Avaris
2014-11-09, 09:49 AM
Though this has been sparked by a specific thread*, it's a more general question.
Where a thread veers off topic or into areas that potentially violate forum rules, it is occasionally 'Locked for Review'. This implies that a decision will be reached at some point on whether the thread will continue or not, and that an updated decision will be made in due course. However, a search of the forum reveals threads marked as 'Locked for Review' and with no subsequent comment going back as far as 2007, implying that on occasion no further decision is made.
I appreciate that this may be a deliberate act: if a thread isn't going to be reopened and has dropped off the front page, who is going to read the edited comment? However I would personally appreciate knowing that a thread is permanently out of bounds, and at what point it should be assumed that a thread is locked permanently.
I guess my question is, how long should a 'review' take? And at what point (if any) is it reasonable to ask the locking moderator to make a final decision?
*Moving Dead Bodies for a Living, which has been closed for about a week now despite offending posts having been scrubbed
Where a thread veers off topic or into areas that potentially violate forum rules, it is occasionally 'Locked for Review'. This implies that a decision will be reached at some point on whether the thread will continue or not, and that an updated decision will be made in due course. However, a search of the forum reveals threads marked as 'Locked for Review' and with no subsequent comment going back as far as 2007, implying that on occasion no further decision is made.
I appreciate that this may be a deliberate act: if a thread isn't going to be reopened and has dropped off the front page, who is going to read the edited comment? However I would personally appreciate knowing that a thread is permanently out of bounds, and at what point it should be assumed that a thread is locked permanently.
I guess my question is, how long should a 'review' take? And at what point (if any) is it reasonable to ask the locking moderator to make a final decision?
*Moving Dead Bodies for a Living, which has been closed for about a week now despite offending posts having been scrubbed