Harry Potter Werewolf

[Mrs McGinty]

Erhm... I am dumb enough to vote you on a joke. Or smart enough if you're werewolf.

I don't mind being voted - actually I find it quite invigorating.

It's being lynched that I'd prefer to avoid, and I trust that if I get mislynched here it won't be just because I opened with a joke claim.

Edit:

If Valmark is a wolf, he and I have definitely cooked up these interactions in our private thread. I love me a bit of meticulously planned Scum Theatre.

[JoyWonderLove]

JoyWonderLove
For naming yourself after everything I’ve ever fought to destroy.

Don't pretend we're not friends! Even Snowbluff, my mortal Mafia frenemy, likes me. Deep down.

Erhm... I am dumb enough to vote you on a joke. Or smart enough if you're werewolf.

I vote Valmark for most wuvable and in need of being kinder to himself.

I don't mind being voted - actually I find it quite invigorating.

It's being lynched that I'd prefer to avoid, and I trust that if I get mislynched here it won't be just because I opened with a joke claim.

And McGinty for most strong minded.

[Valmark]

If Valmark is a wolf, he and I have definitely cooked up these interactions in our private thread. I love me a bit of meticulously planned Scum Theatre.

I'd like to point out that if Ginty is a wolf we most definitely did not cook up these interactions.

I'm just really good at antagonizing people (if that can be called such)

[Mrs McGinty]

I'd like to point out that if Ginty is a wolf we most definitely did not cook up these interactions.

I'm just really good at antagonizing people (if that can be called such)

Come on, they'll never believe we'd really just openly admit to being scumbuddies. It's a foolproof plan.

Edit: Oops, I meant to post this in wolfchat. Now we're in trouble...

[Snowblaze]

<paranoia> This is just the sort of thing I could see wolf!McGinty doing in an attempt to look too wolfy to be a wolf. That being said, I’m not sure whether in this hypothetical scenario Valmark is a wolf too or a townie being set up to be mislynched once McGinty dies. </paranoia>

Of course, this is also just the sort of thing I could see town!McGinty doing based on last game. In fact I find that significantly more likely.

[Valmark]

<paranoia> This is just the sort of thing I could see wolf!McGinty doing in an attempt to look too wolfy to be a wolf. That being said, I’m not sure whether in this hypothetical scenario Valmark is a wolf too or a townie being set up to be mislynched once McGinty dies. </paranoia>

Of course, this is also just the sort of thing I could see town!McGinty doing based on last game. In fact I find that significantly more likely.

I do think they're teasing to see the reaction and are in fact town, more then wolf setting someone else up to be myslinched. Would be in line with their previous behavior.

[Snowblaze]

Also, I feel like "explaining a joke = eliminating day one activity = objectively anti-town" is reading far too much into what I said. Valmark was confused, so I explained. How is that anti-town? I feel like activity based on something not that relevant to the game probably won't help town that much, nor will having half of town thinking roles that clearly don't exist are in the game.

- - - Updated - - -

I do think they're teasing to see the reaction and are in fact town, more then wolf setting someone else up to be myslinched. Would be in line with their previous behavior.

I agree. Hence the paranoia tags around the top bit.

[Xihirli]

Don't pretend we're not friends! Even Snowbluff, my mortal Mafia frenemy, likes me. Deep down.

I killed all my friends to get into the lawyer business!
I don't know what my character is, I'll be honest.

[DukeGod]

Alright, let's not get into arguements, we're all Hufflepuffs here. Not that there's anything wrong with that

I'll day 1 vote for AvatarVecna

[gac3]

I'm going Snowblaze. Lat time your RNG happened to land on the first and only person to have been voted for. This time it's on the first person to vote who happened to have voted for you. I don't like it.

[Mrs McGinty]

we're all Hufflepuffs here

This is an outrageous slur!

Never once in my life have I engaged in Huffling or Puffling or any other such Sordid Practices!!

What you get up to in the privacy of your own chambers is your own business, but do not besmirch my good name in such a manner ever again or I will be forced to discuss the matter with my legal team!!!

Spoiler

Show

I like your username.

It makes you sound like the leader of a 1950s ska band, which is one of the coolest things it's possible for a human to be.

[Xihirli]

Right? Let us slither in peace, thank you!

[Mrs McGinty]

Why is everyone acting like I'm town?

I can totally fake this.

Moar voats on me plz.

[AvatarVecna]

Spoiler: Current Vote Count

Show

AvatarVecna: DukeGod
Caerulea: flat_footed
CaoimhinTheCape: Lord Athos
Duck999: CaoimhinTheCape, Snowblaze
DukeGod: JeenLeen
flat_footed: kgato503
JeenLeen: Caerulea
JoyWonderLove: Xihirli
Snowblaze: AvatarVecna, Mrs McGinty, Duck999, gac3
Valmark: Valmark

Not sure how to feel about the general level of inactivity compared to last game. Don't like that we've still got two people who've yet to post. Also:

I don't care about the joke, it's ending the confusion too early that's wrong.

Confusion is the lifeblood of a good d1.

Confusion is inherent to D1 but it's not the lifeblood because that implies that it's necessary and good thing to have. Conversation is the lifeblood and confusion is one way of generating it. Hmmmmm...

...leaving my vote where it is for now.

[Mrs McGinty]

AvatarVecna

For being far too lucid at this stage of proceedings.

Edit:

What do you think of the way Snowblaze and Valmark responded to my nonsense, AV?

[AvatarVecna]

AvatarVecna

For being far too lucid at this stage of proceedings.

Edit:

What do you think of the way Snowblaze and Valmark responded to my nonsense, AV?

No idea at this point, honestly. You set my scumdar off something hard by default, but so far I've been super-wrong about that.

