Results 61 to 90 of 101
Thread: Fun Learning 4e
-
2019-08-14, 07:08 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2012
Re: Fun Learning 4e
Originally Posted by GreatDragon
That monster defenses scale faster than PC attack bonus matters in 4e play as I learned (the hard way) with my first 4e character, a PHB1 half-elf cleric built before "Divine Power" and the change in how non-human PC racial ability bonuses are handled. This character had a 17 WIS at 1st level for a +3 attack bonus, and with some admittedly bad dice luck, I was hitting less than 55% of the time and it was no fun. My GM let me rebuild for the 18 WIS and +4 attack bonus and my to-hit rate and therefore ability to contribute to the combats increased and I had more enjoyable time.
4e PBH1 Cleric (and Paladin and Warlock) are sometimes described as "V shaped classes" meaning that they have two ability scores that their powers key off of and a 3rd ability used for "riders." In cleric's case it's WIS and STR with most of the riders (damage bonus or similar) coming from CHA. You can build and play a cleric that has both WIS and STR powers, but it tends to be easier to contribute to the action when you focus on one or the other and start with a post-racial modifier of an 18 in your "attack stat" and a 12+ in CHA for the riders. This is less obvious at low level, but as the game progresses, the number you need to roll on the d20 to overcome the enemies defenses creeps up. Starting with a +4 modifier (aka an 18) helps balance out the fact that enemy defenses grow faster than your attack bonus.
P.S. It doesn't hurt a cleric that two of the better skills - insight and perception are both keyed off of WIS.
-
2019-08-14, 10:03 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2017
Re: Fun Learning 4e
You probably don't need a crossbow since you have ranged at-will powers. You probably want to pick up a holy symbol and the standard adventurer's kit. There is encumbrance somewhere, but I don't recall exactly where in the PHB 1. Its something pretty high that is usually enough for most characters.
The stat that you use for an attack is dependent on the power that you use. For Basic Attacks, this depends on the weapon, but some classes will make both weapon and implement attacks with other stats. For example, Paladin has some Cha-based melee attacks.
The half-level that you add to most of your d20 rolls isn't affected by the min-1 rule. You don't get the +1 level bonus to attacks until you hit level 2. If you do some legerdemain on your stats, you might want to increase your strength to increase the odds that you will hit with your melee powers.
Monsters, including NPCs, have defenses that determined by the writer, not necessarily by a strict formula. There tends to be some correlation with equipment (so a mage enemy probably has a lower AC than the fighter bodyguard), but in the end it is whatever the writer thought it should have to be a proper balanced encounter. The wizard does have a shield utility power. IIRC, it is an interrupt power that gives an AC boost. A mage monster may also have a shield power, but it doesn't have to work the same way. Everything about the power would be located in the monster's stat block; there is no looking up what the effects of a particular spell are, like you would do in 3e or 5e for monster spellcasters.
-
2019-08-14, 02:49 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2009
- Location
- Euphonistan
- Gender
Re: Fun Learning 4e
Just would like to point out that 3e is actually the outlier in this regard. oD&D, AD&D (1e and 2e), and 5e all have monsters and some NPCs using different rules than PCs. For instance in pre 3e D&D not all humans have class levels but in 3e all humans have class levels (even if it is just commoner). In some the differences are not quite as much (though often in those editions that is partially due to there not being too many details in character and monster creation for the most part).
3e is really the odd one out where making monsters and NPCs are so similar and actually use the same resources and then compounds that with having way more details to plug in than other editions. It is also the only one that actively really requires that NPCs have certain levels of equipment in order to fit their CR if we are talking about NPCs which thankfully in other editions I can just add magic items I want them to have and not just to get the numbers I want.A vestige for me "Pyro火gnus Friend of Meepo" by Zaydos.
http://www.giantitp.com/forums/shows...5&postcount=26
-
2019-08-15, 03:46 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2018
- Location
- Portland, Oregon
- Gender
Re: Fun Learning 4e
Is the Cleric done?
(I'll edit in Equipment when on Tablet)
If so, I'll start working on figuring out Paragon Level.
I don't see much difference for Battle Cleric: other than more focus on damage spells?
********
Humm. With Monsters being more "what the Author wants", I'm glad I'm not trying to DM this, right now.
Originally Posted by MeeposFire
In 3x, Because PCs, NPCs, and Monsters used similar Mechanics, I had less problems figuring out Monster CRs and even ECLs for unusual Character Concepts. (Monster Manual Minotaur as Barbarian PC)
I like 5e, because it's fairly easy for new players to learn, and a lot of the Subclasses are neat; but their Monsters are no-where near "balanced" - being either super easy to deal with (Giant Rats) or hitting way over their Weight Class. (Intellect Devourer)
*****Now, from what I understand, 4e shines the most in the Tactical aspects of the game (once one understands Game Mechanics) - which isn't something that can be done over a Forum.
I'm not sure how I'm going to figure that part out, since everyone near me is doing either 5e or Retro Clones.
*****************
Some of the Reviews for PF2 are compairing this to 4e (my quick peek looked rather 5e, but would need to actually play to be sure), but I'd rather hear the opinions of those Experienced with 4e on whether or not this is true.My Knowledge, Understanding, and Opinion on things can be changed
No offense is intended by anything I post.*Limited Playtest Group - I'm mostly Stuck in the White Room.
*I am learning valuable things, here. So thanks, everyone!
-
2019-08-15, 08:20 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2015
Re: Fun Learning 4e
An NPC is going to be built on a structure of what they do within the encounter. Mage-types are typically Artillery if they focus on blasting, or Controllers if they focus on statuses, forced movement, etc. The one in this example throws down sleep effects, so we’ll safely peg them as a controller. This determines their base stats which you then modify with ability scores.
