New OOTS products from CafePress
New OOTS t-shirts, ornaments, mugs, bags, and more
Results 1 to 8 of 8
  1. - Top - End - #1
    Titan in the Playground
     
    Lizardfolk

    Join Date
    Jan 2008

    Default Automatic Pass vs. Automatic Fail

    Paralysed creatures automatically fail Dexterity saving throws.
    Careful Spell allows a creature to automatically pass a saving throw (e.g; Fireball; Dex save)

    What do?
    Spoiler: My Mum Says I'm Cool
    Show
    Quote Originally Posted by Anuan View Post
    Cheesegear; Lovable Thesaurus ItP.
    Quote Originally Posted by Lycan 01 View Post
    Cheesegear, have I told you yet that you're awesome?
    Quote Originally Posted by MeatShield#236 View Post
    ALL HAIL LORD CHEESEGEAR! Cheese for the cheesegear!
    Quote Originally Posted by Shas'aia Toriia View Post
    Cheesegear is awesome

  2. - Top - End - #2
    Bugbear in the Playground
     
    BlackDragon

    Join Date
    Apr 2020

    Default Re: Automatic Pass vs. Automatic Fail

    Quote Originally Posted by Cheesegear View Post
    Paralysed creatures automatically fail Dexterity saving throws.
    Careful Spell allows a creature to automatically pass a saving throw (e.g; Fireball; Dex save)

    What do?
    Specific beats general. Generally, Paralyzed creatures automatically fail Dex saves.

    In this specific scenario, they automatically succeed. Think about it like the caster themselves are warping the spell away from their allies.

  3. - Top - End - #3
    Titan in the Playground
     
    Tanarii's Avatar

    Join Date
    Sep 2015

    Default Re: Automatic Pass vs. Automatic Fail

    Quote Originally Posted by Cheesegear View Post
    Paralysed creatures automatically fail Dexterity saving throws.
    Careful Spell allows a creature to automatically pass a saving throw (e.g; Fireball; Dex save)

    What do?
    The creature explodes.

  4. - Top - End - #4
    Ogre in the Playground
     
    Planetar

    Join Date
    May 2018

    Default Re: Automatic Pass vs. Automatic Fail

    I'm not sure if it is clear which of the two is the "specific" and which is the "general", so I don't think there is an absolute rule answer.

    However, I'm pretty certain that automatic pass makes more sense here:
    (1) Paralyse is an automatic failure because if you can't move, you can't dodge.
    (2) Careful spell is an automatic success because you shape and position the spell in a way your allies don't even need to dodge.

    If anything, it should be easier to avoid hitting someone paralyzed than someone moving around.

  5. - Top - End - #5
    Orc in the Playground
     
    HalfOrcPirate

    Join Date
    May 2014

    Default Re: Automatic Pass vs. Automatic Fail

    Quote Originally Posted by Cheesegear View Post
    Paralysed creatures automatically fail Dexterity saving throws.
    Careful Spell allows a creature to automatically pass a saving throw (e.g; Fireball; Dex save)

    What do?
    Someone mentioned that specific beats general but this is an excellent example of two contradictory specific rules.

    As always, the important thing is that this game has a DM for a reason, to making rulings. This is neither a RAW nor an RAI discussion anymore, the rules tell us all we need to know, they just didn't cover this eventuality.

    So, time to apply a ruling. If it were me, I'd agree with MoiMagnus that the Careful Spell is more a function of the spellcaster than of the paralysed creature so the spell shapes itself around them without hitting them.

    If the paralyzed creature has Evasion, I'd deny them that however.
    78% of DM's started their first campaign in a tavern. If you're one of the 22% that didn't, copy and paste this into your signature.

    Where did you start yours?

    The PCs, walk into a town they've never before visited together, all the villagers stop & stare at them. The PCs realise why when they get to the fountain at the centre of town, there are accurate statues of each of them, even down to the gear they currently carry. The statues have been here for generations...

  6. - Top - End - #6
    Titan in the Playground
     
    Valmark's Avatar

    Join Date
    May 2017
    Location
    Montevarchi, Italy
    Gender
    Male

    Default Re: Automatic Pass vs. Automatic Fail

    Quote Originally Posted by Cheesegear View Post
    Paralysed creatures automatically fail Dexterity saving throws.
    Careful Spell allows a creature to automatically pass a saving throw (e.g; Fireball; Dex save)

    What do?
    The closest rule I can find is that the creature receiving multiple effects decides in which order they trigger- my guess would be that in this case the paralyzed person could decide wether they prefer Careful to take precedence or Paralysed.

  7. - Top - End - #7
    Bugbear in the Playground
     
    NecromancerGirl

    Join Date
    Oct 2016
    Location
    Subang Jaya, Malaysia
    Gender
    Male

    Default Re: Automatic Pass vs. Automatic Fail

    Might be just me, but i feel that a class ability is more specific than a condition.

  8. - Top - End - #8
    Bugbear in the Playground
     
    PaladinGuy

    Join Date
    Sep 2018
    Location
    EU
    Gender
    Male

    Default Re: Automatic Pass vs. Automatic Fail

    Just for completeness:

    Quote Originally Posted by Careful Spell
    When you cast a spell that forces other creatures to make a saving throw, you can protect some of those creatures from the spell’s full force. To do so, you spend 1 sorcery point and choose a number of those creatures up to your Charisma modifier (minimum of one creature). A chosen creature automatically succeeds on its saving throw against the spell.
    I'd rule that since it's the Sorcerer choosing to shield their allies from the worst effects of their spell (such as casting a Fireball in melee), the paralysed ally still "passes" their saving throw. It's a "more specific" effect being applied by the Sorcerer to a specific spell, rather than the "general" rule of paralysis (in the sense that paralysis means you fail Dexterity saving throws in general, while Careful spells gives you an automatic success on a specific spell).

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •