Upick 2: Electric Boogaloo

[Rogan]

Is he still? I knew he was at the start of the conversation

Can't tell, sorry. I need to do a proper vote count. But it will be much closer, that much is sure.

[gac3]

Not anymore. The Captain and I switched to Fext. It's a tie now.

I knew at least two people had switched from cap to Fext. I guess Cap had more votes initially than I thought though.

[Fext]

anyways I am super busy today and tomorrow but should be able to catch up in full after that

just don't let anyone capitalize on confusion to push the narrative AV and I must be unaligned when as far as I can tell nothing substantiates that claim beyond our claims being similar

[Book Wombat]

Am I getting this right?
fext claims to have had a Night 1 kill immunity.
Tried to bait Serial Killer by saying they had powers to hunt them to prevent other deaths.
Doesn't actually have these powers but their role mentions the Serial Killer.

[Fext]

Am I getting this right?
fext claims to have had a Night 1 kill immunity.
Tried to bait Serial Killer by saying they had powers to hunt them to prevent other deaths.
Doesn't actually have these powers but their role mentions the Serial Killer.

confirming that's all true

[Metastachydium]

confirming that's all true

In what capacity does your power mention the killer then?

[Fext]

in some capacity

[Captain Cap]

At this point I don't really feel voting Fext anymore. There seems to have been a big misunderstanding and while they definitely lied, if they were a wolf I don't think that weird plan would have been approved by their scumbaddies. Are they a Serial Killer? Maybe, but all things considered, I think we should still focus on Snowblaze's wagon. I would be surprised if there wasn't another wolf on that wagon.

My vote returns on gac3.

[Rogan]

Vote Count
Captain Cap (4): Rogan, Batcathat, Moonfly, Supagoof
Fext (3): Gac3, Elenna, Metastachydium
Supagoof (2): Taffimai, Snowblaze
AvatarVecna (1): AvatarVecna
Gac3 (1): Captain Cap

Please double check this
Changed to take a Nina into account

---

I think a tie between Fext and Captain Cap could be good. If Cap is a wolf with a vote manipulation power, we will know it.

I also think an Power use by AV on Fext would be even better.

[gac3]

I am also now less convinced of Fext...

[Batcathat]

For what it's worth, I'm still having a hard time seeing a wolf act as Fext did. A wolf would probably want to avoid attention, this seems like the complete opposite. Still, I might try to ISO him if I have the time, if only to try to figure out what was claimed/hinted/guessed and when. Right now it's making my head spin.

[Metastachydium]

For what it's worth, I'm still having a hard time seeing a wolf act as Fext did. A wolf would probably want to avoid attention, this seems like the complete opposite. Still, I might try to ISO him if I have the time, if only to try to figure out what was claimed/hinted/guessed and when. Right now it's making my head spin.

Not a dog, but rather the killer.

[gac3]

I'll leave my vote for now until I find a new hill to die on. Maybe I'll get lucky and my dark overlords will whisper secrets to me about who to vote for.

[Rogan]

For what it's worth, I'm still having a hard time seeing a wolf act as Fext did. A wolf would probably want to avoid attention, this seems like the complete opposite. Still, I might try to ISO him if I have the time, if only to try to figure out what was claimed/hinted/guessed and when. Right now it's making my head spin.

Fext whole activity is strange. But I think wolf allies would have warned him not to stick his head out that much. So... not a wolf. But he could be a / the SK. However It feels too high of a profile to be the killer.
So, I don't know what he is planning to do. And I don't know if I can belief a single word he said.

[Book Wombat]

I'll leave my vote for now until I find a new hill to die on. Maybe I'll get lucky and my dark overlords will whisper secrets to me about who to vote for.

Is this a hint about your power? Narrator information?

[gac3]

Is this a hint about your power? Narrator information?

Mostly a joke based on the fluff of my roll as well as saying, I have no idea who to hunt now.

[Supagoof]

My head is still spinning...

I will say I asked Unavenger last night about come clarifications on my role, and got a response. So it's curious to me as to why Fext was/is still waiting on a response?