Now, how the Evil Mage gets these numbers is deliberately abstracted. Any spells or wards that would be in effect before the PCs walk in (like Mage Armor) are just going to be baked into that number. If you want a shorter defensive boost, like a one-off reactive Shield, that would get listed as a power.
Also, while I wouldn’t necessarily drop the crossbow, be aware that it’s not likely to be that useful. Your ranged at-wills will be more effective in most situations. It’s only when you need significant range that the crossbow will have advantage.
-
2019-08-15, 10:57 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2015
Re: Fun Learning 4e
I want to respond to this by quoting some posts from the other thread asking about 4E, with some editing focus on 4E DMing and to emphasize certain points:
As an experienced DM of 2nd ed., 3.0/3.5, and 4E, I fully agree with these comments. I want to add is that 4E's combat math is extremely robust and this allows the XP budget idea to actually function exactly as intended. I can literally throw together an encounter on the fly, mid-session, just by rapidly looking up equal-level monsters, picking some that seem to fit, and throwing an appropriate number of them out on the battlefield: with 5 players that would be 5 monsters for a standard encounter, 7-8 for a hard encounter. I can easily riff on those numbers by adding Elite monsters (counts as 2) and/or adding in minions (4 minions for every monster replaced). I've done this countless times over the years when my players throw me curveballs and the encounters just work.
-
2019-08-15, 01:41 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2009
- Location
- Euphonistan
- Gender
Re: Fun Learning 4e
I have the other view after DMing all of these versions of D&D that is one of the huge reasons why I HATE Dming 3e. It requires way more work to make something interesting or fun on the Dm side that it is the only edition I will refuse to DM ever again. I did a 3e campaign from 1st level to 20th level so I do have some experience in the area and my dislike of it comes from an actual experience rather than just inferences on how I think I would like it.
A vestige for me "Pyro火gnus Friend of Meepo" by Zaydos.
http://www.giantitp.com/forums/shows...5&postcount=26
-
2019-08-15, 03:03 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Sep 2018
- Location
- Seattle, WA
Re: Fun Learning 4e
One important difference between Paragon Paths and Prestige Classes from 3.5 is that you get all the benefits from your Paragon Path in addition to everything you're getting from your base class. They're more like a subclass from 5e in that respect.
The PHB only has a couple of PPs for each class, but the Power series (Divine Power for Clerics) has tons of cool and flavorful options. Another book (can't remember which off the top of my head; maybe PHB II?) has racial Paragon Paths that aren't tied to your base class at all. Or if you're interested in multiclassing, if you've taken all four multiclassing feats for a base class, you can use that base class as your Paragon Path, choosing a total of 3 powers at the points you would normally get them from a PP.Originally Posted by Darths & DroidsOptimization Trophies
Looking for a finished webcomic to read, or want to recommend one to others? Check out my Completed Webcomics You'd Recommend II thread!
Or perhaps you want something Halloweeny for the season? Halloween Webcomics II
-
2019-08-15, 03:06 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2018
- Location
- Portland, Oregon
- Gender
Re: Fun Learning 4e
@tiornys: I also go back to 2e. Liked 3x better than that. Skipped 4e (no players and no extra money, mostly) and can mostly get 5e to work.
@MeeposFire. Without any experience DMing 4e, and it being rather unlikely, I can't make any comparisons.
But, between 3x and 5e, I got better "Balanced" Encounters in the former.
Spoiler: Cleric List of Options
Level 1 At-Will Prayers
Lance of Faith Cleric Attack 1
Priest’s Shield Cleric Attack 1
Righteous Brand Cleric Attack 1
Sacred Flame Cleric Attack 1
Level 1 Encounter Prayers
Cause Fear Cleric Attack 1
Divine Glow Cleric Attack 1
Healing Strike Cleric Attack 1
Wrathful Thunder Cleric Attack 1
Level 1 Daily Prayers
Avenging Flame Cleric Attack 1
Beacon of Hope Cleric Attack 1
Cascade of Light Cleric Attack 1
Guardian of Faith Cleric Attack 1
******
Human: +2 to one Ability Score.
One Bonus At-Will Power from Class:
Edit = One Bonus Skill from Class. History
+1 to Fortitude, Reflex and Will defenses.
Characteristic: Tolerant.
Armor Class: 16 (Chainmail)
(There doesn't seem to be any Starting Equipment, where is Starting Gold and Cost lists?)
Skills: Religion (plus three) Diplomacy, Insight, Heal.
Class Feature Prayers
Channel Divinity: Divine Fortune Cleric Feature
Channel Divinity: Turn Undead Cleric Feature
Healing Word Cleric Feature
*****
Looks like I’ve mostly already chosen: Devoted Cleric.
Francis O'Mally. Human (male)
Cleric (divine leader)
Deity: Bahamut.
One Bonus Feat: Human Perseverance +1 to saves.
First level Feat:Astral FireArmor of Bahamut
Point Buy (link) results: 16,14,12,12,11,11.
Str 12 Dex 11 Con 16 Int 11 Wis 16 Cha 12
Hit Points: 28 (12 +10 Con score). (+5/lv)
Bloodied: 14 Hp
Healing Surges: 7 +3 Con = 10 (+7 hp/surge)
Skills: (Race) Arcane. (Class) Religion; Insight, Heal, Diplomacy
Passive Insight: 10 + 0 (half level) + 3 Wis = 13
Passive Perception: 10 + 0 (half level) + 3 Wis = 13 (?)
(or are skills without proficiency still usable?)
Fortitude Defense: +3 Con +1 race = 14
Reflex Defense: +1 Dex = +1 race = 12
Will Defense: +2 class + 3 Wis +1 race = 16
I think I'll go for: team bonuses.
At Will: Priest’s Shield 1[W] + Strength modifier damage = 1d8+1.
