Results 1 to 30 of 32
Thread: HP, what it truly means.
-
2008-05-31, 01:36 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2008
- Location
- At R'Lyeah, waiting.....
- Gender
HP, what it truly means.
The short answer is: Whatever you want it to mean. There's no right or wrong answers.
The PHB lists HP as somewhat of a driving force that keeps you going in battle. Your will to live under constant pummeling, if you will. Which I guess is why you have to do saves against massive damage or be royaly done for. But that's cool.
Alot of people say it's blood loss. That's cool to. However when you treat HP loss as blood loss, you have to look at piercing weapons and weapons that deal extra damage through blood loss.
If you are truly dying through losing blood, should a piercing weapon not deal more damage? Should you then remove effects such as Bearding; which already deal extra damage through blood loss? Maybe. But who knows if mechanically it would work out.
That brings me to my next point. D&D is whatever you want it to be. No more, and certainly not any less. Certainly you should change it if it doesn't work out. If you feel better about your character bleeding half to death every time he's hit, that's great. It's theatrical, and create a good illusion of the game. However it's also a bit broken by Magic. And semblence of realism is disillusioned the second someone touches you and three of your vital organs as well as 14 pints of blood are back.
But that's okay, because it's fantasy, it's beleivable, and it's just plane awesome.
So, in conclusion, however you view HP, you're right. If D&D was all about realism, you'd have like, 7 HP at level 30. :P
As for the problem with 4th edition and resting granting your HP back, if that's not how you played before, then certainly don't change. Just remove that rule and replace it with the 3.x natural healing. What is D&D afterall if it's not maleable?
Well, can we all agree that we won't always have the same views on the game and that's okay?The Necroswanson's Deviantart.
Freemanatar by Phase, thank you ever so much.
Remember kids, Vortigaunts say, "The Free Man is not a number."
-
2008-05-31, 01:42 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2006
- Gender
Re: HP, what it truly means.
Harry Potter, that'S what HP means.
ok, I'll stop kidding around. Yhea, you are right. It's a pretty abstract thing. Ever learned the Warhammer Fantasy system? there are "wound points", these are, for lack of a better explanation, all the wound you can take before a wound gets serious (arrr, it's only a flesh wound!)
when you drop to 0 Wound point, you have some maluses to your throw, but you aren'T dead. No. 0 Wound points means that every hit you'll get will be life-treathening ones. Because, you know, you are at your limits.
I prefer it this way, personnally. Warhammer treat Armor as "damage reduction", shield as "parry opportunity" + parry bonus. Oh, and every hit can be very, very dangerous. A high-level character, designed for combat, has only, like, a max of 25 wound points. If you consider that every hit does 1d10 + Strenght Bonus + (weapon bonus) - (armor bonus) - (toughness bonus of the victim), it can end up very, very nasty after a few 9s or 10s (specially when you think that you get to re-roll the 10s)
-
2008-05-31, 01:54 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2008
- Location
- Koth
- Gender
Re: HP, what it truly means.
Yes, a million RPGs do "injury" and "modelling real combat" much better than D&D. Doesn't really matter here, though. (Some also do it in much more detail, but they usually also do it worse overall. See Rolemaster - detailed as heck, and totally unplayable and often ridiculous.)
The first post also applies to levels, incidentally. They're likewise not a measure of actual experience - measured in time or in number of battles or other encounters - but rather a dramatic abstraction that usually correlated slightly with dramatic importance. (Which is why in my games the average level of the world seems to go up as the game progresses, although at a fraction of the speed the PCs' levels rise; and why high-level minions make perfect sense.)
Some people will, of course, wrongheadedly insist that these attributes are not abstractions but some kind of objective measurements, which is pretty silly when you examine the issue...
-
2008-05-31, 01:55 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2006
- Location
- St. Paul, MN
Re: HP, what it truly means.
Hit Points
-
2008-06-02, 05:46 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2008
Re: HP, what it truly means.
