Results 451 to 480 of 609
-
2021-03-03, 03:35 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2013
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
I'm surprised you didn't have to read it at least twice in school.
-
2021-03-03, 03:58 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- May 2017
-
2021-03-03, 04:09 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Sep 2019
- Location
- NW FL
- Gender
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
now that I think about it, I have read "1984" more than once, but "Catch-22" would not keep my attention long enough to finish, which is unusual for me. Note I have read Lord of the Rings probably 7 times, the Dune series over 3 times, Roger Zelazny's works multiple times, and all of Heinlein's writings over and over... sigh. Why I could not finish Catch-22 I will never understand.
-
2021-03-03, 04:37 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- May 2017
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
The way it jumps around in time makes it hard to follow, especially since it's frequently unclear when it happens or how it's related. Slaughterhouse-5 jumps around as well, but it's easier to pick up the dangling ends of the story threads because Vonnegut makes them both obvious and distinctive.
-
2021-03-03, 04:48 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Sep 2015
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
I mean, what he says there could be passing over a lot of nuance.
Power comes in various forms, for example soft power and hard power. Sometimes, you have the legal authority to do something, but not the political clout to actually get away with it. And vice versa. And constitutional monarchies often come with somewhat uncomfortable compromises where the monarch is expected to do something, but with little provision about what to do if it doesn't. Parliamentarism comes to mind, with the Governor General being the representative of the head of state, and whose signature is required to pass legislation (essentially a veto), despite being named by the Prime Minister. The GG also has some other powers, like shutting down parliament (proroguing it). If a GG went "rogue", that'd be pretty uncomfortable. Because the system as it is has the monarchy as both above and below the elected government.Attention LotR fans
Spoiler: LotRThe scouring of the Shire never happened. That's right. After reading books I, II, and III, I stopped reading when the One Ring was thrown into Mount Doom. The story ends there. Nothing worthwhile happened afterwards. Middle-Earth was saved.
-
2021-03-03, 04:49 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2015
- Gender
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
The one I always remember is
Spoiler: Catch-22, very paraphrasedYou can't get out of fighting the war unless you're certified insane, but trying to get certified means you're trying to get out of the war, and if you're trying to get out of the war, you're obviously sane.
-
2021-03-03, 05:01 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- May 2015
- Location
- Texas
- Gender
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
I finished it but didn't want to read it again. 1984 I wanted to read again, as an adult, because I had been exposed to more of life and wanted to see if Orwell's story felt different or showed me anything different. It did.
The latter also made for a more enjoyable movie.Avatar by linklele. How Teleport Worksa. Malifice (paraphrased):
Rulings are not 'House Rules.' Rulings are a DM doing what DMs are supposed to do.
b. greenstone (paraphrased):
Agency means that they {players} control their character's actions; you control the world's reactions to the character's actions.
Second known member of the Greyview Appreciation Society
-
2021-03-03, 05:05 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2007
- Location
- Oregon, USA
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
For the record:
Spoiler: War and XPs Bonus ContentOriginally Posted by Stick Planet Travel Guide to the Southern Lands: Azure CityFeytouchedBanana eldritch disciple avatar by...me!
The Index of the Giant's Comments VI―Making Dogma from Zapped Bananas
-
2021-03-03, 07:10 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2013
- Location
- Skyron, Andromeda
- Gender
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
-
2021-03-03, 07:42 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Sep 2015
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
Yea that's a bit contradictory.
Though it's also possible that the law stems from the absolute monarch, and that it's more of a social contract that the nobles expect him to go by, that he promised them to rule by. De jure, he could alter the deal at any time. But since doing so would turn the nobles on him and starve him of resources, it'd be politically suicidal to do so.
This interpretation might not be what was in mind, but would seem to me like the one that breaks away the least from the stated contradictory descriptions.
Like, in Hinjo's example, maybe he could trial Kabuto himself, but doing so would put the whole clan, and its allies, against him. While delegating this to a third-party, the magistrate, would presumably not incur this retaliation. Thus, he has the authority to judge them himself, but he can't really afford to do it. Going back to Shojo, for example, he might very well have had the authority to do the shady trials he did. But doing it publicly could have cost him a lot.
This being the case would make a lot more sense than otherwise, regarding Shojo. If the barriers were political and not judicial, then it would make a lot more sense for Shojo to get away with his crazy antics and irregular orders. If I remember correctly, even paladins were carrying out his irregular judgements. This looks like a paladin carrying out an order he feels legal but immoral. If the order was outright illegal, illegitimate, I would expect more resistance than that.
Counterpoint, though, I'm not sure how to interpret Hinjo's aim to have the courts depose the monarch. And on what basis the motion would have depended. Feigning senility doesn't sound like such a serious offense to me.Attention LotR fans
Spoiler: LotRThe scouring of the Shire never happened. That's right. After reading books I, II, and III, I stopped reading when the One Ring was thrown into Mount Doom. The story ends there. Nothing worthwhile happened afterwards. Middle-Earth was saved.