Sacred Flame is +3 vs. Reflex for 1d6 + 3 radiant damage
Lance of Faith deals 1d8 + Wisdom modifier radiant damage, so your average damage should be 1d8+3 = 8 (+3 from Wisdom,
Encounter: Healing Strike +3 vs. AC for 2d8 + 1 radiant damage (+1 Strength)
Daily: Guardian of Faith +3 vs. Fortitude for 1d8 + 3 radiant damage.
Utility: Divine Fortune and Turn Undead
Rituals: Gentle Repose and Identify.
EquipmentChainmail +6 AC. 40# 40 gp. -1 check. -1 speed.
Mace +2 Prof. 5 gp. 6#. 1d8 blunt.
Versatile +1 DMG when used two handed.
Light Crossbow +2 Prof. 25 gp. 4#. 1d8 P.
Holy symbol 10 gp. 1#.
Standard Adventurer's Kit. 30#. 15 gp.
Backpack, Bedroll, Flint and Steel, Belt Pouch, 10 days Trail Rations, 50' Hemp Rope, 2 Sunrods, Waterskin.
Ok. Currently carrying 81#. (Still looking for Encumbrance)
5 gold left.
Spoiler: Faux Combat
I actually did figure that waking up was all my Cleric could do that round, which is why I put in Monologue-ing Evil Mage.
Cleric casts Lance of Faith!
Holy Symbol Implement:
Half Level 0 + 3 Wis = +3 to hit (?)
Cleric sees that his spell has failed to kill (assuming hit: 1d8+3 = 8 Average damage) the Evil Mage, but maybe has caused the Minion/s to hesitate in attacking him.
Making sure that he has hisshieldmace ready (Chainmail = AC 16) Cleric moves up to the Evil Mage, and tries to knock some Sense into him!
Half level 0 + 2 Proficiency (mace) + 1 Str = +3 to 1d20 roll. (Still)
Is the Cleric done?
If so, I'll start working on figuring out Paragon Level.Last edited by Great Dragon; 2019-08-17 at 10:04 AM.
My Knowledge, Understanding, and Opinion on things can be changed
No offense is intended by anything I post.*Limited Playtest Group - I'm mostly Stuck in the White Room.
*I am learning valuable things, here. So thanks, everyone!
-
2019-08-15, 04:07 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2017
Re: Fun Learning 4e
Looks done-sh. I recommend that you put stuff in your character sheet since there are a few things on it that you'll want to keep track of (like your Bloodied value and Passive Perception) that are generally self-explanatory (the computations are given on the character sheet). This will also get you to compute your actual skill bonuses.
Your attack bonus for all of your weapon (melee) powers will be +3 as you computed in your vignette and your implement (spell) powers will also be +3 (again as you computed). There is a spot on your character sheet to record this so you don't forget (again it has the math breakdown on the sheet). You will find that your implement powers will be more accurate since AC tends to be a little higher than the other defenses. You should only be using a basic mace attack for opportunity attacks since priest's shield does an attack + a side effect. Likewise, your crossbow will only be used for longer ranges since your implement powers will likely be more accurate, more powerful, and have extra effects.
I recommend that you play a bit before you try to advance your character to paragon tier since jumping straight there is likely to cause decision paralysis. You will need to advance to level 11, which will involve picking new feats at every even level, new attack powers every odd level (encounter powers at 3 and 7 and daily powers at 5 and 9), utility powers at levels 2 and 6, ability boosts at levels 4 and 8 (and a blanket boost at 10, I think), before you pick your paragon path at 11. As has been said before, you get benefits from your paragon path and those from your class. The paragon path will give you new powers while the class will replace its existing powers at higher levels (similar to retraining).
-
2019-08-15, 06:04 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2015
Re: Fun Learning 4e
The issues with 5e enemy balance is one of the main reasons I haven't tried to DM that edition. As a player I prefer 4E (because I love tactical combat) but am willing to play pretty much any edition of D&D; as a DM I will run 4E, period.
Spoiler: Faux Combat
I actually did figure that waking up was all my Cleric could do that round, which is why I put in Monologue-ing Evil Mage.
Cleric casts Lance of Faith!
Holy Symbol Implement:
Half Level 0 + 3 Wis = +3 to hit (?)
Cleric sees that his spell has failed to kill (assuming hit: 1d8+1 = 6 Average damage) the Evil Mage, but maybe has caused the Minion/s to hesitate in attacking him.
Making sure that he has hisshieldmace ready (Chainmail = AC 16) Cleric moves up to the Evil Mage, and tries to knock some Sense into him!
Half level 0 + 2 Proficiency (mace) + 1 Str = +3 to 1d20 roll. (Still)
Is the Cleric done?
If so, I'll start working on figuring out Paragon Level.
@Jaeda, the blanket boost to abilities is at level 11 (and 21).
-
2019-08-16, 12:27 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Sep 2018
- Location
- Seattle, WA
Re: Fun Learning 4e
One nice thing about 4e (that's often house ruled or variant ruled into other editions) is that every time you level up, you can change one decision you made about the character. Power or feat isn't working out like you hoped, or you just found a cooler one in a different book? Wish you had a few more healing encounter powers? Next time you level up, swap one power or feat for another of the same level. Bribing the DM with pizza no longer required (but always appreciated).
Originally Posted by Darths & DroidsOptimization Trophies
Looking for a finished webcomic to read, or want to recommend one to others? Check out my Completed Webcomics You'd Recommend II thread!
Or perhaps you want something Halloweeny for the season? Halloween Webcomics II
-
2019-08-16, 03:08 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2015
Re: Fun Learning 4e
Since this is more if a thought exercise than an attempt at creating actual characters for play, go ahead and jump ahead to paragon. In its own way, it will show how forgiving 4e is when it comes to leveling up and making you plan ahead. Which is to say it’s a lot more forgiving than 3e with a lot more choices as you progress than 5e.
