2020-01-08, 08:39 AM (ISO 8601)
Re: Mafia/WW Red Atlantic Cruise
Well, that was fun. Occasionally baffling, but fun.
In retrospect, I should have thought more about why Xi's actions didn't start showing up in our thread untill I asked why they weren't there, instead of just dismissing it with 'lol I'm paranoid again'
Also in retrospect, Xihirli's claimed "Russian Roulette" role was a bit too out there compared with all the other roles which were mostly standard seers, baners, watchers, etc, but it's not like any of us noticed at the time.
Also, does anyone care if I post the Russian QT? (Or the other Russian QT without Xihirli in it?)
Yeah, we totally thought that was a convoluted but clever plan to get us to think one of us was a counterspy and therefore get us to kill one of our own... ironically we did decide to kill Xihirli but failed due to priority.
Originally Posted by gac3
Then we decided there probably weren't counterspies because
a) Caerulea said that there were no American spies, in a tone which made me think it was true. (Which I guess it was...)
b) I tried to post a 'secret' action in a PM that contradicted what I said in our QT, and Caerulea still posted the result in put QT. So I figured if we couldn't keep our actions secret, then there was probably no spy.
c) We thought maybe Basket couldn't kill Xihirli because we couldn't kill our own spies?
Then gac died and we were like "yep, an American plot all along, guess there are no moles"
Is the announcement thing also how Xi got her fake night action result posted in our QT last night?
Originally Posted by Caerulea
Also, that priority thing explains a lot. (Basket, as our assassin, killed Caerulea because it was worth a try, and killed Erin to fish for the madman.) And I guess this means if we had tried to kill someone on the last night, Basket would still be alive... Not that it matters too much in the long run.
I'm Chaotic Good! Ish!