PDA

View Full Version : Question About Atropus



ross
2016-11-06, 08:26 PM
In the Elder Evil book, under the "Sign: Restless Dead" heading for Atropus, one part of the Overwhelming entry says:


they gain turn resistance equal to one-quarter of their
Hit Die total (1–7 HD grants +1 turn resistance, 8–15 HD grants
+2, 16–23 HD grants +3, and so on).

Confused because, although this works up to 11 HD, at 12 and above, the stated values diverge from the given formula; according to which, at 12 to 15 HD, the affected undead should have +3 turn resistance, at 16 to 19, they should have +4, and at 20 to 24, they should have +5 (and so on for higher HD).

The explicitly stated values seem to indicate that the writers intended for the bonus to be equal to one-eighth of the undead's HD, rather than one-fourth.

So is this a mistake in the formula, or the listed bonuses, or am I missing something?

KillianHawkeye
2016-11-06, 10:15 PM
It isn't definite, but I would say that it was probably a simple mistake and that the example numbers are wrong. Rounding down, and assuming a minimum of one, a range of 1 to 7 does produce a result of 1 when divided by four. The numbers given don't exactly fit a "one eighth their Hit Dice" formula, either (more like "1 + 1/8").