For reference, the universal chart of leveling is found on page 29 of PHB1. Now that we have that to follow along, let’s go Paragon. And for the sake of ease, let’s do things in lumps rather than individually build up 10 levels.
First off, there’s your ASIs. You get +1 to two different scores at 4th and again at 8th. Then upon hitting 11th level and, thus, paragon tier, another +1 to all of them.
Next up is picking a Paragon Path. Occasionally these will have prereqs, but they’re rarely complicated. Usually it’s just race, or requiring training in a skill. None of the four PHB1 cleric paths have any requirements, so pick freely. If you want to multi class, then things get more complex. Once you’ve picked your path, note the 2-3 features it gives you, and a new encounter power.
Next up, let’s add feats. So that list of feats that piqued your interest but didn’t make the immediate cut. Take five of them. Now, here’s a spot where order of operations can get a little tricky, but this is an exercise in how well this works. Feats rarely require each other as prerequisites but they do often have ability score requirements. Be conscious about which ones you now have access to with your ASIs but don’t sweat it. Retraining specifically lets you swap out for feats you qualify for even if you didn’t at the time.
Once you’ve done that, pick one from the paragon tier list. Technically you could pick another one from the heroic tier list, but odds are your 7th favorite heroic feat isn’t going to be as good as your favorite paragon feat.
Now that feats are settled, on to powers. You get one from each of the following lists:
2nd level Utility
3rd Level Encounter
5th level Daily
6th level Utility
7th level Encounter
9th level Daily
10th level Utility
And once those are recorded, it’s on to updating numbers. Add 1/2 level wherever it applies (attacks, defenses, skills, initiative). Note that you do not add 1/2 level to damage. Modify anything affected by your increased ability scores, if you haven’t already. Add HP. Clerics get 5/level after first, so that’s a fairly easy add. Then recalculate bloodied value and healing surge value (half and a quarter of your new total, respectively.)
Now to handle misc items that adjust as you level. Humans don’t have any, but some races do. The Dragonborn breath weapon being a PHB1 example. Clerics have a couple, Turn Undead and Healing Word. Damage/healing and burst size for both of those go up by 11th level.
After that, the next big thing is magic items. Now there are plenty of ways to adjust the game for those who aren’t keen on a heavy reliance on magic items. For now, let’s stick with baseline expectations for the sake of the exercise. All magic items have a level that corresponds to character levels. PCs will typically have one magic item of their level, one lvl+1 and one lvl-1. So feel free to pick three of those. In particular, look at a weapon, a holy symbol to improve your implement attacks, armor to improve your AC, and a neck item to improve all your other defenses.
-
2019-08-16, 03:16 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2013
Re: Fun Learning 4e
To be clear here: if you start at level 5, say, you’d get level 6, 5, and 4 items, and a level 4 item’s worth of gold. The standard allotment if you’re adventuring is actually 4 items per 5 levels plus a set amount of gold, and each time you get an item, it would be somewhere from level +1 to level +4. For simplicity’s sake, I’d suggest one item per level, more or less.
-
2019-08-16, 06:58 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2018
- Location
- Portland, Oregon
- Gender
Re: Fun Learning 4e
Thanks, folks!!
Ok, I did borrow the book, and got some things figured out and written down.
First, I realized that I had made a Mistake, in that in order to have the Armor of Bahamut feat, I couldn't have Astral Fire.
Everything else is the same, though.
Originally Posted by NomGarret
Next up is picking a Paragon Path. Occasionally these will have prereqs, but they’re rarely complicated. Usually it’s just race, or requiring training in a skill. None of the four PHB1 cleric paths have any requirements, so pick freely. If you want to multi class, then things get more complex. Once you’ve picked your path, note the 2-3 features it gives you, and a new encounter power.
Next up, let’s add feats. So that list of feats that piqued your interest but didn’t make the immediate cut. Take five of them. Now, here’s a spot where order of operations can get a little tricky, but this is an exercise in how well this works. Feats rarely require each other as prerequisites but they do often have ability score requirements. Be conscious about which ones you now have access to with your ASIs but don’t sweat it. Retraining specifically lets you swap out for feats you qualify for even if you didn’t at the time.
Once you’ve done that, pick one from the paragon tier list. Technically you could pick another one from the heroic tier list, but odds are your 7th favorite heroic feat isn’t going to be as good as your favorite paragon feat.
Now that feats are settled, on to powers.
And once those are recorded, it’s on to updating numbers. Add 1/2 level wherever it applies (attacks, defenses, skills, initiative). Note that you do not add 1/2 level to damage. Modify anything affected by your increased ability scores, if you haven’t already. Add HP. Clerics get 5/level after first, so that’s a fairly easy add. Then recalculate bloodied value and healing surge value (half and a quarter of your new total, respectively.)
Now to handle misc items that adjust as you level. Humans don’t have any, but some races do. The Dragonborn breath weapon being a PHB1 example.
Clerics have a couple, Turn Undead and Healing Word. Damage/healing and burst size for both of those go up by 11th level.
After that, the next big thing is magic items. Now there are plenty of ways to adjust the game for those who aren’t keen on a heavy reliance on magic items. For now, let’s stick with baseline expectations for the sake of the exercise. All magic items have a level that corresponds to character levels. PCs will typically have one magic item of their level, one lvl+1 and one lvl-1. So feel free to pick three of those. In particular, look at a weapon, a holy symbol to improve your implement attacks, armor to improve your AC, and a neck item to improve all your other defenses.
(Answered. Thanks !!)
<Cleric Move - again !>Last edited by Great Dragon; 2019-08-20 at 03:29 PM.
My Knowledge, Understanding, and Opinion on things can be changed
No offense is intended by anything I post.*Limited Playtest Group - I'm mostly Stuck in the White Room.
*I am learning valuable things, here. So thanks, everyone!
