Preferred Character Round Robin: GREENHILT vs REDCLOAK

[alwaysbebatman]

I haven't had the same character in two match ups at one time before. I hope it doesn't cause confusion.


https://i.imgur.com/pQBI6ai.png https://i.imgur.com/YPP6XpM.png

Vote for the one you prefer.

[Fincher]

Roy Greenhilt.

[alwaysbebatman]

I vote Greenhilt

[Gift Jeraff]

Roy Greenhilt

[DemonRoach]

Redcloak dxfcghvbjk

[Hamste]

Red cloak

[Arkku]

I vote Redcloak.

[Jaxzan Proditor]

Redcloak for the win.

[Synesthesy]

Reddie. The Goblin's Revolution can't stop now.

[2D8HP]

I nod for Eric Greenhilt's big brother.

[littlebum2002]

Redcloak. After all, we've already come this far

[Chei]

Let's get Blackwing in here for a proper standoff.

Redcloak's probably going to take this one by a mile. Sorry, Roy. I like the bland ones, at least.

[Potatomade]

Roy in a heartbeat. Funny, too: I imagine that if Redcloak had run into a guy like Roy early in life, Redcloak could have turned out as one of the good guys.

[Chei]

Roy in a heartbeat. Funny, too: I imagine that if Redcloak had run into a guy like Roy early in life, Redcloak could have turned out as one of the good guys.

Redcloak does feel like what Roy would be if he'd become a cleric. Roy with a dash of Durkon, basically.

[alwaysbebatman]

Redcloak had an impressive surge, 5 votes in a row. But Roy tied it back up 6-All. I'll be surprised if anybody in the round robin gets a crushing defeat.



ROUND ROBIN MATRIX
1st number is Votes For, 2nd is margin,
Red is a Loss
http://www.giantitp.com/forums/images/smilies/oots/redcloak.gif
:belkar: http://i75.photobucket.com/albums/i294/trytoguess/O-Chul.png :vaarsuvius: :elan: :roy:
http://www.giantitp.com/forums/images/smilies/oots/redcloak.gif Redcloak http://i53.photobucket.com/albums/g68/Cats_Are_Aliens/Banners/Redcloak.png 41,1 34,1 24,2 On-
going, 6,0
:roy: Roy Greenhilt On-
going, 6,0 25,-1 On-
going https://i53.photobucket.com/albums/g68/Cats_Are_Aliens/Banners/RoyRage_zpsq7rzrmo6.png

[Laurana]

I don't care much for the goblin priest. My vote goes to Roy Greenhilt

[B. Dandelion]

The illustration is a good one, although it does put me in mind again of how I find it somewhat worrying that Redcloak remembers Roy so well when Roy seldom deigns to notice Redcloak at all, with additional irony points for continuing to complain about how Xykon doesn't remember his name while never referring to his "sidekick" by anything other than his race or class.


Funny, too: I imagine that if Redcloak had run into a guy like Roy early in life, Redcloak could have turned out as one of the good guys.

That too, especially in the Origin prequel.

Roy is a good guy and I like him, but he overlooks "the goblin" at his peril. It's Redcloak for me, unsurprisingly.

[Sylian]

Who was the main character in Start of Darkness? That's right, Redcloak.

[Potatomade]

The illustration is a good one, although it does put me in mind again of how I find it somewhat worrying that Redcloak remembers Roy so well when Roy seldom deigns to notice Redcloak at all, with additional irony points for continuing to complain about how Xykon doesn't remember his name while never referring to his "sidekick" by anything other than his race or class.

To be fair, I don't think Roy and Redcloak have ever even exchanged a single word. I also don't think he's aware of the Crimson Mantle or the Plan at all, without which Redcloak really does just look like one of Xykon's lackeys.

[B. Dandelion]

To be fair, I don't think Roy and Redcloak have ever even exchanged a single word. I also don't think he's aware of the Crimson Mantle or the Plan at all, without which Redcloak really does just look like one of Xykon's lackeys.

True, but to be even fairer, Haley has never spoken to Redcloak either and can't possibly know about the Crimson Mantle or the Plan, but she's demonstrated awareness of him being a threat worth individual concern.

I don't really mean to be critical of Roy, it's just a worrying setup when the strategists on opposing teams have an obvious asymmetrical awareness of each other. It's not really helped when Roy makes remarks like being thrilled at the prospect of a villain who remembers his name -- it's seriously tempting fate.

[alwaysbebatman]

All true. But while Roy is strategist, Haley is "detector of shell games."

[Castamir]

A Mary Sue doesn't stop being one just because of fake difficulties. Go Redcloak!

[alwaysbebatman]

A Mary Sue doesn't stop being one just because of fake difficulties.

Who? You can't possibly mean "average fighter Roy Greenhilt"...

Also: all difficulties are fake. It's a work of fiction. No real difficulties in here!

[Darth Paul]

Two equally sarcastic characters, which I like... I'm going to pick the bald one.

