1. - Top - End - #1281
    Titan in the Playground
     
    Grey_Wolf_c's Avatar

    Join Date
    Aug 2007

    Default Re: MitD XII: This Space Intentionally Left Dark

    OK, it's been 24 hours since I last got a PM with a vote or vote change, so I'm calling the voting close.

    Result: A (No change) (15 votes), with D (Add "must not be an embodiment of Evil" requirement) a close second (11).


    Spoiler: Breakdown
    Show

    Voters: 26 (14 votes is a majority)
    votes (top support/total support)

    A(11/23)
    B(2/7)
    C(2/11)
    D(2/19)
    BC (1/2)
    CD (3/6)
    DH (1/5)
    CDH (1)
    CDI (1/2)
    BDHI (1/1)
    BDGH (1/1)

    Since only A and D have the potential for majorities, I eliminate all others, and see how that shakes up
    Voter Vote
    Grey Wolf A
    Kish D
    Qwertystop D
    Squire Doodad A
    The Aboleth A
    Peelee D
    Vulkos A
    Jaxzan Proditor A
    3Power D
    lio45 D
    InvisibleBison D
    Throknor A
    Crusher A
    Vendanna A
    Mightymosy A
    monomer A
    Joerg A
    NoHaxJustPi D
    TheSchleus A
    Sir_Norbert D
    Darth Paul A
    thelivingmonkey D
    woweed D
    dmc91356 D
    Doug Lampert A
    Ruck A


    And because you are all rotters and I hate you, we immediately go into another vote, for thread 13's naming:
    Proposal Votes
    MitD 13: Reasons why it's not a Tarrasque 2
    MitD XIII: To Beast or not To Beast! 2
    MitD XIII: Take your Protean pills and put your helmet on! 2
    MitD XIII: From a work by Edward Lear 1
    MitD XIII: Brought to you by Edward Lear 1
    MitD XIII: He Has A Waist. 7
    MitD XIII: Sometimes we even discuss the creature's species 11
    MitD XIII: Grey Wolf, I'm So Sorry 10
    MitD XIII: Learning is happening 11
    MitD 13: Thar's no shadows! 1
    MitD XIII: Where Posters Fear to Tread 1
    MitD XIII: Pay No Attention To That Monster Inside the Shadow 1
    MitD XIII: Where the Hell Is Athasia? 1
    MitD XIII: And Because You Are All Rotters Grey Wolf Hates You 4
    MitD XIII: still far from being grown up 1
    MitD XIII - The monster's made up and the votes don't matter. 7
    MitD XIII: It can also sow discord and cause headaches! 1
    MitD XIII: Fit for the big scene 1
    MitD XIII...is totally a thing I overheard some guy say 5
    Mitd XIII: (Ate) a Baker's Dozen in the Darkness 1
    MitD XIII: The beauty in guessing the beast 1
    MitD XIII : We're all going to have so much fun! 1

    NOTE: Two options mentioning me have been striken out under then "when in doubt, don't" policy of avoiding giving the mods work.

    And, as usual, in case someone wants to suggest a previous one:
    Spoiler
    Show

    MitD XIV: Bullhonkey!
    MitD VIII: The Gate Gazes Also into You
    MitD VIII: The Gate doesn't know you're there either
    MitD VIII: The Gate Stares Into You
    MitD 8: Maybe he has 8 Tentacles?
    MitD VIII: "Maybe I'm two kobolds?"
    MitD 8 stew, and porridge, but not babies
    MitD VIII: Thar's no shadows!
    MitD 8 the sandbox
    I'm MitD the Eighth, I am, I am
    Mitd 8: The Ocho
    MitD: The Nine Hells
    MitD IX: The Gate doesn't know you're there either
    MitD IX: Thar's no shadows!
    MitD 9: Thar's no shadows!
    MitD thread: Nein, Ich nicht bin ein Tarrasque
    MitD Nein: ich bin kein Snarl Jr.
    Summon MitD IX: Conjures 1d4 wild guesses
    Summon MitD IX: We're almost epic
    Summon MitD IX: Roll on Section 3a
    Summon MitD IX: 3d6 Dire Camels in a Swamp
    MitD IX: Minnesota Glabrezus vs. Pittsburgh Uvuudaums
    MitD IX: Too much obscure clues to find
    MitD IX: A wild guess appears!
    Monster In The Darkness 9: From Outer Space!
    MitD 9: Now That's a Fellowship!
    MitD IX: Is it a Tarrasque? Nein!
    MitD 9: Fellowship of the Thing
    MitD X: A Wild Guess Appears!
    MitD X: I'm MitD the Eighth, I am, I am
    MitD T(r)ENchant: Political Analysis?
    MitD X(s): Unlikely to end the search
    MitD: Every X counts
    MitD X Files: The truth is out there
    MitD X: Monster-san Go
    MitD X: Peeking under that umbrella
    MitD XI: You May Not Know Exactly What You Are- But I Do
    MitD XI: You May Not Know Exactly What You Are- And Neither Do We. Yet
    MitD XI: clearly a recursive half green dragon
    MitD XI: A Good Man
    MitD XI: O-Chul I am your Father
    MitD XI: "You Go, Man"
    MitD XI: Feeling lucky to have new friends
    MitD XI: And so visually complex, too!
    MitD XI: ...is a thing I totally overheard some guy say
    MitD XI: A Monster with Trenchant Political Analysis
    MitD 11: Thar's no shadows!
    MitD XI: Unlikely to end the search
    MitD XI: "Nod. Get treat"
    MitD XI: I personally believe it's a grue or homebrew creature on steroids
    MitD XI: Learning Is Happening
    MitD XI: one pick should be the right one at this point!
    MitD XI: totally a thing I overheard some guy say
    MitD XII: I Don't Recognize That Number
    MitD XII: A Dozen Possibilities
    MitD 12: Thar's no shadows!
    MitD XII: Learning is happening.
    MitD XII: the Gate Also Gazes Into You
    MitD 12: Probably Not a Barbarian
    MitD12: Probably not a barbarian, but maybe a dodecahedron
    MitD XII: wait, what thread?
    MitD XII: "Maybe I'm two kobolds?"
    MitD XII: Holmes knew eleven threads ago but Watson still doesn't.
    MitD XII: Poirot knew eleven threads ago but Hastings won't believe him.
    MitD XII: He Has A Waist
    MitD XII: Into Darkness
    MitD XII Gods, I don't believe it
    MitD XII: Maybe he is two kobolds?
    MitD XII: Start of Darkness
    MitD XII: Monkeys I ain't
    MitD XII: Such an Odd Number, Isn't It?
    MITD XII: the mark of the monster
    MitD XII: Epic Baby Steps
    MitD XII: Under the Umbrella
    MitD XII: Learning is happening (most of the time, at least)
    MitD XII: This Space Intentionally Left Dark


    The rules are a bit simpler for this one: you all get as many votes as you want. Don't PM, just post. If you want to change your vote, specify that you want to take votes away from a suggestion, because otherwise, I assume you just vote for the ones you mention. Highest voted one wins. I get half a vote, in case of a draw.

    Grey Wolf
    Last edited by Grey_Wolf_c; 2019-04-14 at 07:56 PM.
    Interested in MitD? Join us in MitD's thread.
    There is a world of imagination
    Deep in the corners of your mind
    Where reality is an intruder
    And myth and legend thrive
    Quote Originally Posted by The Giant View Post
    But really, the important lesson here is this: Rather than making assumptions that don't fit with the text and then complaining about the text being wrong, why not just choose different assumptions that DO fit with the text?
    Ceterum autem censeo Hilgya malefica est