-
2019-08-17, 11:51 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2013
Re: Fun Learning 4e
+1 to two abilities on the 4s and 8s (i.e. 4, 8, 14, 18, 24, 28) and to all at 11 and 21. If you stick with the same two abilities, they'll get 8 boosts, for a total of +4 to each of their modifiers. Many Epic Destinies also feature a +2 boost to one or two abilities, as well.
-
2019-08-18, 01:20 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2008
- Location
- New Zealand
- Gender
Re: Fun Learning 4e
Note that from level 13, the encounter and daily powers from your class replace earlier ones. You have to remove a lower level encounter power of your choice when you choose your level 13 encounter power, and a lower level daily for your level 15 daily, etc. You're essentially replacing weaker powers with stronger ones. This doesn't apply to powers from your paragon path or epic destiny. Also, some powers remain relevant and it may be better to not replace them. Cause Fear for example is very good in a melee heavy party as it makes the enemy provoke opportunity attacks, which scale with your allies.
Also, I would say you're spending too many utility powers on healing. In actual play your two Healing Word uses will be enough for most fights, with maybe Mass Cure Light Wounds being the only power worth a utility slot IMO. Utility powers that can be used once per encounter are often more useful, and more fun because you get to use them more often. Sanctuary (PHB1) at 2, Holy Celerity (Divine Power) at 6, and Recall Ally (Divine Power) or Shielding Word (PHB1) at 10 are all worth looking at I think.
PHB3 introduces "Skill Powers" which are replacement utility powers you can take instead of your class utility powers, but which require training in a particular skill. There are some interesting choices in the list of powers there.Last edited by Excession; 2019-08-18 at 01:27 AM.
-
2019-08-18, 03:31 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2015
Re: Fun Learning 4e
In my experience, fights rarely last longer than 4-5 rounds, so once you hit Paragon tier you'll have enough encounter and daily powers that you will rarely need to use your At-Wills. This means once you have 4 or so, you start replacing them rather than adding even more to the stack and definitely never using them. It's also worth noting that you can always choose to learn lower level powers in place of a new level, though I rarely would.
As far as power choice, this is an area where in practice you will often build for party synergy as you level. Sure, that's a lot of healing powers, but now the other PCs can turn their attention elsewhere. Now the Fighter can skip the power that lets her spend a healing surge and take the one that grants Combat Advantage, thus letting the Rogue land more Sneak Attacks.
-
2019-08-18, 04:34 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2013
Re: Fun Learning 4e
As a note- this also depends on what kind of powers you have (and this is part of different classes feeling different).
By way of example- Melee Rangers will often take off-action (meaning non-standard action) attacks for their Encounter powers, because Twin Strike (the Ranger At Will) is so good that a Minor Action Encounter attack + Twin Strike is generally better than their Standard Action Encounter powers. Rogues also end up with some great off-action encounter powers. Warlords have several very good interrupts starting at low levels, and might have a mix of Standard and off-action Encounter powers. Most Controllers, on the other hand, have significantly better Encounter powers than their At Wills, and so will only use At Wills in an unusually long combat. Ditto for Clerics, though if you're using the full set of resources, there's an excellent level 1 Strength based immediate action encounter power (from Dragon magazine) and a strong level 3 Immediate Encounter power (from Heroes of Shadow).
Ultimately, by level 11, you'll have 4 Encounter attack powers (level 1, 3, 7, and your paragon path one at 11), and 3 Daily attack powers (1, 5, and 9). If you're playing with themes, you might have another. As a Cleric, that means that you'll probably rarely use your at wills, but that's not always so for other classes.
-
2019-08-18, 05:26 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2008
- Location
- New Zealand
- Gender
Re: Fun Learning 4e
I find two problems with that. First, there are cleric utility powers that are better at preventing damage than Cure Minor Wounds is at healing, especially when Cure Minor is a daily power and others are encounter.
Second, having one character do all the healing isn't great synergy in my experience. Characters can be too spread out for powers to reach them, or the cleric can go down in the first round because the enemies are fighting smart. I think if the group needs another one per day heal, having the Fighter spend a feat to multi-class into Warlord (or the Wizard into Cleric, etc.) will always be better than Cure Minor Wounds.
Choosing only healing spells also locks you out of the more interesting (IMO) game of tactical positioning and interrupts that other utility powers use.Last edited by Excession; 2019-08-18 at 05:28 PM.
-
2019-08-18, 06:55 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2015
Re: Fun Learning 4e
Don't get me wrong, I certainly think there are better choices. I'm just using this thread as a teaching tool without always going quite so deep. In practice, I would hold off on most higher level choices until we knew what the rest of the party was going to be, at the very least. And even then, I think it's better to make choices as you go rather than pre-build. Treat it as a practice run rather than a serious build, is my point.
-
2019-08-18, 07:08 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2008
- Location
- New Zealand
- Gender
Re: Fun Learning 4e
Agreed, making choices as you go, and informed by how the game is going, is the better option.
I think even the choice of class and role should be done as a group. While a group of four strikers can work, by killing everything before it kills you, a group of four leaders can just be slow and annoying. Looking forward can be useful to make levelling up easier or to make sure you don't miss a pre-req for some nice feat later on, but it doesn't need to be set in stone.
I also like to pick skills so there isn't much overlap. Three people training Diplomacy, Arcana, or a few others is rarely useful. Having out of combat roles and specialisations can be nice as well as in-combat. That said, leaving all the talking up to a party face can itself get boring; I have had good fun playing a Wizard with no real social skills but who tended to be the first to talk in awkward silences, and tended to be honest to a fault. Based on a few Intimidate rolls she was also quite scary even when not trying to be.Last edited by Excession; 2019-08-18 at 07:09 PM.
-
2019-08-18, 08:26 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2018
- Location
- Portland, Oregon
- Gender
Re: Fun Learning 4e
(on phone)
Wow !
Quite a bit to read, and ponder.
