Quote Originally Posted by heavyfuel View Post
Q 97 - Cont

OK, so let's say the Cleric is blind, deaf, and not trained in Spellcraft. Does he still know he got hit by a Dispel Magic?
Unclear by current RAW, much like 3.5.

Two things to note however:

1) Sauce for the PCs is sauce for the NPCs - a player who uses undetectable dispels to discreetly strip buffs probably shouldn't be upset if NPCs do the same to the party.
2) The likely result of such tactics becoming commonplace is that everyone starts running around with permanent Arcane Sight or the like, and then constantly telling the GM "I check my buffs again!"