# Thread: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

1. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by Xumtiil
I've bullied Snow enough for today, and Captain Cap is threatening me with MATH.

Unconscionable.
Didn't you just run a game where you were doing multiple math related things? Or are you just averse to statistics?

2. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

To check, I'm picking someone to target/be targeted?

Luizeu

3. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by MaltholLoth
To check, I'm picking someone to target/be targeted?

Luizeu
You are picking someone to be executed at the end of the Day phase. Highest vote count wins.

Generally you want to bold and highlight them in red, quote someone to see how they did that BBcode wise

4. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by AvatarVecna
Oh and of course there's no guarantee we're locked into a cult victory. Like maybe the only cultist is Snowblaze, and this is a town vs aliens game. Or maybe there's only one townie, and once they're converted the game is 10 aliens/6 cultists and it's a matter of who has more killing power. That'd be pretty silly, but it's possible. Maybe all townies pursue their wincon instead of taking an easy victory by getting converted, and hunt down both cult and aliens.
Me? A cultist? Never!

(Fun fact: I have never actually been a cultist or even recruited into a cult. Cult, this is not an invitation to change that. Make me the last recruit before your victory, please and thanks.)

Originally Posted by Xumtiil
I've bullied Snow enough for today, and Captain Cap is threatening me with MATH.

Unconscionable.
...you do know that I'm a maths student and hence trying to kill people for doing maths also indirectly counts as bullying me, right?

5. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by Snowblaze
Me? A cultist? Never!

(Fun fact: I have never actually been a cultist or even recruited into a cult. Cult, this is not an invitation to change that. Make me the last recruit before your victory, please and thanks.)

...you do know that I'm a maths student and hence trying to kill people for doing maths also indirectly counts as bullying me, right?
Hon... you play werewolf on a forum. You are part of a cult.

Also maths SMH I think we should be allowed to do some light bullying here.

6. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by Athedia
Didn't you just run a game where you were doing multiple math related things? Or are you just averse to statistics?
That sounds like the opposite of me, I'm generally quite math-averse but is very fond of statistics.

Originally Posted by Athedia
Hon... you play werewolf on a forum. You are part of a cult.
Where we practice lying and manipulating, while pretending to murder each other. Wow, we're like one charismatic leader (admit it, some of you read this and were disappointed I didn't consider you for the role ) from being the subject of a disturbing documentary, aren't we?

7. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by Batcathat
That sounds like the opposite of me, I'm generally quite math-averse but is very fond of statistics.

Where we practice lying and manipulating, while pretending to murder each other. Wow, we're like one charismatic leader (admit it, some of you read this and were disappointed I didn't consider you for the role ) from being the subject of a disturbing documentary, aren't we?
I think whoever is running the current game gets the role of charismatic leader.

8. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Ah, right. I forgot to cross out my vote.
One moment.

- - - Updated - - -

Originally Posted by Athedia
Then we have those certain people that will beeline for something like SK. The ones that enjoy that whole cat and mouse game. Looks at some of those people who know who they are
Holds up a mirror

Oh, and I kinda wanted to save this for later but I’m working on being a good townie and sharing info.

9. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by Athedia
Hon... you play werewolf on a forum. You are part of a cult.

Also maths SMH I think we should be allowed to do some light bullying here.
I was referring only to cults in the within-a-werewolf-game sense. Outside of that I am part of... okay the fact I'm having to count how many groups that could be considered cults I'm part of is probably a bad sign.

And I never said you couldn't bully me, I just said Xumtiil was saying he was stopping while not stopping.
Originally Posted by Xihirli
Ah, right. I forgot to cross out my vote.
One moment.

- - - Updated - - -

Holds up a mirror

Oh, and I kinda wanted to save this for later but I’m working on being a good townie and sharing info.
I have questions but asking them before bladescape responds is probably counterproductive, so I shall munch popcorn instead.

10. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Flat foot did more then light bullying. They asked the person who had open heart surgery as a baby to have a heart : smalfrown:

I already do. There I was five days old and it was operated on.

flat foot

11. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by Snowblaze
Me? A cultist? Never!

I have questions but asking them before bladescape responds is probably counterproductive, so I shall munch popcorn instead.
Putting aside how the "Cult me last" thing has me in an intense WIFOM spiral, I have more statements than questions but I guess I'll wait for blade as well.

12. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by Illven
Flat foot did more then light bullying. They asked the person who had open heart surgery as a baby to have a heart : smalfrown:

I already do. There I was five days old and it was operated on.

flat foot
oooh like the constant brain scans I got as a kid mean I have proof I am not brainless! (they thought I had absence seizures.... I had ADHD and was zoning out hardcore)

13. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by Athedia
oooh like the constant brain scans I got as a kid mean I have proof I am not brainless! (they thought I had absence seizures.... I had ADHD and was zoning out hardcore)
Now we just need someone with proof of courage and someone who wants to go home and then we're off to the wizard.

14. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by Batcathat
Now we just need someone with proof of courage and someone who wants to go home and then we're off to the wizard.
I wanna go home from work rn :(

15. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by Xumtiil
I've bullied Snow enough for today, and Captain Cap is threatening me with MATH.
You know what, actually thank you for the acknowledgment

I'll see to place a first vote in a few minutes, hopefully just the time to frame the current voting situation (after considering my math, I'll have to admit that voting out someone who discarded Town—which includes me, of course—might not be a totally bad idea, in absence of anything more concrete to go by).

- - - Updated - - -

Originally Posted by Xihirli
Ah, right. I forgot to cross out my vote.
One moment.
It shouldn't actually matter, in fact, from the OP:
Originally Posted by Taffimai
Taffi must have simply missed the change.

- - - Updated - - -

For now, I think I'd rather not lynch Snowblaze, if only because she's one of the few others who regularly keep track of votes. I'm gonna park my vote on Book Wombat counter-wagon.

Snowblaze 3: Batcathat, Let'sGetKraken, Benoojian
Book Wombat 3: Luizeu, Xihirli, Captain Cap
Xihirli 1: Athedia
Let'sGetKraken 1: Snowblaze
Xumtiil 1: Illven
Athedia 1: Book Wombat
Illven 1: flat_footed
Captain Cap 1: Xumtiil
flat_footed 1: Illven

Anyway, maybe we should look at the roles discarded together with Town and see if there's anything a townie would have been less likely to pass on (for example, discarding Investigative would be hard to justify, although that's probably true for any faction).

- - - Updated - - -

I see I counted Illven twice, my bad: the latest is that on flat_footed.

16. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Before I go to bed I’ll move onto Bladescape since he’s the only one that I know has lied to me.

17. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by Snowblaze
Me? A cultist? Never!

(Fun fact: I have never actually been a cultist or even recruited into a cult. Cult, this is not an invitation to change that. Make me the last recruit before your victory, please and thanks.)

...you do know that I'm a maths student and hence trying to kill people for doing maths also indirectly counts as bullying me, right?
Bullying people for maths is a fun past time.

I approve.

- - - Updated - - -

Originally Posted by Xihirli
Ah, right. I forgot to cross out my vote.
One moment.

- - - Updated - - -

Holds up a mirror

Oh, and I kinda wanted to save this for later but I’m working on being a good townie and sharing info.
Because the actual survivor or player who had the survivor card would react differently and I could use it to isolate information.

Also because it was a fun idea.

- - - Updated - - -

Xi not letting me stew chaos feels actually non-town of her because it's an easy target to push if she's non-town that makes her look townier.

Xi as town is unironically more likely to let me fake claim something for confusion.

Xi as Survivor is also partially more likely to let me fake claim survivor.

- - - Updated - - -

Actually Xi discarded a cult card I'm okay ignoring them for now.

- - - Updated - - -

Xi has also seen me lie as town a lot so idk why this would explicitly set off alarmbells.