The Cleric is indeed my first 4e Character, and as such, I fully expect to be informed that there are better options. And I'm very open to suggestions on what to swap out (and for what), and Suggestioned changes for what is currently listed.
The Cure Line: I read as being "free Healing Surges" and so it made sense for my Cleric to grab those. But, a "prevent damage" power that happens more often (Encounter vs Daily) is a valid choice.
What Dragon Magazine# is the power found in?
The other powers and options might need to wait until the books arrive for me to look up.
Thanks for all the help.
I'll check in ASAP.Last edited by Great Dragon; 2019-08-19 at 04:59 PM.
My Knowledge, Understanding, and Opinion on things can be changed
No offense is intended by anything I post.*Limited Playtest Group - I'm mostly Stuck in the White Room.
*I am learning valuable things, here. So thanks, everyone!
-
2019-08-18, 09:57 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2008
- Location
- New Zealand
- Gender
Re: Fun Learning 4e
Not costing a healing surge is a nice feature, but it's not a huge difference. The people most likely to be taking damage will tend to have a decent number of surges. Increasing a character's defences, or moving them out of harms way, can make a bigger difference I think.
There is also the ritual "Comrades' Succor" from Dragon 380 which can be used to move healing surges around the party. Though you overall lose one healing surge from the party when using it. It might be accurate to say that ritual bends the healing surge economy to breaking point, but it's nothing that an Artificer can't do with their class features. That's a level 1 ritual btw, so you could pick that up using the Cleric's class feature IIRC.
The powers I listed are all from PHB1 or the splatbook "Divine Power". Skill powers come from PHB3 mostly.Last edited by Excession; 2019-08-18 at 09:58 PM.
-
2019-08-18, 10:03 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2013
Re: Fun Learning 4e
Cure is a free surge, effectively. Clerics don't have great U2 selections, but the best might actually be a PHB power- Shield of Faith. Which seems lousy, but it was errataed to a Minor action rather than a Standard. If you pop that early in a combat, you've got a very nice chance of eliminating at least 1 hit against an ally, and possibly more.
-
2019-08-19, 12:10 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2009
- Location
- Euphonistan
- Gender
Re: Fun Learning 4e
Cleric is good though I personally prefer warlord or bard though that is more to do with them being more movement focused and more attack granting options (also basic attack options). Cleric has more healing and as I recall defensive buffs.
A vestige for me "Pyro火gnus Friend of Meepo" by Zaydos.
http://www.giantitp.com/forums/shows...5&postcount=26
-
2019-08-19, 05:19 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2018
- Location
- Portland, Oregon
- Gender
Re: Fun Learning 4e
<Cleric Moved - Again !>
Originally Posted by MeeposFire
I would not mind if people wanted to make their own Character/s (showing level progression) and posted them here.
Using all the books is quite alright, just please remember to list which book something can be found in.
Spoiler: optionalOnce there are at least one of each major type, we can have fun (Faux) virtually throwing Monsters at the PC group , so that I (and anyone reading) can get a better picture of how the different powers work, how they can be used in a team, and if there are overlapping powers and boosts for doing so. (try to keep this to minor PbP, or we will most likely need to move it.)
I suppose that a Battle Area will be needed if we do this, and I suggest a Battleship-like Grid.
A-T across the top for Columns
01-20 down the side for Rows
Anyone going beyond these is considered Out of Bounds, even if they have enough Range to still affect the Battle. This is because it can be confusing for exactly which direction Columns Aa-Ta actually is (Left of A or Right of T?), and what numbers apply for Above Row 01.Last edited by Great Dragon; 2019-08-24 at 01:15 PM.
My Knowledge, Understanding, and Opinion on things can be changed
No offense is intended by anything I post.*Limited Playtest Group - I'm mostly Stuck in the White Room.
*I am learning valuable things, here. So thanks, everyone!
-
2019-08-21, 01:28 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2015
Re: Fun Learning 4e
Here are my thoughts on your heroic-tier power selections, considering PHB options only:
SpoilerFirst off, I want to mention that for most characters in 4E, accuracy is a very high priority. More so than in most editions of D&D.
Hitting factors into your damage contribution, but far more importantly it also lets you do things besides damage. On average, your encounter powers do cool/powerful things on hits and nothing on misses. If something happens regardless of hitting it's usually not that powerful. Daily powers are better in this regard but there is still often a massive reward for hitting.
You've chosen to be Wis primary and you've already made the excellent decision to boost that starting stat to 18 (instead of 16 as in your first pass). That fact, plus the fact that your Str is only 11, is why I will almost exclusively be ignoring the Str-based powers.
Attack Powers:
At Wills: your options are limited and you've chosen as well as you can here. If you could lose the Str-based power and take a different option (as is possible with other books in play) I would recommend that.
E1: Healing Strike is Str-based, and therefore significantly less likely to do anything than a Wis-based power. I recommend Divine Glow instead.
This gives you something Wis-based that is safe to do in melee, it deals a decent amount of damage in an area, and it offers a nice offensive boost to your allies. Cause Fear can be more powerful, but it's trickier to use well and it doesn't help with one of the chronic issues for a Wis-based PHB Cleric (getting trapped in melee).
D1: Guardian of Faith is strong provided you can combo it with teammates to effectively restrict enemy movement. I'm willing to assume you have a team where this is true--but if not, Beacon of Hope is an excellent and more flexible alternative. Weakened is a very strong effect for proactively preventing damage.
E3: Daunting Light is a strong choice. Good damage and a decent Effect that happens whether you hit or miss. Even better if you have a Rogue in your party (Rogues care more than anyone else about having combat advantage).
D5: Spiritual Weapon is a great choice for lots of bonus damage during an encounter. Just be careful about getting stuck in melee, as the repeated attacks will provoke opportunity attacks (because the power is Ranged).
