Settlers Of Catan: Game 1 (IC)

[AvatarVecna]

Game 1 Map (https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1CpWlGLG1cq8mfn-sugQtYRhYEnAHSGf1MjOUCbbUjK8/edit?usp=sharing)

[Croverus]

First city at SOP; road leading to KOP

[AvatarVecna]

First city at SOP; road leading to KOP

Acknowledged and mapped. Hamste, state your settlement/road.

[Hamste]

I will place my first settlement on DIE with the road leading HID...I definitely did not choose these purely for their names.

[AvatarVecna]

I will place my first settlement on DIE with the road leading HID...I definitely did not choose these purely for their names.

Acknowledged and mapped. Cuthalion, place your first settlement/road.

[Cuthalion]

KFG leading towards J.

[AvatarVecna]

Acknowledged and mapped. Lentrax, please place two settlements and roads (since we're doing the 'snaking back' thing).

[Lentrax]

Sorry. Was sick yesterday.

1st city at MOR, road leading to MQR.

2nd city at HIM, road leading to IMM.

[AvatarVecna]

Acknowledged and mapped (and map updated with one of the Ms changed to N because I was a moron :smallredface:). Cuthalion, your turn again!

[Cuthalion]

Sorry, didn't see these posts. Must have clicked on the thread when it popped up in CP and left without reading it or something.

EIJ towards E4, please.

[Hamste]

Sorry, didn't see these posts. Must have clicked on the thread when it popped up in CP and left without reading it or something.

EIJ towards E4, please.

Don't you need one empty space between towns? EIJ is next to my DIE

[AvatarVecna]

Sorry, didn't see these posts. Must have clicked on the thread when it popped up in CP and left without reading it or something.

EIJ towards E4, please.


Don't you need one empty space between towns? EIJ is next to my DIE

Indeed. Based on the "towards E4" part, I have a suspicion they might've meant "NIJ towards E4", but I want to clarify before mapping it just to be sure.

[Cuthalion]

...Right. NIJ is correct.

[AvatarVecna]

Acknowledged and mapped. Hamste, you're up.

[Hamste]

There goes any chance I could claim a monopoly on sheep. This here is a surprisingly hard decision. I will go with FEB with the road going towards the FBC intersection.

[AvatarVecna]

There goes any chance I could claim a monopoly on sheep. This here is a surprisingly hard decision. I will go with FEB with the road going towards the FBC intersection.

Acknowledged and mapped. Croverus, place your second settlement/road, and then we can begin! :smallsmile:

[Generic-Guy]

Second town at GLh, whit the road to GLK
I will stay Grey.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 1 Turn 1: Generic-Guy

[roll0]

EDIT: Generic-Guy, you may trade and/or build at this time.

[Generic-Guy]

I willam ending my round early.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 1 Turn 2: Hamste

[roll0]

Please move the thief as you please. You may trade/build at this time.

[Hamste]

I put the Robber on K... I mean who needs wood? Only one person for me to steal from.

[Hamste]

I will end my turn now.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 1 Turn 3: Cuthalion

[roll0]

That hex is being Robbed, no resources gained. You may trade/build at this time.

[Cuthalion]

Does anyone want to trade me a wood and a brick for some sheep?

Build road between F and O, end turn.

edit:nvm he stole my wood

end turn

[AvatarVecna]

Round 1 Turn 4: Lentrax

[roll0]

You may trade/build at this time.

[Lentrax]

Pass turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 2 Turn 1: Generic-Guy.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Generic-Guy]

Pass out of lack of anything usefull.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 2 Turn 2: Hamste

[roll0]

You may move the robber, and then trade/build.

[Hamste]

I move the Robber to O. Steal from Lentrax.

Make road to ADE from my settlement (also my initial road from that settlement was so badly place :P)

I then end my turn as everyone is still resource starved.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 2 Turn 3: Cuthalion.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Cuthalion]

end turn

[AvatarVecna]

Round 2 Turn 4: Lentrax.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Lentrax]

I'll pass turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 3 Turn 1: Generic-Guy.

[roll0]

You may move the robber, and trade/build.

[Generic-Guy]

I move the robber to D11. Hamste, got the most resources, so i will steal lend steal from him. I would go for I6, but i don't think the others would agree. So D11. That only hurts one and not even that badly.
I will end my turn after this, since i am for the next few hours unavaible.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 3 Turn 2: Hamste.

