)

Tumblr only allows 1 audio upload per day, so my math was meaningless. :smallsigh:

I'll be going through Soundcloud.