E7: Because your Charisma is relatively low, I think Searing Light is a much stronger option for you than Break the Spirit. It's a little less damage, but Blinded is a -5 to melee and ranged attacks plus you force the target to grant combat advantage and prevent them from benefiting from combat advantage. That's a much stronger effect than -1 to attacks and well worth the loss of 2 average damage.
D9: Here's the exception. Divine Power's Effect line might be strong enough to be worth using even though it is Str-based. However, this does give some incentive to want to be maintaining a magical melee weapon in addition to your magical holy symbol, which cuts down on the available wealth you have for other items. Both Flame Strike and Blade Barrier are good alternatives--I think. I don't remember what the powers do in their original form; I only have access to the post-errata versions right now.
Utility powers:
U2: I agree with the comments about Shield of Faith being generally better than Cure Light Wounds, especially in the post-errata version where it only costs a minor action.
U6: Cure Serious Wounds is very strong healing, but it comes at a serious cost of taking your standard action. For that reason I might prefer Bastion of Health even though your Charisma modifier is low--a third minor action healing power can come in very handy. This is a very tough call in a vacuum--group composition and the power choices and playstyles of the other characters would likely form the deciding factor in this decision.
U10: Ok, Mass Cure Light Wounds is finally a healing power that I think is worth spending a standard action on. That said, Shielding Word is extremely likely to cancel one hit per encounter, which adds up to a lot of damage prevented over the course of a day. You're in good shape either way.
Given the other choices you've been making so far, it might be worth revisiting your stat line instead of your power selection. You can use both Str-based and Wis-based powers effectively if you start each stat at a minimum of 16 and keep boosting both of them. Here's a possible L1 stat lineup for this:
Str 16 Con 12 Dex 8 Int 10 Wis 16+2=18 Cha 12
If you go this route, I would recommend spending a feat on Weapon Proficiency: Bastard Sword. This gives you a +3 proficiency weapon to help bring up your Str-based accuracy and it comes with a very nice [W] value. Alternatively, use a Dagger and pick your Str-based powers more for their bonuses than for their damage (Dagger is the only +3 proficiency weapon in the PHB that you automatically have proficiency with).
Advantages of this: 1) you get access to the full PHB power lineup without loss of effectiveness, and 2) you retain good ranged capability while also not being crippled if forced into melee. Disadvantages: your wealth is somewhat constrained by maintaining a magic weapon and holy symbol (until Holy Avenger becomes available in mid-epic tier), your Cha-based riders will be weak, and your stat decisions are very constrained.
With this approach, you can ignore the objections I raised to Str-based attack powers. The only change I'd recommend to attack powers is taking Righteous Brand instead of Priest's Shield, as +3 (or more) to attack is significantly more powerful than two +1's to AC.
I can look at paragon/epic tier later. I also intend to post a character or two when I have time.
-
2019-08-22, 12:07 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2018
- Location
- Portland, Oregon
- Gender
Re: Fun Learning 4e
Just jumping in on phone for now, I'll be able to do some more with my tablet on Friday.
@tiornys: those are some nice recommendations. Thanks for the help.
I'm wondering how you got two 16s, since the Point Buy link only gave me one 16 and a 14 for highest stats, at least not without taking 8s.
I did notice that you have one 8 in Dex (most likely explains the second 16*) does that count against my AC in heavy armor?
Ah, reading back
Originally Posted by Keledrath
Edit: Best results for Point Buy site
16, 16, 12, 10, 10, 10
Str 16 Dex 10 Con 10 Int 10 Wis 16+2= 18 Cha 12
IDK, 8 Dex doesn't seem to hurt me except in Initiative.
I'll edit the below a little later this morning.
Str 16 Dex 08 Con 10 Int 12 Wis 16 + 2 Race = 18 Cha 12
Thus HP is 22 at 1st level, and only a +1 for Cha based effects.
Not the best for overall personal health, but that's alright.
Spoiler: Cleric List of Options
Class Feature Prayers
Channel Divinity: Divine Fortune Cleric Feature
Channel Divinity: Turn Undead Cleric Feature
Healing Word Cleric Feature
Level 1 At-Will Prayers
Lance of Faith Cleric Attack 1
Priest’s Shield Cleric Attack 1
Righteous Brand Cleric Attack 1
Sacred Flame Cleric Attack 1
Level 1 Encounter Prayers
Cause Fear Cleric Attack 1
Divine Glow Cleric Attack 1
Healing Strike Cleric Attack 1
Wrathful Thunder Cleric Attack 1
Level 1 Daily Prayers
Avenging Flame Cleric Attack 1
Beacon of Hope Cleric Attack 1
Cascade of Light Cleric Attack 1
Guardian of Faith Cleric Attack 1
Human: +2 to one Ability Score.
One Bonus At-Will Power from Class:
Edit = One Bonus Skill from Class. Arcana
+1 to Fortitude, Reflex and Will defenses.
Characteristic: Tolerant.
Armor Class: 16 (Chainmail)
Class Features: Channel Divinity, Healer’s Lore, healing word, Ritual Casting.
Human Cleric+2 to one ability.
+1 Class At-Will power
+1 Skill (Arcana)
+1 to all saves.
Cleric Skills: Religion; Insight, Persuasion, Heal
Str1116 Con 10 Dex1108 Int 12 Wis 16 +2 Race = 18 Cha 12
04 +1 Wis +1 Cha
08 +1 Wis (20) +1 Cha (14)
11 +1 all
14 +1 Str +1 Cha
18 +1 Str +1 (19) Cha (17)
21 +1 all (Dex 10)
24 +1 Con +1 Cha
28 +1 Con +1 (12) Cha (20)
NomGarret Feats: You mentioned 5 feats for Hero Tier.
