[MtG] GitP Regulars as Magic the Gathering Cards

[khadgar567]

I'll trade cards with someone - you just need to give me something to work with.

loves warlock has problem with creating class fluff and always calls paladin duo holy dunce isthere any thing you need

[Snowbluff]

Okay, I got back from work. What are the changes I need to make to the list.

I'll trade cards with someone - you just need to give me something to work with.

I'll trade with you. I'm Snowbuff. The Snowbluffiest.

[Jormengand]

Traitorous Blackguard 2BB
Creature - Human Knight R
Whenever Traitorous Blackguard becomes paired with a creature called Loyal Paladin, exile them, and then meld them into Amoral Incarnation
4/2
/
Amoral Incarnation (C)
Creature - Eldrazi Knight R
Creatures you control have protection from each colour that they are not. (For example, nonwhite creatures you control have protection from white)
6/6

Feather Flurry 1R
Sorcery - R
Feather Flurry deals 1 damage to target creature or player. Then, if you own feather flurry and both own and control a creature called Nivix Neophoenix, exile it and this card and meld them into Neo, Phoenix Lord.
At the beginning of your end step, if two or more creatures entered the battlefield under your control this turn, you may return feather flurry from your graveyard to your hand.
/
Neo, Phoenix Lord (UR)
Creature - Phoenix Wizard R
Flying, Prowess
Whenever you cast your second spell each turn, you may return target card from your graveyard to your hand.
Whenever your second creature enters the battlefield under your control each turn, you may return target card from your graveyard to your hand.
4/5

Rinar's Tower 1UU
Enchantment - R
2: Draw a card, then discard a card. Then, if you both own and control both Rinar's Tower and an enchantment called Xulda's Alleyway, exile them both and meld them into Xuldarinar's Nightmare.
Madness comes at a price. Knowledge comes with a reward.
/
Xuldarinar's Nightmare (B)
Creature - Nightmare Horror R
Whenever a player discards a card, put a 2/2 black horror creature token onto the battlefield under your control.
2: Draw a card, then discard a card.
Everything comes with a reward if you try hard enough.

The Felblade 8
Legendary Artifact - Equipment MR
Equip 3
The Felblade costs 3 less for each creature you control but don't own.
Equipped creature gets +9/-4 and has Indestructible.
Whenever the Felblade becomes equipped to a creature called "Fel Lord", if you both own and control both cards, exile them and meld them into Red Fel, Lord of Evil
/
Red Fel, Lord of Evil (BR)
Legendary Creature - Wizard MR
Indestructible
When Red Fel, Lord of Evil deals damage to a creature, gain control of it.
BR: Red Fel deals 1 damage to target creature.
13/1

Knight of the Dragoncrest 4WW
Creature - Human Soldier MR
First Strike, Lifelink, Vigilance, Protection from white, from black, from blue and from green.
T: If you both own and control Knight of the Dragoncrest and a creature called Primordial Dragon, exile them and meld them into Draconium, Dragon Champion.
His only goal is to find his master. All else is secondary.
/
Draconium, Dragon Champion (WR)
Legendary Creature - Human Dragon Knight MR
First Strike, Flying, Lifelink, Trample, Vigilance, Protection from white, from black, from blue and from green.
XRR: Draconium, Dragon Champion deals X damage to each creature your opponents control and each opponent.

Sanguine Sword 1
Artifact - Equipment U
Equip 1
Equipped creature gets +1/+0 and has lifelink
Whenever Sanguine Sword becomes equipped to a creature called Field Sanguinist, if you both own and control both cards, exile them and meld them into Elric's Hospitaller
/
Elric's Hospitaller (W)
Creature - Human Knight U
First Strike, Lifelink
Whenever Elric's Hospitaller deals damage to a creature, prevent the next X damage that would be dealt to each creature you control where X is the amount of damage dealt in this way..
Now, he's trying to save every damned creature he can find.
3/1