Benoo/AV are the ones I'm okay voting today I think. Xi I'll need to think about.

18. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by Let'sGetKraken
Putting aside how the "Cult me last" thing has me in an intense WIFOM spiral, I have more statements than questions but I guess I'll wait for blade as well.
evil laughter
Bullying people for maths is a fun past time.

I approve.

- - - Updated - - -

Because the actual survivor or player who had the survivor card would react differently and I could use it to isolate information.

Also because it was a fun idea.

- - - Updated - - -

Xi not letting me stew chaos feels actually non-town of her because it's an easy target to push if she's non-town that makes her look townier.

Xi as town is unironically more likely to let me fake claim something for confusion.

Xi as Survivor is also partially more likely to let me fake claim survivor.

- - - Updated - - -

Actually Xi discarded a cult card I'm okay ignoring them for now.

- - - Updated - - -

Xi has also seen me lie as town a lot so idk why this would explicitly set off alarmbells.

Benoo/AV are the ones I'm okay voting today I think. Xi I'll need to think about.
That was... not the expected response, but in hindsight it should have been. Is it bad that I want to townread bladescape for fakeclaiming Survivor?

My Xihirli read is "I'm just going to park these vaguely coherent thoughts over there and come back to them in a phase or few" rn.

Also: Benoojian. Because I'm not particularly inspired by Wombat as a counterwagon and don't want him to die purely for not being me (hey, did you like how I'm softclaiming not-serial-killer? I'm totally not the serial killer, everyone!) and to see what happens.

(There are also actual reasons related to Benoojian's posts but I don't feel like explaining them rn.)

- - - Updated - - -

Also on Captain Cap's role choice point: I explicitly chose the role I thought would be most fun over the role I thought would be optimal, so I don't think "discarded a role that would have been useful" is a valid argument against anyone in isolation.

19. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Xi has also seen me lie as town a lot so idk why this would explicitly set off alarmbells.
Eh, not huge ones. Is why I just asked at first and only voted when I had a slight worry I wouldn’t be able to respond before EoD.

I figured it was probably something like that.
Athedia, maybe you drew 3 Town cards, but why discard Protecting? Seems important.

20. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by MaltholLoth
To check, I'm picking someone to target/be targeted?

Luizeu
Originally Posted by Athedia
You are picking someone to be executed at the end of the Day phase. Highest vote count wins.

Generally you want to bold and highlight them in red, quote someone to see how they did that BBcode wise
Updated and thank you. :)

21. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Now that that blade/xihirli have both said that... I have questions.... but the biggest one is the confidence Xihirli had that blade was lying. Like, why Xihirli was confident there was only a single survivor card? Did I miss that somewhere?

22. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by Xihirli
Eh, not huge ones. Is why I just asked at first and only voted when I had a slight worry I wouldn’t be able to respond before EoD.

I figured it was probably something like that.
Athedia, maybe you drew 3 Town cards, but why discard Protecting? Seems important.
Because I hate playing that role. It is a *lot* of stress for me and every time I have ended up in protective roles (off forum) I have managed to like block the vig from killing the werewolf and caused town to lose. I will do it if forced (with lots of self doubt) I just don't enjoy it as much. I will say I was aware this would raise questions and I kinda wanted someone to ask. Also I wanted to honestly let the scum teams know that I am not the one blocking kills since I know they are one of the early ones to eliminate and I just wanna be a lil more chill this game.

23. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Updated votecount!

Snowblaze 3: Batcathat, Let'sGetKraken, Benoojian
Book Wombat 2: Luizeu, Captain Cap
Xihirli 1: Athedia
Benoojian 1: Snowblaze
Xumtiil 1: Illven
Athedia 1: Book Wombat
Illven 1: flat_footed
Captain Cap 1: Xumtiil
flat_footed 1: Illven

Huh. I am now uncontested lead wagon.

24. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by Let'sGetKraken
Now that that blade/xihirli have both said that... I have questions.... but the biggest one is the confidence Xihirli had that blade was lying. Like, why Xihirli was confident there was only a single survivor card? Did I miss that somewhere?
When i was picking between my three cards and asking taffy question, i was told that there were only 1 sk and 1 surv cards.

- - - Updated - - -

Originally Posted by Snowblaze
Updated votecount!

Snowblaze 3: Batcathat, Let'sGetKraken, Benoojian
Book Wombat 2: Luizeu, Captain Cap
Xihirli 1: Athedia
Benoojian 1: Snowblaze
Xumtiil 1: Illven
Athedia 1: Book Wombat
Illven 1: flat_footed
Captain Cap 1: Xumtiil
flat_footed 1: Illven

Huh. I am now uncontested lead wagon.

Question is it simply most votes or do we need a majority by end of day to lynch?

25. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by Snowblaze
Updated votecount!

Snowblaze 3: Batcathat, Let'sGetKraken, Benoojian
Book Wombat 2: Luizeu, Captain Cap
Xihirli 1: Athedia
Benoojian 1: Snowblaze
Xumtiil 1: Illven
Athedia 1: Book Wombat
Illven 1: flat_footed
Captain Cap 1: Xumtiil
flat_footed 1: Illven

Huh. I am now uncontested lead wagon.

Honestly since Xihirli isn't forming a wagon and BW did vote against me. Changing my vote to Book Wombat

26. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by JollyChris
When i was picking between my three cards and asking taffy question, i was told that there were only 1 sk and 1 surv cards.

- - - Updated - - -

Question is it simply most votes or do we need a majority by end of day to lynch?
Most votes, and if two or more players are tied for most votes then the person who reached that total first dies.

So if day ended right now, I would die.

27. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by JollyChris
When i was picking between my three cards and asking taffy question, i was told that there were only 1 sk and 1 surv cards.

- - - Updated - - -

Question is it simply most votes or do we need a majority by end of day to lynch?
Rule is usually most votes. Tie breaker is either whoever reached the highest vote first *or* randomized.

If it is a bastard game sometimes it is "whichever is the worst outcome for town"

also ... dang it I shouldn't protect Snow, I did say I would get her out asap after she bamboozled me last game I played. But I don't want to eliminate her *juuuust* because of a petty grudge.

28. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by Athedia

also ... dang it I shouldn't protect Snow, I did say I would get her out asap after she bamboozled me last game I played. But I don't want to eliminate her *juuuust* because of a petty grudge.
tbf I definitely deserve a D1 death for that game.

Make whatever vote you think maximises your alignment's chances of winning, and if that's a vote for me that's fine.

29. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by Athedia
also ... dang it I shouldn't protect Snow, I did say I would get her out asap after she bamboozled me last game I played. But I don't want to eliminate her *juuuust* because of a petty grudge.
To be fair, for a D1 vote "petty grudge" is about a good a reason as anything else. Granted, with the discard list we actually have some D1 information this game, but it's certainly not much nor easily interpreted.

Between "this is what Snow wouldn't be expected to do so it's probably what she did", discarding a town card and general gutfeel I'm pretty alright with Snow getting yeeted. Not exactly confident in the least, but alright.

30. ## Re: Crazy Idea IV: Everything Everywhere All At Once!

Originally Posted by Batcathat
To be fair, for a D1 vote "petty grudge" is about a good a reason as anything else. Granted, with the discard list we actually have some D1 information this game, but it's certainly not much nor easily interpreted.

Between "this is what Snow wouldn't be expected to do so it's probably what she did", discarding a town card and general gutfeel I'm pretty alright with Snow getting yeeted. Not exactly confident in the least, but alright.
Elaborate on the general gutfeel please?

(The town card thing is a valid point against me I guess. Somewhat less okay with "this is what Snow wouldn't be expected to do so it's probably what she did" being used as a serious argument against me but... shrug I'm not convinced it's that wolfy for BCH specifically so...)

#### Posting Permissions

• You may not post new threads
• You may not post replies
• You may not post attachments
• You may not edit your posts
•