Eager stack with Warning?

[theboss]

Basically as the title says, does this two enchantment stuck?

Eager:



An eager weapon can be drawn as a free
action. While wielding it, you gain a +2
bonus on initiative checks and a +2 bonus
on damage rolls made during a surprise
round and the first round of combat.
Prerequisites: Craft Magic Arms and
Armor, cat’s grace.
Cost to Create: Varies.


Warning:



A warning weapon grants you a +5 insight
bonus on initiative checks as long as it
is held.
Prerequisites: Craft Magic Arms and
Armor, cat’s grace.
Cost to Create: Varies.

The way I see it, they don't... But I'd like to hear some thoughts becasue they don't mention any type of bonus in the Eager enchantment.

Thanks in advance

[Bronk]

Basically as the title says, does this two enchantment stuck?

Eager:
Warning:

The way I see it, they don't... But I'd like to hear some thoughts becasue they don't mention any type of bonus in the Eager enchantment.

Thanks in advance

Yes, they do stack, for the reasons you mentioned. They're two bonuses, of two different types: untyped and insight.

[Beheld]

Yes, untyped bonuses stack with insight bonuses. In fact, untyped bonuses stack with other untyped bonuses from a different source.

[theboss]

Many thanks

[Necroticplague]

The way I see it, they don't... But I'd like to hear some thoughts becasue they don't mention any type of bonus in the Eager enchantment.


Why wouldn't they stack? Two different bonus types stack.

[theboss]

Why wouldn't they stack? Two different bonus types stack.

Same Prerequisites...Same enchantment, Same price....

[MaxiDuRaritry]

Same Prerequisites...Same enchantment, Same price....Different ability, different bonus type.

They stack.

[Necroticplague]

Same Prerequisites...Same enchantment, Same price....

Different size of bonus, different name of ability, different amount of bonuses....That's like saying Flaming and Frost don't stack because they're so similar.

[Quertus]

These two enchantment stacking is one of the reasons why the "best" party I was in, the worst init bonus in the party was a +7.

[theboss]

I didn't knew that and I'm glad that now I know. It's for my character... I'm not trying to ruin someone's build...


These two enchantment stacking is one of the reasons why the "best" party I was in, the worst init bonus in the party was a +7.

My bonus now is +20 :smalltongue:

[Quertus]

My bonus now is +20 :smalltongue:

You might get a turn... if you roll high enough. :smalltongue:

Actually, we were looking at... Hmmm... 7 (dex) + 7 (eager+warning) + 4 (improved init) + 2 (gifted general) + 7 (chr <- lightning blade) + 1 (dragonfly amulet) = +28. Or thereabouts.

[Gildedragon]

You might get a turn... if you roll high enough. :smalltongue:

Actually, we were looking at... Hmmm... 7 (dex) + 7 (eager+warning) + 4 (improved init) + 2 (gifted general) + 7 (chr <- lightning blade) + 1 (dragonfly amulet) = +28. Or thereabouts.
How are you getting Cha to initiative from lightning blade?

[DarkSonic1337]

Maybe he's thinking swiftblade?

Also want to mention ring of anticipation to the initiative stacking conversation. If I recall correctly it was close to an effective +4 bonus to initiative.