Long Signature Thread

[akma]

And from my personal observations, threads that get the most comments, from big amount of comments to a small number:
Pointless threads that encourage little feedback (birthday threads are the exception)
Topics that become a debate.
Topics that encourage posters to make up stuff.
Homebrew that is broken mechanically, but the fluff is nice+.
Homebrew that is mechnically ok.

I actully considered switching the places of topics that become a debate and topics that encourage posters to make up stuff. While debate topics more commonly reach high number of posts, topics that encourage people to make up stuff can get a much higher page count, and are much less likely to be locked by a mod.
So it`s commonelity versus power/survivability.