Results 1 to 15 of 15

20191226, 03:50 AM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Feb 2016
Asymmetry of Xaxis and Yaxis, why?
Throughout all of my education in math it was frequently implied (and IIRC occasionally stated, but NEVER explained) that it was ok for a plot to have multiple values of x for a given value of y, but not ok for there to be multiple values of y for a given value of x. [That, for example, if one were to graph X x Y = X that it should be massaged into Y=X/X and then into Y=1 and thus be a horizontal line ay Y=1 (possibly with a gap at X=0 if we stop the process at Y=X/X) rather than the cross shape that the original X*Y=X denotes]
I never understood the point of this, can someone explain it?Last edited by Bohandas; 20191226 at 03:51 AM.

20191226, 04:33 AM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Mar 2012
 Location
 UK
 Gender
Re: Asymmetry of Xaxis and Yaxis, why?
I suspect they are thinking of clarity of presentation  I have certainly seen graphs/charts wth multiple Y scales (usually only 2  one deliniated to the left and one to the right).
Graphs with multiple X scales are much rare in my experience as you have nowhere to put the second scale.
Note for these graphs what is usually important is the shape of the curve  so if you are plotting how two different measures change over time you put time along the X axis and the measures on Y and then can compare the shape of the lines  direct comparison of the values being meaningless.
Actually that last point may be why they are saying don't do this  people tend to perform the direct comparison even when they should not.

20191226, 04:50 AM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Aug 2013
Re: Asymmetry of Xaxis and Yaxis, why?
This statement isn't necessarily true for arbitrary plots, but it is true for the type of plot that is most commonly considered in early math education: plots of functions. And that's the explanation that you are looking for:
A function is, by definition, a mapping of elements from two sets X and Y, where each element in X is mapped to exactly one element in Y. Thus, one value in Y can be the target of the mapping for multiple values in X but not the other way around.Inuit avatar withcherrybanana on top by Yanisa

20191226, 05:09 AM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Feb 2016
Re: Asymmetry of Xaxis and Yaxis, why?
Last edited by Bohandas; 20191226 at 05:10 AM.

20191226, 07:10 AM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Aug 2008
Re: Asymmetry of Xaxis and Yaxis, why?
This isn't an X/Y situation so much as an input/output situation, where the convention happens to be using X as an input. Functions are defined such that each input has exactly 1 output, which is why for the function y=sqrt(x) square root is defined as the positive square root in particular. The same would apply for the function x=sqrt(y), where y is used as an input instead.
Functions being built this way is arbitrary at a deep level, but there are a number of useful properties which depend on it, especially when working with multiple functions at once. Other branches of mathematics don't necessarily do this.I would really like to see a game made by Obryn, Kurald Galain, and Knaight from these forums.
I'm not joking one bit. I would buy the hell out of that.  ChubbyRain
Current Design Project: Legacy, a game of masters and apprentices for two players and a GM.

20191226, 08:22 AM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Aug 2019
Re: Asymmetry of Xaxis and Yaxis, why?
Functions take Elements/Numbers from X and convert them to Y.
If you had programming, its pretty clear that you want your, say sqareroot function to always act the same. For one input value, you want one output value, that you can then use. If you get two different things out, its hard to catch them both and use them meaningfully.
Functions act much like black boxes or machines. To do more complicated stuff, you want to link them together in a chain. Like exp(sin(sqrt(x))).
This only works if each function gives only one output.

20191226, 08:54 AM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Aug 2008
Re: Asymmetry of Xaxis and Yaxis, why?
They take elements/numbers from something and convert to something  X and Y are common conventions for functions of a single variable that produce a one dimensional output, but they aren't by any means required. For instance another common convention is for a function to output X,Y,Z coordinates using a t input, or a u and a v input in a more genericized sense.
I would really like to see a game made by Obryn, Kurald Galain, and Knaight from these forums.
I'm not joking one bit. I would buy the hell out of that.  ChubbyRain
Current Design Project: Legacy, a game of masters and apprentices for two players and a GM.

