PDA

View Full Version : New Webcomic, Check This Stuff Out



MightyMuenster
2007-01-08, 01:59 PM
My friends and I recently started up our own web comic; any feedback would be great!

Band of Geeks! (http://www.bandofgeeks.smackjeeves.com)

Gnome Barbarian
2007-01-14, 03:21 PM
I do like it. Very funny

Cayzle
2007-01-14, 05:58 PM
I like the clever meta stuff. Like the one about the Power of the Writer. The poorly drawn misogynist one, not so much. But what is it *about*?

occaisional color in a b/w strip is striking and funny.

Cayzle
http://www.cayzle/com/grace

Jewel Thief
2007-01-14, 06:14 PM
It's so bizarre! Crazy! Insane! I... head... hurts...

But I like it.

MightyMuenster
2007-01-16, 09:32 PM
I like the clever meta stuff. Like the one about the Power of the Writer. The poorly drawn misogynist one, not so much. But what is it *about*?

occaisional color in a b/w strip is striking and funny.

Cayzle
http://www.cayzle/com/grace

Well, we're still kind of finding ourselves. What we're going toward right now is a fantasy-esque series along with occasional fillers if there's anything in pop culture that particularly catches our eye that we would like to make a commentary on.

JKR
2007-01-30, 10:41 AM
Love the second comic. "Behold, you're a donkey!"
That's really clever. Nice. Seems like the art has improved a lot. You may want to work on the character's forms a little more though. They look a touch stiff. Anyway, good luck!

lsove
2007-02-07, 02:11 AM
~not bad.~

Castaras
2007-02-07, 08:42 AM
Interesting....

*Bookmarks for future reference*

Daedrous Avari
2007-02-17, 11:52 AM
My rating.
Plot: 8
The plot is pretty good, I haven't gone deep enough into it to find any plotholes.
Graphics: 9
The graphics are pretty good, you're a pretty talented artist.
Writing: 8
Jokes are pretty good, although some of the "we should make a comic" things are incredibly cliche. As long as there isn't an author character like Dave Anez has in Bob and George.
Updating: 8
Pretty good.
Special Features: 0
There are special features?!?!?
Overall Rating: 8
Overall, it's a pretty good comic.

MightyMuenster
2007-02-17, 09:04 PM
My rating.
Plot: 8
The plot is pretty good, I haven't gone deep enough into it to find any plotholes.
Graphics: 9
The graphics are pretty good, you're a pretty talented artist.
Writing: 8
Jokes are pretty good, although some of the "we should make a comic" things are incredibly cliche. As long as there isn't an author character like Dave Anez has in Bob and George.
Updating: 8
Pretty good.
Special Features: 0
There are special features?!?!?
Overall Rating: 8
Overall, it's a pretty good comic.

Ha, about the author-comic jokes. Those were really just us getting into it and we figured a good way to start would be some self-references to get some swing into it all. Thanks for the positive feedback! I'll pass on to Li that you like his art ;)