Serpent's Seal 5
Artifact - U
Whenever a creature you control deals lethal damage, you gain 5 life.
T: If you both own and control Serpent's Seal and an enchantment called World Serpent's Curse, exile them both and meld them into Jörmungandr's Brood
/
Jörmungandr's Brood
Creature - Snake U
Creatures you control have First Strike and Deathtouch.
Creatures you don't control get -2/-2.
3/1

Samurai Shrimp 1UB
Creature - Fish Samurai C
Bushido 2
Whenever Samurai Shrimp is returned to your hand by the effect of a card named "Ninja Prawn", if you control both cards, exile them and meld them into Seahorse Outrider.
2/2
/
Seahorse Outrider (UB)
Creature - Fish Soldier C
Seahorse Outrider can't be blocked.
When Seahorse Outrider deals combat damage to a player, the next spell you cast costs 2 less.
2/2

Crazed Gladiator BB
Creature - Human Soldier R
Creatures have "2: Gain control of this creature. Any player may activate this ability".
Whenever you both own and control Crazed Gladiator and a creature called Crazed Ringmaster, exile them and meld them into Snowbluff.
Viewer discretion advised.
1/1
/
Snowbluff (BR)
Legendary Creature R
2: Gain control of target creature or spell on the stack.
Current situation unknown.
2/2

Training Monastery
Land R
WT: Add CR to your mana pool.
RT: Add CW to your mana pool.
T: If you both own and control Training Monastery and an enchantment called Monastery Training, exile them both and meld them into Monastery Monk
/
Monastery Monk (WR)
Creature - Human Monk R
Double strike.
Whenever Monastery monk becomes blocked or stops being blocked, it deals damage equal to its power to blocking creature.
4/2

(Completed up to post #72)

[Amechra]

Alright, here's a few (also one for me, since I'm a narcissist.)





EDIT: The Warlock Khadgar should be 2B, not 3B. I'll fix that when I have the chance.

[Elricaltovilla]

Sanguine Sword 1
Artifact - Equipment U
Equip 1
Equipped creature gets +1/+0 and has lifelink
Whenever Sanguine Sword becomes equipped to a creature called Field Sanguinist, if you both own and control both cards, exile them and meld them into Elric's Hospitaller
/
Elric's Hospitaller (W)
Creature - Human Knight U
First Strike, Lifelink
Whenever Elric's Hospitaller deals damage to a creature, prevent the next X damage that would be dealt to each creature you control.
Now, he's trying to save every damned creature he can find.

This is pretty sweet. I'm not familiar with the merge mechanic, but it seems to make sense. I think you forgot to define how you determine X and what the Power and Toughness of the Hospitaller are.

Serpent's Seal 5
Artifact - U
Whenever a creature you control deals lethal damage, you gain 5 life.
T: If you both own and control Serpent's Seal and an enchantment called World Serpent's Curse, exile them both and meld them into Jörmungandr's Brood
/
Jörmungandr's Brood
Creature - Snake U
Creatures you don't control have First Strike and Deathtouch.
Creatures you don't control get -2/-2.
3/1

This one gives Deathtouch and First Strike to creatures you don't control? Shouldn't it be creatures you do control?

[Jormengand]

Fixed and fixed.

[Red Fel]

The Felblade 8
Legendary Artifact - Equipment MR
Equip 3
The Felblade costs 3 less for each creature you control but don't own.
Equipped creature gets +9/-4 and has Indestructible.
Whenever the Felblade becomes equipped to a creature called "Fel Lord", if you both own and control both cards, exile them and meld them into Red Fel, Lord of Evil
/
Red Fel, Lord of Evil (BR)
Legendary Creature - Wizard MR
Indestructible
When Red Fel, Lord of Evil deals damage to a creature, gain control of it.
BR: Red Fel deals 1 damage to target creature.
13/1

Huh. Okay, that's pretty neat. Let me see that I follow it all.

We start with this:



Thanks again, Draconium.

