Mcdt2
2014-09-28, 05:45 PM
So, I've been working on a fix for the weapon system (trying to make it more interesting and realistic) and I noticed something rather annoying: Piercing damage is pretty useless.
Well, to be fair, it is much more useful in the case of an underwater fight, but how often does that come up, anyway? But as far as Damage Reduction goes, how often does it come up? I can think of two situations: Rakshasa (and it has to be good as well, obviously to replicate AD&D's need for blessed crossbow bolts) and the Spearblock enhancement from MiC (which is utter garbage). Pf has a few sources of it (think there's a Sorcerer bloodline that grants it, and a few spells) but even there it's pretty niche.
So, help me out Playground. What do you think should be vulnerable to Piercing damage? The first thing that comes to mind is the Vampire and Vampire Spawn, to represent stakes and such (Do you think it should be just x/piercing? or should it be x/piercing or silver? I feel that former, mostly because vampires being weak to silver seems odd to me just in general.)
Other potential candidates in Core:
Gargoyles (Because why not, Dr/magic is boring. Bit of a stretch though)
The Tarrasque (Representing getting under the heavy plates with the stab)
...Uhhhhhhhh (This is a lot harder than I thought it would be. Guess I'm passing the ball to you, my friends.)
Well, to be fair, it is much more useful in the case of an underwater fight, but how often does that come up, anyway? But as far as Damage Reduction goes, how often does it come up? I can think of two situations: Rakshasa (and it has to be good as well, obviously to replicate AD&D's need for blessed crossbow bolts) and the Spearblock enhancement from MiC (which is utter garbage). Pf has a few sources of it (think there's a Sorcerer bloodline that grants it, and a few spells) but even there it's pretty niche.
So, help me out Playground. What do you think should be vulnerable to Piercing damage? The first thing that comes to mind is the Vampire and Vampire Spawn, to represent stakes and such (Do you think it should be just x/piercing? or should it be x/piercing or silver? I feel that former, mostly because vampires being weak to silver seems odd to me just in general.)
Other potential candidates in Core:
Gargoyles (Because why not, Dr/magic is boring. Bit of a stretch though)
The Tarrasque (Representing getting under the heavy plates with the stab)
...Uhhhhhhhh (This is a lot harder than I thought it would be. Guess I'm passing the ball to you, my friends.)