-
2021-03-03, 08:04 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2013
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
Rigging trials is.
-
2021-03-03, 08:17 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- May 2017
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
It does seem a bit of a puzzler, how it would be worse for your ruler to feign incompetence than to be incompetent. (^_^)°
A couple of points:
~ Technically, Hinjo doesn't say he's going to have the magistrates depose Shojo (except perhaps in the punny sense). He says it'll be up to the magistrates what'll happen next. At the time I thought of it as "Uh oh, he's in trouble" - but now that you've brought this to mind, I wonder what the heck that statement was supposed to mean. Because...
~ The "offenses" Hinjo probably heard about were lying to paladins / hiding things from them, staging a trial on behalf of "the gods" in the name of the Sapphire Guard, and using SG resources to get the Order down there to do a quest that's a de-facto violation of Soon's oath. None of those have more than a trivial bearing on his position as ruler of Azure City, only on his position on commander of the SG. I don't know why an Azure City magistrate would have (or want) jurisdiction.
-
2021-03-03, 08:48 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2016
- Location
- Seoul
- Gender
Cool elan Illithid Slayer by linkele.
Editor/co-writer of Magicae Est Potestas, a crossover between Artemis Fowl and Undertale. Ao3 FanFiction.net DeviantArt
We also have a TvTropes page!
Currently playing: Red Hand of Doom(campaign journal)Campaign still going on, but journal discontinued until further notice.
Extended sig here.
-
2021-03-03, 09:08 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2012
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
I know what you mean. I had to read Catch-22 in high school and when I started, I thought Joseph Heller was being absurd for no good reason. When he finally revealed Snowden's death (which chronologically happened much earlier), I understood one of the points he was trying to make. The only thing that separates us from a bag of organs is our "spirit", which is the part of us that cannot be destroyed by guns or knives, but can be relinquished when we abandon what we hold dear. Yossarian was afraid that people were trying to kill him (which to be honest, they were), and he could sell out to authority and have an easy life, but by doing so he would lose the only thing that the war could not take from him.
Not a new concept (it has existed for thousands of years!), but as a 17 year old I thought that Heller did a good job of making it real.
-
2021-03-03, 11:10 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- May 2018
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
I read them both again recently; I honestly think I found more in Heller the second time.
Orwell had a terrifying vision, but in many ways it was the standard dystopian novel: the author warns of a possible future where a bunch of supermen engineer the "end of history". And there was a scene where a superman demonstrates to the protagonist that they understand everything and control everything, and another scene where a superman describes the philosophy in a cold monologue.
Heller had something far worse. He imagined no supermen, no engineered future, no end of history. He warns of a concrete present where a bunch of mediocre bunglers have stumbled into power for no reason or purpose. His generals are mostly helpless in the face of history. In one scene, the generals don't even know where the front line is (because someone moves some thumbtacks on a map, and nobody wants to tell a general anything that will upset them); in another a group of generals can't even control the room they're in (because their clothes have been thrown out the window, and without clothes there's nothing to show that they're generals). And in one of the most depressing parts of the whole novel, the underlying philosophy which is evaded for most of the book is finally described in its raw form by a powerless old woman in an anguished wail.
And yeah, nearly everyone dies, and the way the story jumps around it takes you until nearly the end to realize that nearly everyone has been dead for most of the book.Last edited by Dion; 2021-03-03 at 11:20 PM.
-
2021-03-04, 01:35 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2019
-
2021-03-04, 02:58 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2016
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
Yeah, i don't buy that because someone lives somewhere, they have the right to do whatever to people who come into the surrounding area. As you point out, the bugbears have a village there, and were probably there first, so do they have the right to reject Serini?
Kidnapping doesn't require any malicious intent, it just means capturing another person without lawful authority. If you take you own children because you love them this can be kidnapping, if it deprives another parent of their custodial rights (this is actually one of the more common forms of kidnapping).
Putting aside real world laws - pretend they don't exist, if you were walking in the countryside, and someone who happened to live nearby threw a dart into your neck with a tranquilizer attached, taunted you with promised of freedom, then gave you roofies and dumped you somewhere, would you think of that as a good, neutral or evil act?I think it is somewhat evil. Granted not as evil as if they killed you, but killing is pretty much the gold standard of evil (you have to be creative to do worse).
I generally don't put much stock in D&D wikis, and especially isolated incidents: just because that one example of drow poison having side effects exists, that does not mean the vast majority of games & stories will use that side effect if drow poison shows up in the games. And regardless, this requires a lot of assumptions when Serini has already stated the poison was completely harmless. Sure, she might be lying again...but why? How would that improve the flow of this current narrative? It's an awful lot of extra assumptions to justify, and in the end it's just easier to follow the "standard" d&d rules about sleeping potions: they work, barring a successful Fort save.
