Results 1 to 13 of 13
-
2021-05-07, 10:10 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2019
Is Quivering Palm a melee attack? (could you choose to knock a creature out with it?)
Hey guys, quick question -
According to the rules of 'knocking a creature out' - you can choose to knock a creature out ''When an attacker reduces a creature to 0 hit points with a melee attack''.
Quivering Palm stipulates ''When you hit a creature with an unarmed strike, you can spend 3 ki points to start these imperceptible vibrations, which last for a number of days equal to your monk level. The vibrations are harmless unless you use your action to end them. To do so, you and the target must be on the same plane of existence. When you use this action, the creature must make a Constitution saving throw. If it fails, it is reduced to 0 hit points. If it succeeds, it takes 10d10 necrotic damage.''
So.. when Quivering Palm reduces a creature to 0 hit points, or does the 10d10 damage, can the player choose to knock the creature out? As the Quivering Palm, did after all start with an unarmed strike.. which is a melee attack. Right?
Any clarification would be amazing - thanks for reading!
-
2021-05-07, 10:12 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2008
- Location
- Texas
- Gender
Re: Is Quivering Palm a melee attack? (could you choose to knock a creature out with
0 hit points is knocked out, not dead, as long as the target operates under PC rules.
-
2021-05-07, 10:14 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2005
- Location
- Milwaukee
Re: Is Quivering Palm a melee attack? (could you choose to knock a creature out with
My interpretation would be the initial unarmed strike could knock them out rather than kill, but the secondary quivering palm effect would not be subject to the same rule. Might be wrong, but that's how I see it.
Remember: It doesn't matter if you win or lose - as long as you look really cool doing it!
-
2021-05-07, 10:15 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2011
- Location
- Castle Sparrowcellar
- Gender
Re: Is Quivering Palm a melee attack? (could you choose to knock a creature out with
I would say no as written. The key to me is that while your attack gave them the Quivering Palm 'effect', you take a separate action to actually deal the damage. That second action isn't a melee attack, and therefore not suitable to being non-lethal. While not identical in requirements, it's the same sorta thing with not being able to make the second half of Booming Blade nonlethal.
That said if a monk player wanted to do it nonlethally I wouldn't have a problem with it. I don't see it really harming anything to do so.
-
2021-05-07, 10:18 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2019
Re: Is Quivering Palm a melee attack? (could you choose to knock a creature out with
Huh, ok I'm confused then. Monsters don't generally fall under player-character rules, do they? They don't roll death saves, etc.
I was under the assumption that the 'knocking out rules' were there to provide a means to, well, knock a goblin out, so you can interrogate them later or something - and the rules say you have to knock them out with a melee attack.
If 0 hit points automatically means 'knocked out' anyway - then what's the point of the rule? You could choose to knock any creature out, with a spell, ranged attack, or any other means?
I'm sorry I don't want to come across as blunt or rude, that's not my intention at all - I just genuinely don't understand.
-
2021-05-07, 10:20 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2019
-
2021-05-07, 01:21 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2018
- Location
- Between SEA and PDX.
- Gender
Re: Is Quivering Palm a melee attack? (could you choose to knock a creature out with
I will also add that the Open Hand Monk is full of mechanics that encourage nonviolence, such as Sanctuary that protects the Monk so long as they don't attack anyone, a self-heal that directly conflicts with the monk's damage abilities, and a remote-controlled bomb that the Monk chooses when to activate.
Having Quivering Palm knock someone unconscious seems very in-theme for the subclass.
5th Edition Homebrewery
Prestige Options, changing primary attributes to open a world of new multiclassing.
Adrenaline Surge, fitting Short Rests into combat to fix bosses/Short Rest Classes.
Pain, using Exhaustion to make tactical martial combatants.
Fate Sorcery, lucky winner of the 5e D&D Subclass Contest VII!
-
2021-05-07, 01:55 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- May 2015
- Location
- Texas
- Gender
Re: Is Quivering Palm a melee attack? (could you choose to knock a creature out with
Avatar by linklele. How Teleport Worksa. Malifice (paraphrased):
Rulings are not 'House Rules.' Rulings are a DM doing what DMs are supposed to do.
b. greenstone (paraphrased):
Agency means that they {players} control their character's actions; you control the world's reactions to the character's actions.
Second known member of the Greyview Appreciation Society
-
2021-05-07, 03:51 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2013
- Location
- Somewhere
- Gender
Re: Is Quivering Palm a melee attack? (could you choose to knock a creature out with
It's Eberron, not ebberon.
It's not high magic, it's wide magic.
And it's definitely not steampunk. The only time steam gets involved is when the fire and water elementals break loose.
-
2021-05-08, 07:57 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- May 2018
-
2021-05-08, 09:07 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2007
- Gender
Re: Is Quivering Palm a melee attack? (could you choose to knock a creature out with
Pokemon friend code : 3067-5701-8746
Trade list can be found on my Giant League wiki page, all pokemon are kept in stock with 5 IVs, most with egg moves, some bred for Hidden Powers. Currently at 55 in stock and counting.
Padherders for my phone and my tablet!
-
2021-05-08, 10:29 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2005
- Location
- Albuquerque, NM
Re: Is Quivering Palm a melee attack? (could you choose to knock a creature out with
Honestly, "melee attack" needs to be errata'd. There are way too many things that have been entered into the game since the PHB that are technically melee attacks, but I have a hard time wrapping my head around how they 'knock someone out'. Anything that deals necrotic damage (ala QP or Inflict Wounds)? it withers matter, and even the soul... that's a bit too violent for my tastes to simply knock someone out. Psychic damage (psychic blades, shadow blade), I can see an edge case - it's short circuiting your synapses... on the other hand, why isn't it always considered knock out damage if it's the final blow?
What about green-flame blade? If you hit a creature with 11 HPs and your weapon deals 7... if flame damage deals 6, would you allow that to be knock out damage? Would you say the fire hits first?(when the "fluff", which we've all seen the argument is just as important as the mechanics, states emphatically that the flame appears after the hit).
To the OP specifically, in accord with MOG and Korvin, is if you rolled exactly the creatures remaining HP on your 10d10 roll, or it failed the save, as a DM, if it was your desire, I would be ok with it not killing the creature outright, but I would also have it be stable and unconscious. So you have 1d4 hours to track it down and do whatever you're going to do with it. So if you've left it wandering the world for 17 or so days... good luckLast edited by Theodoxus; 2021-05-08 at 10:31 AM. Reason: I think faster than I type... /sigh
Trollbait extraordinaire
-
2021-05-08, 10:32 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Sep 2015
Re: Is Quivering Palm a melee attack? (could you choose to knock a creature out with
No, but also it's clearly not intended you should be able to use it in a non-lethal way.
At 17th level, you gain the ability to set up lethal vibrations in someone's body.
PHB p86