Quote Originally Posted by Debihuman View Post
Cut The Air seems rather pointless. How do you judge the attack against a save? You need a mechanic for this. I recommend removing this and letting the vw save normally or give her a +1 competence bonus to Reflex saves if she is holding a slashing weapon.

Cut The Air (Ex): A vorpal warrior gains a +1 competence bonus to Reflex saves as long as she is holding a slashing weapon.


Debby
It seems rather clear to me. you simply make an attack roll in place of a save and compare it to the dc, a la the mind over body maneuver.

Why do you consider it pointless? It is significanly stronger than your rewrite, and it fits the concept of the vorpal warrior better, IMO.