I don't thin Serini did say it was harmless, and she is not a reliable narrator anyway (her lies per strip ratio is very high). In any case, she may not consider it harmful because it has no long lasting effects, just like real world tranquilizer. It harms you in the sense it knocks you out when you really want to be awake and probably makes you feel a bit sick, but not in the sense that it does permanent damage.
I want to take a second to acknowledge that you've been very consistent throughout this discussion about judging Serini's individual actions, rather than Serini herself, and I appreciate that.
That's not correct. Judicial authority is assigned by law, law being derived from the legislature (or in a more old fashioned setting like OotS, by the monarch). Nation states can do this however they like. Not ever from mutual agreement between citizens and the government, except to the extent that elected governments probably assign judicial authority in a way that their population approves of.
Azure City clearly was able to do this, Serini clearly isn't. More questionable is whether Gobtopia or Azure City in its present form can do it.
Actually, Hinjo (who you point out is likely to know the law) was present when Shojo asserted that he had jurisdiction to arrest the Order in the north, and he did not object to the comment.
His later arrest of Shojo was for Shojo's chicanery, not for his assertion of jurisdiction.
Put better than I did.Last edited by Liquor Box; 2021-03-04 at 03:24 AM.
-
2021-03-04, 02:59 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2015
- Gender
-
2021-03-04, 03:28 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2016
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
True. But the fact that she lived there was the reason put forward by Ionathus (and before him, by Peelee) as why she would have the right to capture people who "trespass". So that was the point I answered.
Others have raised the importance of her apparent mission as a justification, and I have answered them. More than happy to go through it with you, but I get the feeling you just wanted to make that point, rather than a back and forth.
-
2021-03-04, 03:45 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2021
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
Thank you, that makes wayyyy more sense than the way I was misreading it.
So basically I keep thinking of it as one whole action, like "arresting on false pretenses," but it's true that arresting and false pretenses are separate things. And Hinjo never confronts the false pretenses part because he doesn't really know what the truth was about the Order. He's only swayed to their side because Roy protects him from Miko, and Xykon is breathing down everyone's necks. Otherwise he might have arranged a new trial for them first.
So now I think Hinjo doesn't suggest one way or the other whether Shojo had a right to do that even though he knew they weren't really a danger to the existence of the world. Only that he would have had a right to do that if he wasn't withholding information.
If he was like a normal paladin leader, I would say he doesnt, because their laws don't work like mundane laws do. It's more like.. "do the honorable thing" than "fill out form 2038 first." Harder to escape on a technicality. But of course he's not a paladin.
Since the right comes from the Sapphire Guard and not Azure City though, ultimately Shojo gets that authority from Soon. Which would put Serini on equal or better authority there, if it comes from "being a part of the Scribbler Gate Protection Squad."
Shojo might actually have been telling half a truth that he got the authority from the gods. It's unlikely he consulted on the specific action, but since the gods can talk about the Snarl to mortals who already know about it, it's possible the Scribblers all got some token sign of approval at some point.
If it's true that all divination comes from the gods (not that I'm sure this is established, but if) then the fact that they have a rudimentary divination thing set up to inform each other about the Gates might support this. Again though, pure speculation.
On Catch-22.... Yeah I tried in high school but I could not follow it at all. Maybe about time I gave another go.Last edited by Good Coyote; 2021-03-04 at 03:48 AM.
-
2021-03-04, 04:39 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2015
- Gender
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
Yeah, you're pretty much right, so, fair enough, I'll give you my fuller analysis.
My stance here is more or less that of the things we have seen Serini done, the worst of them is the kidnapping, which is fairly justifiable given the circumstances and the information from her perspective; and the rest of her actions are essentially so minor that we can't determine anything about her alignment from them. (Or, perhaps, that her treatment of the trolls is more indicator of Good than lying to paladins and bonking them on the head is of Evil.) Based on the reason we know who she is in the first place and the way she came across in those strips, I would lean more toward Good than Evil, and there's been nothing significant enough in these new strips that moves the needle for me yet.
-
2021-03-04, 05:55 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2017
- Location
- France
- Gender
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
Do you have to hold yourself by the ankle? That doesn't seem very practical.
I do not have a single clue what you are talking about.
Thanks
There wasn't any false pretense, though. The SG's divinations pointed to the Order of the Stick because they (well Elan) did destroy Dorukan's Gate which is what they were tried for. While it's likely that absent Miko's kingslaying followed by Roy's intervention and Xykon's imminent arrival he would have had them retried, I think he also was convinced by the argument they made that destroying Dorukan's Gate was the right call and guesses that an actual trial would have resulted in a "Not Guilty" verdict.