20191226, 11:21 AM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Dec 2010
 Location
 The Great White North
 Gender
Re: Asymmetry of Xaxis and Yaxis, why?
{Scrubbed}. Mathematicians do deal with equations such as y²=x and x²+y²=1 and the graphs.
Last edited by jdizzlean; 20191226 at 11:46 PM. Reason: clean up
How do you keep a fool busy? Turn upside down for answer.
˙ɹǝʍsuɐ ɹoɟ uʍop ǝpısdn uɹnʇ ¿ʎsnq ןooɟ ɐ dǝǝʞ noʎ op ʍoɥ

20191226, 01:12 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Aug 2019

20191226, 02:26 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Aug 2011
Re: Asymmetry of Xaxis and Yaxis, why?
Other's have stated the basic answer: functions have a unique mapping, meaning a single input only leads to a certain output. So when you see a graph where x is the input (i.e. a graph of a function of x), each x value will map to a single unique value.
You do see other graphs, though. You brought up an example yourself: y = sqrt(x), or y^2 = x. If you were to plot all the points on the x/y plane that are a solution to that equality, you'd get a sideways parabola. It's a perfectly valid plot, you can do that, it just isn't a plot of a function.
In school you're usually dealing with functions, hence the insistence on the unique mapping. If you were to take more pure math courses, you'd probably see the distinction more often. In highschool and most of first year (as well as the "focused" classes you see sometimes, like calculus classes aimed at physics and engineering students, even in upper years) the distinction isn't as useful so it often doesn't get explained all that well.Originally Posted by crayzzOriginally Posted by jere7my

20191226, 09:08 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Sep 2014
Re: Asymmetry of Xaxis and Yaxis, why?
Yeah, this is a "functions" thing. Basically, the idea of a function is that it's a thing where if you hand it some specific thing as an input, you get the same output each time you give it that input. The way it's usually easiest to explain it to my students is that it's like a vending machine: each button (input) better give you a predictable kind of can of soda (output). It's ok to have two buttons that both give you Coke, but not ok to have a button that sometimes gives you Coke and sometimes gives you Caffeine Free Diet Coke.
Since the convention when graphing is to graph the inputs (independent variables) as x and the outputs (dependent variables) as y, if it's a function it'll sometimes have more than one x value with the same y value (just like having two buttons on a vending machine that are both stocked with the same product), but you won't have the same x value have two y values (just like you wouldn't have multiple products stocked in the same slot in a vending machine).
Not all graphs work this way, of course. The most common nonfunction graph a lot of people would see relatively early on in their math education would be a scatter plot. A lot of those would have data points that share x values but not y values depending on the data. However, you would be in high school before you need to graph equations that aren't functions depending on your curriculum, and it's fairly easy to miss the nonfunction equations along the way depending on how far you go in math and the particular courses you take. (Where I teach now, I think the equation of a circle in geometry is the first nonfunction equation most students will end up doing much graphing of other than the trivial ones of x=some constant that they'll see when learning about equations for lines in middle school.)

20200109, 03:19 AM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Jan 2020

20200120, 02:38 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Jun 2011
 Location
 UK
Re: Asymmetry of Xaxis and Yaxis, why?
You do get graphs where both X and Y take multiple values, but they need to be controlled by a parameter that isn't X or Y, or the combination of the two has to hold constant.
E.g.:
Last edited by RCgothic; 20200120 at 02:43 PM.

20200120, 05:12 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Jul 2010
Re: Asymmetry of Xaxis and Yaxis, why?

20200122, 07:55 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Oct 2010
 Location
 Dallas, TX
 Gender
Re: Asymmetry of Xaxis and Yaxis, why?
Yes, “because that’s how functions are defined” is the answer. But it’s worth looking into why functions are defined that way.
A lot of graphs are created to answer some question of the form, “If I do this, what would happen?”
The asymmetry of the graph (and the definition of a function) come from the inherent difference between cause (“I do this”) and effect (“what would happen”).