Middle Earth WW:The Return of the King

[Duck999]

I'm going with Luizeu.
1. OMGUS on day 2 shouldn't be happening, especially when a wolf was lynched day one to allow for better analyzing day 2.
2. His reason is not that strong in voting for ThePhantom, since he could always just lynch ThaPhantom later on if it really becomes an issue. It seems like a wolf throwing an early vote on another wolf to gain some trust later on. The bandwagon just turned out poorly for Luizeu.

[Luizeu]

I'm going with Luizeu.
1. OMGUS on day 2 shouldn't be happening, especially when a wolf was lynched day one to allow for better analyzing day 2.
2. His reason is not that strong in voting for ThePhantom, since he could always just lynch ThaPhantom later on if it really becomes an issue. It seems like a wolf throwing an early vote on another wolf to gain some trust later on. The bandwagon just turned out poorly for Luizeu.

Duck, it was Day1. I didn't think my vote would get traction. I'm glad it did. And I didn't vote for ThePhantom alone, if he was lynched it was because people bought the idea.
I've never thought I would be criticized for voting on a wolf. That's a first on my history here. Well, why dont you all keep a close watch on me and see how the next days go about huh? How many wolves should I [sarcasm] "bus" [/sarcasm] until I'm considered one of the good guys?

[Murska]

Duck, it was Day1. I didn't think my vote would get traction. I'm glad it did. And I didn't vote for ThePhantom alone, if he was lynched it was because people bought the idea.
I've never thought I would be criticized for voting on a wolf. That's a first on my history here. Well, why dont you all keep a close watch on me and see how the next days go about huh? How many wolves should I [sarcasm] "bus" [/sarcasm] until I'm considered one of the good guys?

All of them.

Welcome to the position where early success means that if you ever falter again during the entire game, you'll get people trying to lynch you because obviously you are just a wolf that's been bussing everyone on their team. It's an interesting spot to be on.

[Silent_Interim]

First off, OMGUS? I'm not familiar with the term.

Second off, I'm more inclined to agree with Meta than Sprig right now. I'm not entirely trusting Luizeu right now, but I don't think his arguments are entirely bad. It was day one. Luizeu isn't at all off the hook with me, but I'm more suspicious of Sprig right now.

[Logic]

I'm feeling Sprig more than Luizeu. Right now, I believe Luizeu. Meanwhile, something about Sprig is tripping my suspicions. Meta I have pegged at slight-wolf-lean, but nothing firmer than that.

As for everyone voting Phantom, I give them all a slight town lean for the moment. Luizeu is the only one that I think warrants more than a second glance, and my second glance says he's a desperate-to-be-believed townie.

And Silent? OMGUS is Oh My God You Suck.
The act of returning a vote on someone that just voted for you, often for no apparent reason other than that they voted for you.

[Pelican]

I'm actually feeling Silent Interim as the most likely wolf candidate right now. I'm inclined to agree with Sprig that Meta's elevated language and overstated arguments give me a bad vibe--it's not enough for a vote, as this could of course just be the way Meta likes to speak in a discussion, but overall the interaction between these two has me feeling a little better about Sprig and a little cautious about Meta. As for Luizeu, I don't think his current behavior matches his wolf behavior in previous games.

I could definitely see SI trying to play the new(ish) player card to slide by as a wolf, and his responses so far seem very carefully constructed so as not to be argumentative, which seems like a good way to avoid the limelight and keep people feeling good about not voting for you.

[Elenna]

I'm disinclined to suspect Silent Interim too much right now, since he is new. Sprig, on the other hand, is not particularly new IIRC and I don't see a more experienced player suggesting that the wagon was entirely composed on wolves.

Sprig, if you think that

There is no chance they are all wolf.

then why did you agree with Mrs McGinty?

[Shadow11615]

Sprig, because everyone else is doing it. I like bands and I like wagons. Therefore, I like bandwagons.

[Cuthalion]

Spoiler: Vote count

Show

Sprig -Snerk, Meta, Murska, Ramsus, Mrs. McGinty, Silent Interim, Logic, Elenna, Shadow11615
Luizeu -Thematthew, Fleeing Coward, Duck, Pelican, and Lex!, and GAAD!
Meta -Sprig

Oh yeah Day is over gimme a few.
----

The hobbits argued back and forth.

So... we should kill more bad guys, right?

Yeah, I think so.

Hey, we killed a bad guy yesterday! So we should be able to do it again.

Hmm, what do you guys think we should do?

Ooh! I have an idea. Let's kill one of the people who helped us, you know, kill the bad guy! Because... because anyone who kills a bad guy is bad, because, you know, they like killing people?

Oh, yeah. That makes sense.

---

Sprig was killed.

Spoiler: Sprig was...