{H} Human Perseverance
01 Armor of Bahamut
02 Weapon Proficiency: Bastard Sword (tiornys)
04 Durable
06 Alertness
08 Armor Proficiency (Scale)
10 Armor Proficiency (Plate)
Fortitude 10 + 0 (half Level) + 2 Con +1 Race = 13
Reflex 10 + 0 (half Level) + 0 Dex +1 Race = 11
Will 10 + 0 (half Level) +2 Class + 4 Wis +1 Race = 17
First LevelAt Will: Priest’s Shield; Sacred Flame; and Lance of Faith
Encounter: Healing Strike
Daily:Guardian of FaithBeacon of Hope
Utility: Divine Fortune and Turn Undead
Rituals: Gentle Repose and Identify
First Level Equipment:
Chainmail +6 AC. 40# 40 gp. -1 check. -1 speed.
Mace +2 Prof. 5 gp. 6#. 1d8 blunt.
Versatile +1 Dmg when used two handed.
Light Crossbow +2 Prof. 25 gp. 4#. 1d8 P.
Holy symbol 10 gp. 1#.
Standard Adventurer's Kit. 30#. 15 go.
Backpack, Bedroll, Flint and Steel, Belt Pouch, 10 days Trail Rations, 50' Hemp Rope, 2 Sunrods, Waterskin.
Ok. Currently carrying 81#.
5 gold left.
Spoiler: Heroic Powers
2nd levelUtility: [slCure Light Wounds[/s] Shield of Faith
3rd LevelEncounter: Daunting Light
5th levelDaily: Spiritual Weapon
6th levelUtility:Cure serious WoundsBastion of Health
7th levelEncounter:Break the SpiritSearing Light
9th levelDaily:Divine PowerFlame Strike
10th levelUtility: Mass Cure Light Wounds
Slowly including Equipment adjustments.
Spoiler: Heroic Equipment
Second+1 Holy Symbol; +1 Viscous Mace (Critical = +1d12 damage per plus)
Third+1 amulet of Protection; Gloves of Piercing;
FourthWavestrider Boots;
Fifth+1 Angelsteel (Chainmail) Armor; Everlasting Provisions;
Sixth+2 Holy Symbol
Seventh+2 Amulet of Protection; +2 Viscous Mace (Critical = +2d12 damage)
EighthBelt of Sacrifice
Ninth+2 Angelsteel (Chainmail) Armor
TenthHandy Haversack;
Got some help from my friend.
@Excession: But, still need help figuring out what Paragon Powers replace which Heroic Powers.
Feats
11 Combat Anticipation
12 Danger Sense
14 Devastating Critical
16 Mettle
18 Uncanny Dodge
20 Devastating Critical
Spoiler: Paragon Powers
ThirteenEncounter:Inspiring StrikeHealing Strike traded for Mantle of Glory
FifteenDaily: Seal of Warding
SixteenUtility:Divine ArmorHallowed Ground
+2 AC and DR 5 to all allies for the encounter is nice, but +2 to saves, all defenses, and Attacks for the encounter is a little better, to my thinking.
SeventeenEncounter: Thunderous Word
I’d consider Enthrall if the immobilized effect was applied for all allies, but it looks like the targets are only unable to attack the caster, if said is successful in beating their (Wis vs) Will Defense.
NineteenDaily: Holy Wrath
Spoiler: Paragon Equipment
Eleventh+3 Holy Symbol; Sending Stones (pair)
Twelve+3 Amulet of Protection;
Thirteen+3 Periapt of Wisdom; +3 Viscous Mace (Critical = +3d12 damage)
Fourteen+3 Angelsteel (Chainmail) Armor
Fifteen
Sixteen+4 Amulet of Protection;
Seventeen+4 Holy Symbol; +4 Viscous Mace (Critical = +4d12 damage)
EighteenRing of Protection
NineteenHelm of Command;
Twenty+4 Angelsteel (Chainmail) Armor
Feats
21 Epic Resurgence
22 Blind-Fight
24 Triumphant Attack
26 Light Shield Proficiency
28 Heavy Shield Proficiency
30 Font of Radiance
Even further down the list, what Paragon powers are traded for Epic powers
Spoiler: Epic Powers
Twenty-twoUtility: Purify
Twenty-threeEncounter: Astral Blades of Death
Twenty-fiveDaily: Seal of Protection
Twenty-sevenEncounter: Sunburst
Twenty-nineDaily: Astral Storm
Spoiler: Epic Equipment
Twenty-one+5 Holy Symbol;
Twenty-two+5 Amulet of Protection; +5 Viscous Mace (Critical = +5d12 damage)
Twenty-three
Twenty-four
Ring of Regeneration; +5 Angelsteel (Chainmail) Armor
Twenty-five+6 Amulet of Protection;
Twenty-six+6 Holy Symbol;
Twenty-seven+6 Viscous Mace (Critical = +6d12 damage)
Twenty-eight
Twenty-nine
+6 Angelsteel (Chainmail) Armor
Thirty+6 Scarab of Invulnerability
Ability Scores done.
Next up: Figuring out Powers.
After: Equipment changes.Last edited by Great Dragon; 2019-08-24 at 01:27 PM.
My Knowledge, Understanding, and Opinion on things can be changed
No offense is intended by anything I post.*Limited Playtest Group - I'm mostly Stuck in the White Room.
*I am learning valuable things, here. So thanks, everyone!
-
2019-08-22, 12:54 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2007
- Location
- GMT -5
- Gender
Re: Fun Learning 4e
No, because each defense is modified by the HIGHER or two stats
AC: Dex/Int (or none when using heavy armor)
Fortitude: Str/Con
Reflex: Dex/Int (regardless of armor)
Will: Wis/Cha
So if you weren't in heavy armor, AC would be modified by the higher of Dex or Int. Since you can only reduce 1 ability score below 10, the lowest possible ability score modifier between these two is +0 (8/10).I follow a general rule: better to ask and be told no than not to ask at all.
Shadeblight by KennyPyro