Renen
2014-06-07, 02:05 PM
Regarding this thread: http://brilliantgameologists.com/boards/index.php?topic=7991.40
Reading this thread, I felt like starting another discussion on the topic.
Who thinks that Psy Infusion + Midnight Augmentation trick doesnt work?
Here's the reason given in above-linked thread:
The Reason the Trick Doesn't Work:
When we treat the midnight x as if it had essentia invested, what should it do? Well what happens when we normally invest essentia? It trips the 1/day limit. To assume otherwise is to read into the text more than is actually there. The 'it doesn't say I can't!' argument is all that's left. Sorry guys, it seems we are left with a RAW without NI pp.
I do see its possible for the 'as if' part being interpreted as NOT tripping the 1/day limit. But as far as I can tell, I can't rule out the interpretation of it still tripping that limit. And we all know what to do when faced with a 'the text isn't explicit' borked interpretation vs balanced interpretation...
I think it definitely works, but maybe someone can explain it to me well enough that I think otherwise?
Reading this thread, I felt like starting another discussion on the topic.
Who thinks that Psy Infusion + Midnight Augmentation trick doesnt work?
Here's the reason given in above-linked thread:
The Reason the Trick Doesn't Work:
When we treat the midnight x as if it had essentia invested, what should it do? Well what happens when we normally invest essentia? It trips the 1/day limit. To assume otherwise is to read into the text more than is actually there. The 'it doesn't say I can't!' argument is all that's left. Sorry guys, it seems we are left with a RAW without NI pp.
I do see its possible for the 'as if' part being interpreted as NOT tripping the 1/day limit. But as far as I can tell, I can't rule out the interpretation of it still tripping that limit. And we all know what to do when faced with a 'the text isn't explicit' borked interpretation vs balanced interpretation...
I think it definitely works, but maybe someone can explain it to me well enough that I think otherwise?