OK, it's been 24 hours since I last got a PM with a vote or vote change, so I'm calling the voting close.
Result: A (No change) (15 votes), with D (Add "must not be an embodiment of Evil" requirement) a close second (11).
Voters: 26 (14 votes is a majority)
votes (top support/total support)
Since only A and D have the potential for majorities, I eliminate all others, and see how that shakes up
Voter Vote Grey Wolf A Kish D Qwertystop D Squire Doodad A The Aboleth A Peelee D Vulkos A Jaxzan Proditor A 3Power D lio45 D InvisibleBison D Throknor A Crusher A Vendanna A Mightymosy A monomer A Joerg A NoHaxJustPi D TheSchleus A Sir_Norbert D Darth Paul A thelivingmonkey D woweed D dmc91356 D Doug Lampert A Ruck A
And because you are all rotters and I hate you, we immediately go into another vote, for thread 13's naming:
Proposal Votes MitD 13: Reasons why it's not a Tarrasque 2 MitD XIII: To Beast or not To Beast! 2 MitD XIII: Take your Protean pills and put your helmet on! 2 MitD XIII: From a work by Edward Lear 1 MitD XIII: Brought to you by Edward Lear 1 MitD XIII: He Has A Waist. 7 MitD XIII: Sometimes we even discuss the creature's species 11 MitD XIII: Grey Wolf, I'm So Sorry 10 MitD XIII: Learning is happening 11 MitD 13: Thar's no shadows! 1 MitD XIII: Where Posters Fear to Tread 1 MitD XIII: Pay No Attention To That Monster Inside the Shadow 1 MitD XIII: Where the Hell Is Athasia? 1 MitD XIII: And Because You Are All Rotters Grey Wolf Hates You 4 MitD XIII: still far from being grown up 1 MitD XIII - The monster's made up and the votes don't matter. 7 MitD XIII: It can also sow discord and cause headaches! 1 MitD XIII: Fit for the big scene 1 MitD XIII...is totally a thing I overheard some guy say 5 Mitd XIII: (Ate) a Baker's Dozen in the Darkness 1 MitD XIII: The beauty in guessing the beast 1 MitD XIII : We're all going to have so much fun! 1
NOTE: Two options mentioning me have been striken out under then "when in doubt, don't" policy of avoiding giving the mods work.
And, as usual, in case someone wants to suggest a previous one:
MitD XIV: Bullhonkey!
MitD VIII: The Gate Gazes Also into You
MitD VIII: The Gate doesn't know you're there either
MitD VIII: The Gate Stares Into You
MitD 8: Maybe he has 8 Tentacles?
MitD VIII: "Maybe I'm two kobolds?"
MitD 8 stew, and porridge, but not babies
MitD VIII: Thar's no shadows!
MitD 8 the sandbox
I'm MitD the Eighth, I am, I am
Mitd 8: The Ocho
MitD: The Nine Hells
MitD IX: The Gate doesn't know you're there either
MitD IX: Thar's no shadows!
MitD 9: Thar's no shadows!
MitD thread: Nein, Ich nicht bin ein Tarrasque
MitD Nein: ich bin kein Snarl Jr.
Summon MitD IX: Conjures 1d4 wild guesses
Summon MitD IX: We're almost epic
Summon MitD IX: Roll on Section 3a
Summon MitD IX: 3d6 Dire Camels in a Swamp
MitD IX: Minnesota Glabrezus vs. Pittsburgh Uvuudaums
MitD IX: Too much obscure clues to find
MitD IX: A wild guess appears!
Monster In The Darkness 9: From Outer Space!
MitD 9: Now That's a Fellowship!
MitD IX: Is it a Tarrasque? Nein!
MitD 9: Fellowship of the Thing
MitD X: A Wild Guess Appears!
MitD X: I'm MitD the Eighth, I am, I am
MitD T(r)ENchant: Political Analysis?
MitD X(s): Unlikely to end the search
MitD: Every X counts
MitD X Files: The truth is out there
MitD X: Monster-san Go
MitD X: Peeking under that umbrella
MitD XI: You May Not Know Exactly What You Are- But I Do
MitD XI: You May Not Know Exactly What You Are- And Neither Do We. Yet
MitD XI: clearly a recursive half green dragon
MitD XI: A Good Man
MitD XI: O-Chul I am your Father
MitD XI: "You Go, Man"
MitD XI: Feeling lucky to have new friends
MitD XI: And so visually complex, too!
MitD XI: ...is a thing I totally overheard some guy say
MitD XI: A Monster with Trenchant Political Analysis
MitD 11: Thar's no shadows!
MitD XI: Unlikely to end the search
MitD XI: "Nod. Get treat"
MitD XI: I personally believe it's a grue or homebrew creature on steroids
MitD XI: Learning Is Happening
MitD XI: one pick should be the right one at this point!
MitD XI: totally a thing I overheard some guy say
MitD XII: I Don't Recognize That Number
MitD XII: A Dozen Possibilities
MitD 12: Thar's no shadows!
MitD XII: Learning is happening.
MitD XII: the Gate Also Gazes Into You
MitD 12: Probably Not a Barbarian
MitD12: Probably not a barbarian, but maybe a dodecahedron
MitD XII: wait, what thread?
MitD XII: "Maybe I'm two kobolds?"
MitD XII: Holmes knew eleven threads ago but Watson still doesn't.
MitD XII: Poirot knew eleven threads ago but Hastings won't believe him.
MitD XII: He Has A Waist
MitD XII: Into Darkness
MitD XII Gods, I don't believe it
MitD XII: Maybe he is two kobolds?
MitD XII: Start of Darkness
MitD XII: Monkeys I ain't
MitD XII: Such an Odd Number, Isn't It?
MITD XII: the mark of the monster
MitD XII: Epic Baby Steps
MitD XII: Under the Umbrella
MitD XII: Learning is happening (most of the time, at least)
MitD XII: This Space Intentionally Left Dark
The rules are a bit simpler for this one: you all get as many votes as you want. Don't PM, just post. If you want to change your vote, specify that you want to take votes away from a suggestion, because otherwise, I assume you just vote for the ones you mention. Highest voted one wins. I get half a vote, in case of a draw.