PDA

View Full Version : ripping their flesh



Braininthejar2
2016-08-21, 05:33 PM
Girallon Windmill Flesh Rip - is there any way to use it with bare hands instead of two weapons?

(I'm building an unarmed swordsage vampire)

The Viscount
2016-08-21, 06:01 PM
The maneuver actually only requires that you wield two weapons to activate it, not that you use both weapons to attack. I believe that a weapon and an unarmed strike count as 2 weapons for this going off of text for wolf fang strike.

Necroticplague
2016-08-21, 06:36 PM
Yes, there is. It's called abusing loopholes. The boost requires that you wield two different weapons. It does not, however, require that the attacks that benefit from it actually be with more than one weapon. So as long as you have some kind of weapon on you, you can use the maneuver with your unarmed strike and just punch them for rend damage. If you want to go for something completely disarmed that works, having any other natural weapon will suffice. If you want some good flavor synergy, pick up a set of claws and the Beast Strike feat.

MisterKaws
2016-08-21, 06:41 PM
You can just TWF with unarmed strikes. Just attack with two different body parts: two arms, two legs, heck, even headbutt+turkey slap if you want to get really weird with it.

Braininthejar2
2016-08-21, 06:48 PM
Hmm... I thought you couldn't duel-wield unarmed strike (as "unarmed strike" is a strike with whichever body part is the most convenient at the moment, so you don't have "two" of it)

... buuut, a vampire would technically have a natural slam attack too.

Big Fau
2016-08-21, 07:05 PM
Hmm... I thought you couldn't duel-wield unarmed strike (as "unarmed strike" is a strike with whichever body part is the most convenient at the moment, so you don't have "two" of it)

... buuut, a vampire would technically have a natural slam attack too.

That's Pathfinder rules. 3.5 rules it a little differently.

Necroticplague
2016-08-21, 07:12 PM
You can just TWF with unarmed strikes. Just attack with two different body parts: two arms, two legs, heck, even headbutt+turkey slap if you want to get really weird with it.

That's not how that works. All of those are a single weapon, an 'unarmed strike'. Thus, you can't TWF an unarmed strike with itself, because you only have on it. That's like trying to TWF a greatsword with itself by striking with the point, then with the flat.

MisterKaws
2016-08-21, 07:54 PM
That's not how that works. All of those are a single weapon, an 'unarmed strike'. Thus, you can't TWF an unarmed strike with itself, because you only have on it. That's like trying to TWF a greatsword with itself by striking with the point, then with the flat.

Well, CustServ says you can, as does PHB(Unarmed is treated as a manufactured weapon) and nearly every single DM I've met.

Braininthejar2
2016-08-22, 02:03 AM
Well, CustServ says you can, as does PHB(Unarmed is treated as a manufactured weapon) and nearly every single DM I've met.

I think "dual wielding unarmed strike" is what a monk's flurry is supposed to represent.

Necroticplague
2016-08-22, 07:59 AM
Well, CustServ says you can, as does PHB(Unarmed is treated as a manufactured weapon) and nearly every single DM I've met.

1.Custserv isn't RAW, that's just some dude's ruling.
2. PHB actually supports that you can't TWF with only your unarmed strike.

If you wield a second weapon in your off hand, you can get one extra attack per round with that weapon.
Now, the 'second' should be enough to seal the deal already. After all, you can't really say 'my unarmed strike' and 'my same unarmed strike' are two different weapons. however, just to add more evidence.

There is no such thing as an off-hand attack for a monk striking unarmed.
Since you can't have an off-hand attack with an Unarmed Strike, and TWF requires you wield a weapon in your off-hand, the two aren't compatable.
3. How a previous DM has ruled is even less relevent than Custserv.

Telonius
2016-08-22, 08:37 AM
Refer to the Kensai prestige class in Complete Warrior; various parts of unarmed strike can be separated from the rest. (i.e. your fists would get the bonuses, but not legs/knees/elbows/headbutts/whatever).

MisterKaws
2016-08-22, 10:57 AM
Refer to the Kensai prestige class in Complete Warrior; various parts of unarmed strike can be separated from the rest. (i.e. your fists would get the bonuses, but not legs/knees/elbows/headbutts/whatever).

I was just about to mention that one.