Now, the Felblade is obviously designed to work with the Fel Lord, so let's go with that. Here's my first concern, because I'm not sure how the turns play out - can you play an artifact after the Fel Lord attacks? Because his ability to control creatures he hits only lasts until the end of the turn. If not, then the cost reduction on Felblade really only applies if it's played immediately after Fel Lord, given that his ability triggers as soon as he enters play, or if you use the Fel Lord's BR ability. Notably, if you use the BR ability, the cost reduction really isn't a lot - spend two mana to take control of a creature, reduce the Felblade's cost by three, net saving of one. Still, I love the flavor of the mechanics working together.

So let's see what happens. The Fel Lord is a Legendary Demon Wizard (Demon, not Devil, for shame, Drac), 4/5, with the ability to damage and take control of creatures. The Felblade is a +9/-4 artifact that makes its wielder indestructible. When combined, they form yours truly, with the powers of both - a 13/1 Indestructible Legendary Wizard with the ability to damage and take control of creatures. On the one hand, their combination is merely equal to the sum of its parts, rather than something more; on the other, having the advantage of the artifact without the ability to lose the artifact is a really nice touch. And I have a weakness for this melding mechanic.

Overall? Do likey, Jormengand, do likey.

Now pardon me while I update my sig again.

[Blue Ghost]

Demon and Devil mean different things in MtG than in DnD. While DnD devils are LE schemers, MtG devils are CE tricksters and tend to be pretty low grade. MtG demons often fill the role of DnD devils. Red Fel in MtG would be a Demon.

[Elricaltovilla]

I kind of want to go back and rewrite World Serpent's Curse as an Epic spell but I don't know the mechanics on those very well.

[Blue Ghost]

I kind of want to go back and rewrite World Serpent's Curse as an Epic spell but I don't know the mechanics on those very well.

I'd recommend against it. Epic is not a good mechanic. Preventing yourself from playing any other cards for the rest of the game is not fun.

[Jallorn]

Huh. Okay, that's pretty neat. Let me see that I follow it all.

We start with this:



Thanks again, Draconium.

Now, the Felblade is obviously designed to work with the Fel Lord, so let's go with that. Here's my first concern, because I'm not sure how the turns play out - can you play an artifact after the Fel Lord attacks? Because his ability to control creatures he hits only lasts until the end of the turn. If not, then the cost reduction on Felblade really only applies if it's played immediately after Fel Lord, given that his ability triggers as soon as he enters play, or if you use the Fel Lord's BR ability. Notably, if you use the BR ability, the cost reduction really isn't a lot - spend two mana to take control of a creature, reduce the Felblade's cost by three, net saving of one. Still, I love the flavor of the mechanics working together.

So let's see what happens. The Fel Lord is a Legendary Demon Wizard (Demon, not Devil, for shame, Drac), 4/5, with the ability to damage and take control of creatures. The Felblade is a +9/-4 artifact that makes its wielder indestructible. When combined, they form yours truly, with the powers of both - a 13/1 Indestructible Legendary Wizard with the ability to damage and take control of creatures. On the one hand, their combination is merely equal to the sum of its parts, rather than something more; on the other, having the advantage of the artifact without the ability to lose the artifact is a really nice touch. And I have a weakness for this melding mechanic.

Overall? Do likey, Jormengand, do likey.

Now pardon me while I update my sig again.

There is a second main phase after the combat phase, that would be when you can gain the benefit of creatures you control but don't own. Also from what I can figure, the card is intentionally designed so that you can ping things, take them, and lower it's cost, that's why it's 3 mana reduced. If it reduced less, it would be bad, and if it reduced more it would be too good. Now, exploring it in conjunction with it's partner is one thing, however, and exploring it in the broader context of DnD is another. There are a number of cards, many red, that can cause cards to swap control, even permanently, thus providing a significant cost reduction for a card that is incredibly good (as long as you have creatures with a solid butt). Crater Elemental, for instance, is a 0/5 for three, which has the ability to boost its power to 8 as long as creatures you control have total power 8 or more. So equip him and for three mana each turn you have a 17/1 Indestructable creature.

