2015-06-28, 02:41 AM (ISO 8601)
Re: Sane Magic Item Prices
Several items from the PHB are missing: Oil, Healer's Kit, Ball bearings, Caltrops, Hunting Trap, Acid, Holy Water, Alchemist's Fire, Antitoxin, etc.
Also poisons from the DMG (those have a price listed already and give a great baseline - which is much closer to 3.X than your numbers are).
Items based on spells which should be between 150-200% of the appropriate level spell:
Potion of Animal Friendship 150%
Potion of Resistance 150%
Potion of Mind Reading 150%
Potion of Invisibility 150%
Potion of Diminution 220% (duration and no concentration)
Potion of Growth 220% (duration and no concentration)
Potion of Water Breathing 150%
Potion of Clairvoyance 150%
Potion of Gaseous Form 150%
Potion of Flying 150%
Necklace of Fireballs (One bead) 160% for scaling aspect
Potion of Speed 200% (no concentration)
Oil of Slipperiness 150%
Elemental Gem 150%
Oil of Etherealness 150%
In case anyone wants to see my version:
My prices for consumables
(though I made a few alterations - removed ammo. Removed bless from potion of heroism)
Last edited by Kryx; 2015-06-28 at 03:34 AM.