I agree with the 4e PHB: HP represents your combined will and ability to keep fighting. I avoid trying to break down the abstraction much further than that.
-
2008-06-02, 05:51 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Sep 2007
Re: HP, what it truly means.
Pssht, Necro. Your kung-fu is weak. THIS is what HP means, right out of the pros mouths:
What do hit points represent? Here's a quote from Saga Edition:
Hit points (sometimes abbreviated "hp") represent two things in the game world: the ability to take physical punishment and keep going, and the ability to turn a serious blow into a graze or near miss. As you become more experienced, you become more adept at parrying strikes, dodging attacks, and rolling with blows such that you minimize or avoid significant physical trauma, but all this effort slowly wears you down. Rather than trying to keep track of the difference between attacks and how much physical injury you take, hit points are an abstract measure of your total ability to survive damage.
Hit points are not a universal gauge of concrete, physical toughness. If a soldier and a small tank both have 100 hit points, that doesn't mean the soldier is physically as tough as the tank! Hit points are deliberately abstract so that the same measure of damage can be applied to an inanimate object (such as a wall), an animate object (such as a tank), a massive creature (such as a Krayt dragon), or a high-level character. Consider what hit points mean to each of them:
The high-level character's durability comes mostly from avoiding attacks, rolling with blows, and so forth. Only a fraction of his survival is based on his physical ability to absorb damage.
The Krayt dragon's hit points include skill and speed, but a much greater portion comes from its sheer size and bulk. In other words, it's hard to hit something that big in a way that will cause critically injuries.
The tank's hit points are completely physical in nature, but they aren't determined only by its size and mass. They also account for qualities such as the resiliency of the tank's systems, the volatility of its fuel and payload, the number of redundant and backup systems, and so on.
The wall's hit points are completely physical and almost entirely determined by simple physical characteristics such as the type of material used to build the wall, the thickness of the wall, and so on.
Over the years, some players have developed a terrible misconception that a character with 100 hit points can be shot almost a dozen times in the chest. Not true! Both a high-level soldier with 100 hit points and a stormtrooper with 10 hit points will be grievously injured and possibly killed by a single blaster wound to the chest. However, the high-level soldier will dodge the first nine shots, and the stormtrooper won't. (If it helps, imagine that a high-level hero has a reserve of "virtual hit points" to offset attacks that would otherwise be lethal. Once he has exhausted his reserve, the blow that finally reduces him to 0 hit points will solidly connect and cause serious physical trauma.)
-
2008-06-02, 05:59 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2007
- Location
- Canberra, Australia
- Gender
Re: HP, what it truly means.
I'd say it's combination of physical toughness (when you taking falling damage, morale has nothing to do with it), determination (hence why minions have only 1 HP, they are just cheap grunts who lack the will to win) and your characters understanding of how to avoid taking serious damage.
For the last one, say an enemy manages to get through your defenses and stabs you. A low level character isn't used to being stabbed so they take more damage. A high level character knows how to twist and dodge to make the stabbing not hit somewhere quite so vital.
-
2008-06-02, 06:01 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Sep 2007
Re: HP, what it truly means.
Take a look at me olde poste.
Or just hear the gods speak:
http://www.wizards.com/default.asp?x...w20070322jc101
-
2008-06-02, 06:04 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2007
- Gender
Re: HP, what it truly means.
HP, or "hit points," are an abstraction of how close you are to death.
I win the thread with my clear-cut definition that no one can ever disagree with.
Neutral-4e, Anti-Nonsense.
Thanks to Omega for the rocksome avatar.
-
2008-06-02, 06:06 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Nov 2007
- Location
- Toronto
- Gender
Re: HP, what it truly means.
A wise man once said "You know how sometimes your character will get the stuffing beaten out of him? Well HP is how much stuffing he has."
-
2008-06-02, 06:13 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Nov 2007
Re: HP, what it truly means.
The following errors occurred with your search:
1. This forum requires that you wait 300 seconds between searches. Please try again in 306 seconds.
-
2008-06-02, 06:21 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2006
- Location
- Norn Iron
- Gender
-
2008-06-02, 09:27 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2007
Re: HP, what it truly means.