Oh, sorry, the bald fighter.

Greenhilt.

[Potatomade]

A Mary Sue doesn't stop being one just because of fake difficulties.

...huh? Roy's hardly a Mary Sue. He consistently makes bad decisions, is far from the most powerful even in the Order itself, has plenty of genuine character flaws, and isn't inexplicably universally liked by every other character.

Edit: He also isn't able to magic himself out of every bad situation, or he wouldn't have, y'know, died.

Is there any Mary Sue trait that I missed that Roy possesses?

[Draconi Redfir]

i'm biased towards Gobbos. so ima say Redcloak

[alwaysbebatman]

He unexpectedly got his sword back by magic....

That was terrible Deus ex, not an awesome surprise or anything...

[137beth]

At first glance I think I like Roy more. However, I really loved Start of Darkness, probably more than any of the online comics, so I think in the end I'll go with SoD's protagonist, Redcloak.

Besides, if I don't vote for Redcloak now, it will all have been for nothing.

[Potatomade]

He unexpectedly got his sword back by magic....

That was terrible Deus ex, not an awesome surprise or anything...

Meh, him losing the sword in that instance wasn't even a minor plot point yet, so him getting it back via sudden magical blah doesn't even register on the Wesley Crusher Meter.

[alwaysbebatman]

Meh, him losing the sword in that instance wasn't even a minor plot point yet, so him getting it back via sudden magical blah doesn't even register on the Wesley Crusher Meter.

I agree and disagree.

If he hadn't gotten the sword back it could have been a major plot point. Roy really needs that sword, for Durkon*, for Xykon, and for their respective thralls.

An incredibly tiresome plot point that just about everybody was happy to see short circuited by a new-power twist that-- while surprising-- was NOT out of the blue.

I have added [sarcasm] tags in case it wasn't clear what I was getting at before.

[martianmister]

Redcloak, I guess.

[Potatomade]

I have added [sarcasm] tags in case it wasn't clear what I was getting at before.

Well, don't I feel silly now :smalltongue:

[alwaysbebatman]

Redcloak pulls ahead!


ROUND ROBIN MATRIX
1st number is Votes For, 2nd is margin,
Red is a Loss
http://www.giantitp.com/forums/images/smilies/oots/redcloak.gif
:belkar: http://i75.photobucket.com/albums/i294/trytoguess/O-Chul.png :vaarsuvius: :elan: :roy:
http://www.giantitp.com/forums/images/smilies/oots/redcloak.gif Redcloak http://i53.photobucket.com/albums/g68/Cats_Are_Aliens/Banners/Redcloak.png 41,1 34,1 24,2 On-
going, 12,4
:roy: Roy Greenhilt On-
going, 8,-4 25,-1 On-
going https://i53.photobucket.com/albums/g68/Cats_Are_Aliens/Banners/RoyRage_zpsq7rzrmo6.png

[Rogan]

Hmm... Hard choise..

Both had some great moments, like the Arena fight for Roy or say, the destruction (or implosion) of the Resistance for Red

Roy is a good guy, Red a bad one, so thats one point in favor for Roy (from my point of view)
But Red has his Elementals...

Oh well... Roy, take my vote and be happy about it.

[Laurana]

Who was the main character in Start of Darkness? That's right, Redcloak.

I'd say that was Xykon or even Right-Eye.

[Ruck]

I think you'd be wrong, and objectively so, if you said that.

Anyway, I voted Redcloak down the line and see no reason to change that here.

[Second Arrow]

Grumpy pirate versus grumpy bald human?

Redcloak it is.

[drazen]

Roy is in my top 2, so I vote Roy, obviously.

Redcloak is probably at the top of everyone else, though, so it's pretty close.

[lunaticfringe]

Redcloak, because I like him more & Clerics curbstomp Fighters at high level in 3.5.

[Ariko]

Roy Greenhilt

[Joerg]

Redcloak...

[alwaysbebatman]

Redcloak has expanded his margin to 5 votes. 16/11.

[LadyEowyn]

Voting for Redcloak - because, of all the strips in OOTS, this (http://www.giantitp.com/comics/oots0702.html) is the one that consistently makes me happiest.

[Kantaki]

Easy. Redcloak.
Because he needs a hug.:smallbiggrin:

[alwaysbebatman]

18/11 Redcloak

[alwaysbebatman]

It looks like Redcloak has this one in the bag.

There's about 24 hours left and he has a big lead. But then, lots of votes still out there...

[Peelee]

Let's see if I can't start a thing. Roy.

[lothos]

I Vote for Roy Greenhilt.

"By the Power of Greenhilt ! (http://www.giantitp.com/comics/oots1045.html)"

[alwaysbebatman]

18/13 Redcloak. Now it looks a little more sporting...

[alwaysbebatman]

One last reminder: this closes in a few hours. It's not exactly close, but you never know....

If you haven't voted, now is the time.

[alwaysbebatman]

Closed, 18/13 Redcloak.