I don't think it's broken, however, because its Legendary, so its a really good card, the kind you can build a deck around (and being colorless, Green would also like it, with Green's ramp enabling the ability to cast it reasonably) but not a broken one. Because most creatures equipped with it will fall to a -x/-1 effect or counter.

And he's a Demon because Demons are more powerful than Devils in MtG. MtG doesn't have Lawful vs. Chaotic, and Devils are generally red, while Demons are always Black (sometimes others as well) as the quintessential example of Black's love of Power as its own end and purpose.

That said, the Meld mechanic should call the new Melded card a token or it should be the flip side of the card with the Mechanic instead of a new card. Personally, I'd say the latter, since then you can resurrect it should it die (though this one, being indestructable, is far more likely to be exiled than sent to graveyard, others might not have that benefit). Also, then you don't have a card that people can't play unless they happen to chance upon what will be a valuable second card, since there's no may in the ability, meaning that if you equip Fel Lord with the Felblade, but don't happen to own a copy of the Meld (whether full card or token), you are forced to exile both and can't put anything into play. Under tourney rules at least. In casual a proxy is usually tolerated.

[Red Fel]

Demon and Devil mean different things in MtG than in DnD. While DnD devils are LE schemers, MtG devils are CE tricksters and tend to be pretty low grade. MtG demons often fill the role of DnD devils. Red Fel in MtG would be a Demon.

... I accept this appellation. For now.

[Blackhawk748]

Ok, i cant find the freakin link to the MtG Card maker, so these dont actual cards atm

Spoiler: Neophoenix

Show

Spoiler: Red Fel

Show

Spoiler: Snowbluff

Show

Im pretty sure these are in line with current cards, im mostly concerned about mana cost.

[Red Fel]

Ok, i cant find the freakin link to the MtG Card maker, so these dont actual cards atm

The link you want is MTG Cardsmith. And you really, really might consider using smaller images. Wowzers.

I like mine. It's simple and accurate - I really would rather have a mindless minion taking the hits for me.

Or someone I dislike who can't do anything about it. I'm flexible.

[Blackhawk748]

The link you want is MTG Cardsmith. And you really, really might consider using smaller images. Wowzers.

I like mine. It's simple and accurate - I really would rather have a mindless minion taking the hits for me.

Or someone I dislike who can't do anything about it. I'm flexible.

Yes, yes they are. It always seem to be that way with pics i find, the perfect ones are freakin huge Thanks for the link, ill get them shrunk in a bit.

I thought you would, its basically a Palisade Giant that hits harder.....and flies.

Edit: Fixed it. They are now actual cards.

[ThePurple]

People be mistreatin' me for being purple and callin' me colorless, so take this!

[Blue Ghost]

Ok, i cant find the freakin link to the MtG Card maker, so these dont actual cards atm

Spoiler: Neophoenix

Show

Spoiler: Red Fel

Show

Spoiler: Snowbluff

Show

Im pretty sure these are in line with current cards, im mostly concerned about mana cost.

Blazing Phoenix: Phoenixes are always red. Destroying all creatures is a white effect, though black has dabbled in it.
Fel Guard: Both vigilance and the damage redirection ability are firmly white. See Palisade Giant for templating.
Yandere's Wrath: This is very undercosted. Doom Blade was as efficient as removal got back in the day, and they've dialed back the power of removal significantly in recent years. This effect would probably cost 4 mana at uncommon nowadays, or as much as 6 at common.


A card for Elric:

[Blackhawk748]

Blazing Phoenix: Phoenixes are always red. Destroying all creatures is a white effect, though black has dabbled in it.
Fel Guard: Both vigilance and the damage redirection ability are firmly white. See Palisade Giant for templating.
Yandere's Wrath: This is very undercosted. Doom Blade was as efficient as removal got back in the day, and they've dialed back the power of removal significantly in recent years. This effect would probably cost 4 mana at uncommon nowadays, or as much as 6 at common.