Time for some nonsense of my own...

[Mrs McGinty]

No idea at this point, honestly. You set my scumdar off something hard by default, but so far I've been super-wrong about that.

ruh-roh

that's not a good answer

kinda feels like you might actually be scum now

don't sweat it tho

i'll probably forget by eod

[AvatarVecna]

ruh-roh

that's not a good answer

kinda feels like you might actually be scum now

don't sweat it tho

i'll probably forget by eod

Really? That's the thing I've done that looks extra-wolfy?

[Mrs McGinty]

Really? That's the thing I've done that looks extra-wolfy?

It's all in the details.

[AvatarVecna]

Valmark for the lynch.

[Mrs McGinty]

Valmark for the lynch.

I must admit, the last game proved that Valmark's fakery rolls right past my scumdar.

Nevertheless, I feel like an explanation would be handy here.

[AvatarVecna]

I must admit, the last game proved that Valmark's fakery rolls right past my scumdar.

Nevertheless, I feel like an explanation would be handy here.

I'm a knot expert, you see.

[CaoimhinTheCape]

This is an outrageous slur!

Never once in my life have I engaged in Huffling or Puffling or any other such Sordid Practices!!

Gasp! You have completely misrepresented us! There is no Huffing or Puffing with us. You forgot our most important attribute:

---

But onto the actual game, I don't love the wagon on Snowblaze which was mostly random votes, plus a vote because Snow's "random" vote may be a wolf move according to gac3? I doubt a wolf would be worried enough to counter wagon that obviously this early on Day 1. Snow's vote is a null read to me, but I'm keeping an eye on that wagon.

Not sure how to feel about the general level of inactivity compared to last game. Don't like that we've still got two people who've yet to post.

Last game's day 1 was super busy, a lot due to McGinty's posts and the reaction to them. If I remember right Day 1 was a lot of town vs town fighting and that hurt us long term, so I can't say that I'm worried about the inactivity yet. Captain Cap was very active last game so for him at least I assume he's been busy.

Keeping my vote where it is for now.

[Mrs McGinty]

Caomhin's post has significantly villainous overtones.

[Valmark]

I'm gonna echo Caoimhin on this, though I'm more interested in Duck999.

It's not that I don't like day 1. You need a day 1 to get a day 2. Except in that one game that was out of order that one time, but that's beside the point. I'm just really bad at day 1.

And the rng machine says Snowblaze, so I guess I'm with AV on forcing her to update her sig.

It's already weird to see a second vote on someone due to rng, much less three.
Not only that, but this coming from someone who called voting useless on day 1 last game and never appeared if I'm not misremembering. They were Town last time, they are acting the complete opposite plus suspicious behavior, thus Wolf.

I'm going Snowblaze. Lat time your RNG happened to land on the first and only person to have been voted for. This time it's on the first person to vote who happened to have voted for you. I don't like it.

Also because I'm leery of judging Gac3, all times there was some apparent failing in their reasoning they were revealed as Town.
Sure, last two times it was also helpful to me because I knew we were on opposite sides, but I would have voted for them either way those times.

[Mrs McGinty]

I'm gonna echo Caoimhin on this, though I'm more interested in Duck999.


It's already weird to see a second vote on someone due to rng, much less three.
Not only that, but this coming from someone who called voting useless on day 1 last game and never appeared if I'm not misremembering. They were Town last time, they are acting the complete opposite plus suspicious behavior, thus Wolf.



Also because I'm leery of judging Gac3, all times there was some apparent failing in their reasoning they were revealed as Town.
Sure, last two times it was also helpful to me because I knew we were on opposite sides, but I would have voted for them either way those times.

I don't understand this post at all, which makes me think it townie.

Someone explain why I'm wrong.

[Valmark]

I don't understand this post at all, which makes me think it townie.

Someone explain why I'm wrong.

Echoing Caoimhin in thinking that the votes on Snow piled up too fast.

Duck voted third on the same person due to RNG. Duck was the same player that called voting on day 1 useless and I'm fairly sure they were a no show during it.
It already looks bad to pile on a wagon because of RNG, plus it was done by a player that did the exact opposite last time.
Not only that but Duck is an older player, which makes me think they wouldn't suddenly completely change their playstyle without apparent reason.
Thus, voting for them.

On Gac3, last two games where I suspected them they were revealed as Town. Thus, I'm not keen on judging them. Also, their reasoning this time around actually checks out to me.

[gac3]

Yeah. I'm not very good at looking town. I'm trying to make a list of votes and stuff to track things and see who looks suspicious.


So far the biggest thing I saw was that Snowblaze was leading the vote count and then suddenly half the votes switched to divide up the wagon to more people.neither gave much reason.

[Mrs McGinty]

Echoing Caoimhin in thinking that the votes on Snow piled up too fast.

Duck voted third on the same person due to RNG. Duck was the same player that called voting on day 1 useless and I'm fairly sure they were a no show during it.
It already looks bad to pile on a wagon because of RNG, plus it was done by a player that did the exact opposite last time.
Not only that but Duck is an older player, which makes me think they wouldn't suddenly completely change their playstyle without apparent reason.
Thus, voting for them.

On Gac3, last two games where I suspected them they were revealed as Town. Thus, I'm not keen on judging them. Also, their reasoning this time around actually checks out to me.

I know you fooled me last time, but this is just gloriously procedural even by those standards.

If you're scum here, I'm gonna need someone else to show it to me.

Is Valmark my blind spot?

[gac3]

I edited my last one but a new post came up so I'll repost that part.

So far the biggest thing I saw was that Snowblaze was leading the vote count and then suddenly half the votes switched to divide up the wagon to more people.neither gave much reason.