Show

Malva "Headstrong" Brandybuck, a plain villager.

Spoiler: Did not vote :(

Show

Askthepizzaguy
Rain Dragon
Luizeu
Syldar
Choxorn
Beck
Legato
TFT

Spoiler: Have not voted for two days...

Show

Beck

Spoiler: Player list

Show

Phantom- Shagrat, plain wolf. Lynched D1.
Zar Peter, Legolas, mason, killed N1.
Sprig, Malva "Headstrong" Brandybuck, villager, lynched D2.

Lex
Duck
Ramsus
Elenna
Shadow11615
Silent Interim
thematthew
Askthepizzaguy
Logic
Pelican
Rain Dragon
Meta
Luizeu
Fleeing Coward
GAAD
Syldar
Snerk
Choxorn
Beck Novo
Mrs. McGinty
Legato
TFT
Murska

Night 2 has begun. You have 24 hours.

[Lex-Kat]

If Visor didn't make a mistake with the vote count, I might secretly not even have a vote and just don't know it yet since 3 people voted for Legato.

Vote count: Luizeu -Thematthew, Fleeing Coward, Duck, Pelican

Oh yeah Day is over gimme a few.

Apparently my vote doesn't count today. Perhaps it's a secret gimmick where a random player's vote isn't counted.

[Cuthalion]

Apparently my vote doesn't count today. Perhaps it's a secret gimmick where a random player's vote isn't counted.

Oh yeah, totally.

[GAAD]

Mine wasn't counted either. I did vote, and I wasn't put down for forgetting to vote, but my vote neither counted nor was posted. Someone should keep track of this. We've got some vote manipulation.

[Cuthalion]

Nono, sorry, that's just me.

[Lex-Kat]

Awww. *Hugs Cuthalion*

[Snerk]

Too many active players not voting.

[Luizeu]

Would the votes that were not counted change the outcome?
If they did, you should off me and bring Sprig back

[Lex-Kat]

There would need to be three more uncounted votes. I don't think they are there.

[Askthepizzaguy]

That's on me, guys. I was out filing a marriage application and christmas shopping.

It will not happen again for the remainder of play. I promise.

[Ramsus]

You filled out marriage applications for seven other people as christmas presents? Are those even returnable?

[Askthepizzaguy]

So long as divorce remains legal, yes.

[Legato Endless]

I'm here and I won't miss anymore phases, but as previously mentioned the month's grind does what it does.

[Cuthalion]

Night's over? I'll let Visor handle this if he can, sorry!

[Visor]

I'm here now (sorry, family things to deal with.)

Update time soon.

Night 2

More like Prince Dead. amirite

thematthew has died. He was the Prince of Dol Amroth, baner.

Spoiler: Player list

Show

Phantom- Shagrat, plain wolf. Lynched D1.
Zar Peter, Legolas, mason, killed N1.
Sprig, Malva "Headstrong" Brandybuck, villager, lynched D2.
thematthew, Prince of Dol Amroth, baner, killed N2.

Lex
Duck
Ramsus
Elenna
Shadow11615
Silent Interim
Askthepizzaguy
Logic
Pelican
Rain Dragon
Meta
Luizeu
Fleeing Coward
GAAD
Syldar
Snerk
Choxorn
Beck Novo
Mrs. McGinty
Legato
TFT
Murska

Day 3 has begun. You have (at least 48) hours.

[Syldar]

Kill the duck. He voted for luizeu for reasoning that amounted to "he voted on a wolf on day one." Plus, I have a good feeling about that tower. Not so much about the duck.

[Silent_Interim]

Kill the duck. He voted for luizeu for reasoning that amounted to "he voted on a wolf on day one." Plus, I have a good feeling about that tower. Not so much about the duck.

That's... not an accurate representation of what Duck said. And where does TFT come into it?

[Ramsus]

Hmmm, what group of people would kill someone fairly new like thematthew this early?

[Pelican]

I've got a handful of town reads right now but not too many strong wolf reads. Think I'm going to follow through with a hunch from earlier and vote Elenna.

[Meta]

Hmmm, what group of people would kill someone fairly new like thematthew this early?

Pretty sure they're mason hunting. Look at how the first wagon felt like they had to defend their votes and the result of the first night-kill. I didn't want to put it out there day 2, but twice is no coincidence.

[Logic]

Hmmm, what group of people would kill someone fairly new like thematthew this early?

thematthew doesn't seem that new to me. I don't recall for sure, but I think he is fairly experienced in werewolf, just not specifically on this forum.

I'm feeling Pelican as a more likely wolf thus far.

[Fleeing Coward]

I'm going to go with Luizeu again.
His comment last night just adds to my gut feeling that he's a wolf trying abit too hard to look like town.