Say we had two SK roles, set to target each other...would both be of neutral alignment, or would one be town and other wolf?

We're up to three neutrals then if that's true on SKs/others. For those who played before, would that align with the previous game?

[Book Wombat]

Mostly a joke based on the fluff of my roll as well as saying, I have no idea who to hunt now.

Suspicious...

[gac3]

My head is still spinning...

I will say I asked Unavenger last night about come clarifications on my role, and got a response. So it's curious to me as to why Fext was/is still waiting on a response?

Say we had two SK roles, set to target each other...would both be of neutral alignment, or would one be town and other wolf?

We're up to three neutrals then if that's true on SKs/others. For those who played before, would that align with the previous game?

Three neutrals?

- - - Updated - - -

Suspicious...

Only way I know how to do things

[Book Wombat]

My head is still spinning...

I will say I asked Unavenger last night about come clarifications on my role, and got a response. So it's curious to me as to why Fext was/is still waiting on a response?

Say we had two SK roles, set to target each other...would both be of neutral alignment, or would one be town and other wolf?

We're up to three neutrals then if that's true on SKs/others. For those who played before, would that align with the previous game?

1. Maybe Unavenger didn't want to give a response? Hmm, I think something would still have been said though in that case like "No response".
2. I assume both would be neutral and hostile to each other.
3. In UPick I there was one Neutral, namely the Serial Killer. In Craziest Idea there was a Survivor and a Serial Killer.

[Metastachydium]

would one be town and other wolf?

I'm pretty sure a serial killer cannot, by definition, be either of those two.

[Supagoof]

Three neutrals?

- - - Updated - - -



Only way I know how to do things

Book, AV, and Fext...

[Metastachydium]

Book, AV, and Fext...

AV and (more recently) Fext are both claiming town.

[Rogan]

My head is still spinning...

I will say I asked Unavenger last night about come clarifications on my role, and got a response. So it's curious to me as to why Fext was/is still waiting on a response?

Say we had two SK roles, set to target each other...would both be of neutral alignment, or would one be town and other wolf?

We're up to three neutrals then if that's true on SKs/others. For those who played before, would that align with the previous game?

I have an open question for unavenger in my QT, so it seems like a timing issue.

A Town and a Mafia role specifically hunting each other doesn't make sense. Town needs to kill mafia and the other way round, no need to add special roles. What could make sense is one mafia role and one town role specifically hunting a third party. This would be likely if the third party in question were OP.

Two Neutrals wanting to kill each other is also possible, but it feels strange. One neutral wanting to kill one specific mafia and one specific town player would be JeenLeen in PJ.

[Book Wombat]

There could be three I guess? The Survivor, the Serial Killer and another one. Dunno.

[Supagoof]

So we have two SKs in town then is what I'm hearing, seems OP but I've got no issues with that.

[Fext]

My head is still spinning...

I will say I asked Unavenger last night about come clarifications on my role, and got a response. So it's curious to me as to why Fext was/is still waiting on a response?

Say we had two SK roles, set to target each other...would both be of neutral alignment, or would one be town and other wolf?

We're up to three neutrals then if that's true on SKs/others. For those who played before, would that align with the previous game?

I mean I only asked after I got no notification of anything at night

obviously I can't ask about that at night?

also we don't have two SK roles, we have "the Serial Killer"

[Book Wombat]

Two Neutrals wanting to kill each other is also possible, but it feels strange. One neutral wanting to kill one specific mafia and one specific town player would be JeenLeen in PJ.

Though that was because the roles could be assigned to either faction and JeenLeen had to hunt the holders of one specific role. Both could have been Town or Mafia.

[gac3]

So we have two SKs in town then is what I'm hearing, seems OP but I've got no issues with that.

No. We have two roles that mention a serial killer.

- - - Updated - - -

Though one makes sense and the other... Is Fext and their lack of explanation.

[Fext]

anyways I still believe AV is town at the moment although I haven't read much of today

if anybody wants to grab quotes or make cliffs notes over how his "I was attacked twice" apparently became just once that would be appreciated