By the way my position on the whole Serini thing is "she's been in three strips calm down, people."Forum Wisdom
Mage avatar by smutmulch & linklele.
-
2021-03-04, 06:17 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2021
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
The false pretense is the pretense that they were being retrieved for an actual trial. I am probably not using the right words to refer to that, but it does seem important.
That's a very reasonable position. Authority is irrelevant to my opinion on Serini, I'm just speculating for fun.
-
2021-03-04, 07:45 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Apr 2019
- Gender
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
-
2021-03-04, 09:31 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2013
- Gender
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
No, "she happens to live there" was NOT the reason I put forward. Your example of "if I'm just walking through the countryside and you tranquilize me because you happen to live nearby" also misses the point entirely.
She is defending the Gate. The paladins are clearly meddling with the Gate. She does not just happen to live there. She is defending reality & existence itself.
We are clearly talking ourselves in circles, and will continue to do so, because it seems you don't draw any distinction between real-world behavior and fantasy world behavior -- especially the fact that this fantasy world has a single, unambiguous "kill switch" lurking in Kraagor's Tomb. That factor will, by necessity, change some of the equation.
If the existence of that fantastical, existential threat and the necessity to protect it doesn't affect any of the conclusions you draw about Serini, and get you to accept that a 1-for-1 perfect equivalent to real-world morality is therefore impossible, I can't see any way you will ever accept Serini's actions as not-Evil. It all kind of hinges on that difference.
-
2021-03-04, 09:33 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Nov 2012
- Location
- Cambridge, Ma.
- Gender
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
Of course he'd guess that. :)
And of course he'd be right. :))
She'll let them go eventually. It's a story after all.
:)))
I'd wondered how he got the diary. I'd assumed it was a yard sale, but I suppose this is more in keeping.Last edited by F.Harr; 2021-03-04 at 09:34 AM.
http://www.giantitp.com/forums/showt...6#post15476516
I know I'm stealing this from someone else. But it's SO FUNNY
Zweisteine quoting Razanir:
"I am a human sixtyfourthling! Fear my minimal halfling ancestry!"
From: Razanir
Bagnold could be one sixty-fourth halfling.
-
2021-03-04, 10:05 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- May 2018
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
Capturing paladins and lying to them isn’t a nice thing to do.
But most adventurers, if they needed to get rid of martial combatants, would have killed the martial combatants.
So we know she avoids killing Trolls AND paladins.
Is she good? Certainly not! If she were good, she’d have to be all murder murder on the trolls! You have to commit a LOT of murders to be good in D&D.
Is she lawful? Certainly not! If she were lawful, she would send away for the Sheriff of Nottingham or the Dwarf High Council or whatever to ineffectively defend the gated every time there’s trouble. You have to let a LOT of worlds be needlessly destroyed to be lawful in D&D.
-
2021-03-04, 10:30 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2009
- Location
- Birmingham, AL
- Gender
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
I didn't read their post as pointing out the bugbears were there first, which is an incorrect assertion anyway; the bugbears live there because of Monster Hollow, which Serini built, so she by necessity predates the bugbears village.
And the law is fiat rests on the belief that the authority is present. If nobody listens to the legitimate king, that person is no longer the king. Doesn't matter that they have the law decreeing them the king, the person who everyone listens to and obeys is the actual king. Authority only rests in the office that people are willing to recognize. This is the most fundamental basis of governance and authority.Last edited by Peelee; 2021-03-04 at 10:37 AM.
Cuthalion's art is the prettiest art of all the art. Like my avatar.
Number of times Roland St. Jude has sworn revenge upon me: 2
-
2021-03-04, 10:39 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2016
- Location
- Seoul
- Gender
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
Cool elan Illithid Slayer by linkele.
Editor/co-writer of Magicae Est Potestas, a crossover between Artemis Fowl and Undertale. Ao3 FanFiction.net DeviantArt
We also have a TvTropes page!
Currently playing: Red Hand of Doom(campaign journal)Campaign still going on, but journal discontinued until further notice.
Extended sig here.
-
2021-03-04, 10:58 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2009
- Location
- Birmingham, AL
- Gender
Re: OOTS #1227 - The Discussion Thread
Indeed, that has been linked before in this discussion and rebuttals to it have been made (for example, my rebuttal was something similar to "that sounds like an entirely self-serving statement with no ability to back up or prove it, made by someone who was already in the middle of abusing his own actual authority left right and center. Or in other words, most likely hogwash.")
After all, Shojo was killed by someone claiming divine authority to do so, and we all saw how that worked out. Shojo has zero credibility.Last edited by Peelee; 2021-03-04 at 10:58 AM.
Cuthalion's art is the prettiest art of all the art. Like my avatar.
Number of times Roland St. Jude has sworn revenge upon me: 2