[roll0]

EDIT: You may trade/build.

[Hamste]

Aw man, I wanted that stone (also wow on so many 8's)

I can't really build anything unless Cuthalien gives me wood for free so I end turn

[AvatarVecna]

Round 3 Turn 3: Cuthalion.

[roll0]

You may trade/build at this time.

[Cuthalion]

Road F to O, bitte. End turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 3 Turn 4: Lentrax.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Lentrax]

Buy a development card.

Pass turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 4 Turn 1: Generic-Guy.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Generic-Guy]

Cuthalion, can i buy this wood for 2 ore stone?

[Cuthalion]

Cuthalion, can i buy this wood for 2 ore stone?

Not for trade, sorry.

[Generic-Guy]

In that case:
I trade 3 Stone for 1 Wood oversea, followed by the use of that Wood and my Brick to build a Road.

-3 Stone; -1 Brick; add Road G-P

That would end my turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 4 Turn 2: Hamste.

[roll0]

You may trade/build at this time.

[Hamste]

I'm the king of the bricks!

Four bricks traded into wood. Make a road to ADe from ADE (If I hadn't placed badly originally I would have gotten a settlement by now)

End turn

[AvatarVecna]

Round 4 Turn 3: Cuthalion.

[roll0]

You may trade/build at this time.

[Cuthalion]

End turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 4 Turn 4: Lentrax.

[roll0]

You may trade/build at this time.

[Lentrax]

I will play my knight card and move the robber to E.

[AvatarVecna]

I will play my knight card and move the robber to E.

Robber has been moved. [roll0]

[Lentrax]

I'll end my turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 5 Turn 1: Generic-Guy.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Generic-Guy]

End the turn, i lack the resorces to do anything else

[AvatarVecna]

Round 5 Turn 2: Hamste.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Hamste]

After a series of trades I build a settlement on ADe.

End my turn

[AvatarVecna]

Round 5 Turn 3: Cuthalion.

[roll0]

You may move the robber, and trade/build.

[Cuthalion]

Move robber to O, steal from Lentrax.

[roll0]

EDIT: buy development card, end turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 5 Turn 4: Lentrax.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Lentrax]

Trade my four sheep for a wood. Build a road to QRp.

End turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 6 Turn 1: Generic-Guy.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Generic-Guy]

I cruse, giva a evil glare to O5 and the robbers on it and end the turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 6 Turn 2: Hamste.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Hamste]

I end my turn as there is nothing that can be done with my resources.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 6 Turn 3: Cuthalion.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Cuthalion]

build settlement, end turn

[Generic-Guy]

build settlement, end turn

KJO? Just for the games protocol.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 6 Turn 4: Lentrax.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.


KJO? Just for the games protocol.

Given it's the only place they can legally build, I'm assuming so.

[Lentrax]

Ending turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 7 Turn 1: Generic-Guy.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Generic-Guy]

I would pray to the God of Wood, but since i am sure this is not going to work, i will end this turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 7 Turn 2: Hamste.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Hamste]

I end my turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 7 Turn 3: Cuthalion.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Cuthalion]

Build road J to P, end turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 7 Turn 4: Lentrax.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Lentrax]

I'll buy a development card and end my turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 8 Turn 1: Generic-Guy.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Generic-Guy]

Posted a open trade in the OOC and end my turn.
The trade is possible untill i got wood, and of course only in your/my turns.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 8 Turn 2: Hamste.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Hamste]

I think all of our people are starving with how little wheat we have. At least we have sheep.

I end my turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 8 Turn 3: Cuthalion.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Cuthalion]

End turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 8 Turn 4: Lentrax.

[roll0]

You may move the robber, and trade/build.

[Lentrax]

Right. With the new Wheat and Wood, I can build a settlement at QRp.

[Hamste]

Wait what wheat?

[AvatarVecna]

Wait what wheat?

Issue was me misspeaking, and possibly not recording Lentrax's new sheep properly. I'll check fully when I get home.

[Lentrax]

Well, I end turn then without building.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 9 Turn 1: Generic-Guy.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Generic-Guy]

I trade three stone for a wood by the use of my port.
I ask Cuthalion not to put a road where i think he wants to put a road.
I end my turn.