Ya i saw, but Neo doesnt use a ton of red, though i could make it a black......

You are not wrong, though there are a few that aren't (Bartel Runeaxe), its mostly that i don't see Fel as White, and bad guys need bodyguards too.

I was comparing it to Exile, which also gives you Life=to targets Toughness, but ill change it.

Edit: Its now Black Flame Phoenix, its the same but Black now and Yandere's Wrath costs 2BB

[Jallorn]

Blazing Phoenix: Phoenixes are always red. Destroying all creatures is a white effect, though black has dabbled in it.
Fel Guard: Both vigilance and the damage redirection ability are firmly white. See Palisade Giant for templating.
Yandere's Wrath: This is very undercosted. Doom Blade was as efficient as removal got back in the day, and they've dialed back the power of removal significantly in recent years. This effect would probably cost 4 mana at uncommon nowadays, or as much as 6 at common.


A card for Elric:

That is a really interesting mix of mechanics, and I like it. A lot. I don't think it's one I'd really play, not my style, but it's interesting to consider the possible strategies around it.

Ya i saw, but Neo doesnt use a ton of red, though i could make it a black......

You are not wrong, though there are a few that aren't (Bartel Runeaxe), its mostly that i don't see Fel as White, and bad guys need bodyguards too.

I was comparing it to Exile, which also gives you Life=to targets Toughness, but ill change it.

Exile is also limited to nonwhite and attacking, and still costs one more mana.

[Blackhawk748]

Exile is also limited to nonwhite and attacking, and still costs one more mana.

Ya i was like "Hmmm limited target, but you get life out of it. Ah screw someone will tell me if i'm wrong lol" and Lo.

[Draconium]

Okay, Jorm, I got inspired to make a card for you... Or at least one based off of your name...

[Elricaltovilla]

A card for Elric:

Well that looks fun. Tricky to play with both prowess and transform, but potentially very nice.

It's interesting seeing what people have made for me. None of it has been what I'd expected to see.

[Snowbluff]

A snowbluff is a geological feature, but it is now a bluff with snow on it but a snow in the shape of a bluff.

Spoiler: Snowbluff

Show

Hahaha nice. This is a thanks. I analyses it below.

Yandere's Wrath: This is very undercosted. Doom Blade was as efficient as removal got back in the day, and they've dialed back the power of removal significantly in recent years. This effect would probably cost 4 mana at uncommon nowadays, or as much as 6 at common.

Color costed instant speed exile is 3 mana, maybe as BBB or BB with a penalty (anguished unmaking costs 3 life).

[JNAProductions]

So no one wants to make one for me?

[Blue Ghost]

Color costed instant speed exile is 3 mana, maybe as BBB or BB with a penalty (anguished unmaking costs 3 life).

Note that both Swords to Plowshares and Path to Exile are quite a bit more powerful than the current standard. Anguished Unmaking is probably the strongest unconditional removal available right now, but it is two colors.

So no one wants to make one for me?

Any requests for what you want on yours?

[JNAProductions]

Something something crafting something something homebrew.

I'm not sure how to translate this into MtG terms, but I'm a pretty prolific homebrewer for 5E, so something in that vein.

[Snowbluff]

Something something crafting something something homebrew.

I'm not sure how to translate this into MtG terms, but I'm a pretty prolific homebrewer for 5E, so something in that vein.

I was thinking of doing an artificer who makes copies of stuff.

[JNAProductions]

I was thinking of doing an artificer who makes copies of stuff.

That'd be cool.

[Draconium]

So no one wants to make one for me?

Actually, you already got one. It's just not all fancy like some of these others.

[Blue Ghost]

Something something crafting something something homebrew.

I'm not sure how to translate this into MtG terms, but I'm a pretty prolific homebrewer for 5E, so something in that vein.

Something like this, maybe?