[Cuthalion]

I trade three stone for a wood by the use of my port.
I ask Cuthalion not to put a road where i think he wants to put a road.
I end my turn.

I politely point out that I could have technically already done so.

I ask Generic-Guy where else I can go and note that my options are very limited re:expansion.

[Generic-Guy]

I thank him and suggest to go North and may even take, sooner or later, the Wood-port, allowing him acces to a 2 Wood for 1 Resource of choice trade.
Catan is a very cramped island and his positioning in the middle is benifidal for the gathering of the limited resouces, but will result in a limited room for expansion.
My position in the SouthEast on the other hand does allow me the trade on ports easyer, but limits my ways to the richer resouces.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 9 Turn 2: Hamste.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Hamste]

I end my turn

[AvatarVecna]

Round 9 Turn 3: Cuthalion.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Cuthalion]

Road between O and L, end turn.

Sorry. :smallfrown:

[Hamste]

Who will get it first?

[AvatarVecna]

Round 9 Turn 4: Lentrax.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Lentrax]

I will just end my turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 10 Turn 1: Generic-Guy.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Hamste]

Hey, if you had one more stone you could trade and make your settlement. I will give you a stone for 1/2 of the wood that the settlement makes (so every second time an 8 is rolled you would owe me a wood).

[Generic-Guy]

https://i.imgflip.com/1j696g.jpg

Trade 2 Sheep and 1 Stone for Wheat.
Build that settlement. KPL.

[Hamste]

https://i.imgflip.com/1j696g.jpg

Trade 2 Sheep and 1 Stone for Wheat.
Build that settlement. KPL.

You have to trade three matching resources (arguably I can't do my trade of 1 stone for wood in the future as it may count as giving away resources but to me it seems like a deal with a long term pay off not me giving away resources).

[Generic-Guy]

a 4:1 needs matching resouces. but a 3:1 port doesn't.

[Hamste]

a 4:1 needs matching resouces. but a 3:1 port doesn't.

I'm looking at the rules that were linked and it definitely says identical resources for generic harbors.

[Generic-Guy]

No, it claims that at certain habors, it is a 2:1 whit the shown ressouce, but nothing that the 3:1 needs the same.

[Hamste]

No, it claims that at certain habors, it is a 2:1 whit the shown ressouce, but nothing that the 3:1 needs the same.

Did you look in the Almanac under maritime trade?

[AvatarVecna]

I would prefer that trade discussions were kept to the OOC, but they're acceptable in the IC. I'm going to have to insist that rules issues being kept out of the IC, though. Also, I found the rule under Maritime Trade on pg 9:

"Generic Harbor (3:1): Here you may exchange 3 identical resource cards for any 1 other resource card during your trade phase."

So Hamste is correct.

[Generic-Guy]

Sooo, after all the fog cleared itself, i trade 3 sheep for a wheat.
Then, i build the KPL settlement and end my turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 10 Turn 2: Hamste.

[roll0]

You may trade/build at this time.

[Hamste]

I end my turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 10 Turn 3: Cuthalion.

[roll0]

You may move the robber, and trade/build.

[Cuthalion]

build road from K to C

end turn

[AvatarVecna]

Round 10 Turn 4: Lentrax.

[roll0]

You may move the robber, and trade/build.

[Lentrax]

Move the robber to F. Steal from Hamste.

End turn.

[Hamste]

So much theft from me. I really need to hire some guards.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 11 Turn 1: Generic-Guy.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Generic-Guy]

Well, nothing to do here.
End turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 11 Turn 2: Hamste.

[roll]2d6[\roll]

You may trade/build.

[AvatarVecna]

Whoops!

[roll0]

[Hamste]

Pass turn

[AvatarVecna]

Round 11 Turn 3: Cuthalion.

[roll0]

You may move the robber, and trade/build.

[Cuthalion]

Move robber to I, build road from G to B, end turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 11 Turn 4: Lentrax.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Lentrax]

Pass turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 12 Turn 1: Generic-Guy.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Generic-Guy]

I end my turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 12 Turn 2: Hamste.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Hamste]

I end my turn

[AvatarVecna]

Round 12 Turn 3: Cuthalion.

[roll0]

You may move the robber, and trade/build.

[Cuthalion]

Trade four ore for a brick, and build a road from F to the c.

End turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 12 Turn 4: Lentrax.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Lentrax]

Trading 4 stone for a brick.

Build a settlement at QRp

[AvatarVecna]

Settlement built.

[Lentrax]

Whoops. Meant to say that was all I was doing.

I'll end turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 13 Turn 1: Generic-Guy.

[roll0]

You may move the thief, and trade/build at this time.

[Generic-Guy]

J7. Cuthalion, i require wheat and i am not going to risk it to the RNG.
...
I don't trust the RNG.
With the wheat and the stone, i build the great, first city of catan. It is named KPL.
End turn.
...
(How does a City look like?)

[AvatarVecna]

Round 13 Turn 2: Hamste.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.


(How does a City look like?)

Like a target.

[Hamste]

I buy a development card and end my turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 13 Turn 3: Cuthalion.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Cuthalion]

I won't. So there.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 13 Turn 4: Lentrax.

[roll0]

You may move the thief, and trade/build.

[Lentrax]

I will move the robber to K and steal from Generic.

Then I will trade two stone for the resource I need to build a road to DHI.

Then I will end my turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Thief roll: [roll0]

Round 14 Turn 1: Generic-Guy.

[roll1]

You may trade/build.

[Generic-Guy]

A sorry for the delay and a road at PR. End turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 14 Turn 2: Hamste.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Hamste]

I end my turn

[AvatarVecna]

Round 14 Turn 3: Cuthalion.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Cuthalion]

End turn, hope for resources somewhere someday.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 14 Turn 4: Lentrax.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Lentrax]

Pass turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 15 Turn 1: Generic-Guy.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Generic-Guy]

Road Oq, that would be all.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 15 Turn 2: Hamste.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 15 Turn 3: Cuthalion.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Cuthalion]

sorry for the delay

end turn

[AvatarVecna]

Round 15 Turn 4: Lentrax.

[roll0]

You may move the thief, and trade/build.

[Lentrax]

I will move the robber to E.

Then I will see what I get, and decide from there.

[AvatarVecna]

I will move the robber to E.

Then I will see what I get, and decide from there.

A sheep has been transferred from Hamste to you. Actions?

[Lentrax]

I will buy a development card, and end my turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 16 Turn 1: Generic-Guy.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Generic-Guy]

RqS Settelment.

end turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 16 Turn 2: Hamste.

[roll0]

You may move the thief, and trade/build. But first, you'll also need to get rid of some things, for being over 7.

[Hamste]

Huh didn't realize I had missed my turn before. Whoops. I give up 2 wheat and two wood.

Place robber on O steal from Lentrax.

[AvatarVecna]

Huh didn't realize I had missed my turn before. Whoops. I give up 2 wheat and two wood.

Place robber on O steal from Lentrax.

Thievery accounted for. Actions?

[Hamste]

Another development card and end turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 16 Turn 3: Cuthalion.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Cuthalion]

Road and settlement along the northern shores of C to the wood port.

endturn

[AvatarVecna]

Round 16 Turn 4: Lentrax.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Lentrax]

Use my Knight card to move the robber to F. Steal from Hamste.

Buy another development card.

End turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 17 Turn 1: Generic-Guy.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Generic-Guy]

A road L-f build ith the traded wood (and my brick).
End turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 17 Turn 2: Hamste.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Hamste]

I would like a development card please If it is ok I would actually like to do something else as I don't have the card yet (want to make sure it is ok before posting what I want to do).

[AvatarVecna]

Change of mind noted, no PM sent yet. What would you like to do instead?

[Hamste]

I would like to play a monoply card to take all the sheep. That should give me a total of 8 sheep (also that is the most ridiculous development card). I will then trade 6 sheep at my 2:1 harbor for 2 stone and 1 wheat. I will then use 3 stone and 2 wheat to make settlement DIE into a city.

EDIT:I also end my turn

[AvatarVecna]

Round 17 Turn 3: Cuthalion.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Cuthalion]

end turn

[AvatarVecna]

Round 17 Turn 4: Lentrax.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Lentrax]

I will end my turn.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 18 Turn 1: Generic-Guy.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[AvatarVecna]

Round 18 Turn 2: Hamste.

[roll0]

You may trade/build.

[Hamste]

I will play a knight and move the Robber to Q5 and steal from Lentrax if I can (can't check right now if Knights allow me to steal or not)