I think it's a common second language error. Especially from languages where bon means good and mal means bad. So pretty much all the Latin-derived ones.
And HP can be how well you dodge blows, or pure physical resistance. Yes, it makes no sense after level 6. It's unrealistic, we know. But it is damn cool. And heroes in movies always take unrealistic levels of punishment and keep on trucking, so why not DnD?
-
2008-06-02, 09:33 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2005
- Location
- NYC
Re: HP, what it truly means.
An interesting tangent is that 4e has introduced the "bloodied" condition to the abstract HP system, and IMO it is best to treat it as a recognizable condition which you can flavor however you want as the situation merits: you're limping a little bit, you're favoring one arm, you've been nicked and are trickling some blood, you took a blow to the noggin and are a trifle woozy, whatever you like.
You have your way. I have my way. As for the right way, the correct way, and the only way, it does not exist. - Friedrich Nietzsche
-
2008-06-02, 09:53 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- May 2008
Re: HP, what it truly means.
Hp abstraction is mostly an excuse. The first person who came up with the HP concept, likely wasn't thinking of abstractions. Then people wanted more realism, so HP was later described as an abstraction. It was an abstraction that didn't make much sense, because the healing system made it seem like physical damage. In 4E D&D the asbtraction finally makes a lot more sense, do to charcters being able to heal themsleves, and clerics always healing a percentage of a persons HP. It makes the PC's seem less really injured, and more just banged up.
Still I would prefer a system that radically changed the HP concept. The number of HP your character gets at first level, is the only HP you should get. No HP from leveling. Leveling would just increase defenses, and the ability to dodge.
-
2008-06-02, 09:54 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- May 2007
Re: HP, what it truly means.
Well, here's one of the places D&D kinda falls flat on its face, in my opinion. If HP doesn't represent physical health, then weapon damage doesn't represent physical damage. But if that's the case, why does a longsword deal more damage than a rapier? Why do piercing weapons have a higher critical multiplier?
-
2008-06-02, 09:55 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2005
- Location
- NYC
Re: HP, what it truly means.
You have your way. I have my way. As for the right way, the correct way, and the only way, it does not exist. - Friedrich Nietzsche
-
2008-06-02, 10:08 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- May 2008
Re: HP, what it truly means.
I know it changes almost everything. I am waiting for some genious to come up with a solution.
Hp is my biggest problem with D&D. It ruins any immersion process.
-
2008-06-02, 10:46 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- May 2007
- Location
- The Land of Cleves
- Gender
Re: HP, what it truly means.
And HP can be how well you dodge blows, or pure physical resistance. Yes, it makes no sense after level 6. It's unrealistic, we know. But it is damn cool. And heroes in movies always take unrealistic levels of punishment and keep on trucking, so why not DnD?
Yeah, you don't see people in the real world taking that much damage and surviving, but that can be explained as, first of all, 20th-level folks are extremely rare, second, that level of violence is also very rare in our world, and third, if a 20th-level fellow does happen to find himself in a violent situation, since his opponent probably isn't 20th level too, he's likely to get himself out of the situation before he gets that seriously injured.Time travels in divers paces with divers persons.
As You Like It, III:ii:328
Chronos's Unalliterative Skillmonkey Guide
Current Homebrew: 5th edition psionics
-
2008-06-03, 04:08 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2006
- Location
- Norn Iron
- Gender
Re: HP, what it truly means.
No, it was pretty well intended as an abstraction from day one.
Then people wanted more realism, so HP was later described as an abstraction. It was an abstraction that didn't make much sense, because the healing system made it seem like physical damage.
In 4E D&D the asbtraction finally makes a lot more sense, [due] to charcters being able to heal themsleves, and clerics always healing a percentage of a persons HP.
Still I would prefer a system that radically changed the HP concept. The number of HP your character gets at first level, is the only HP you should get. No HP from leveling. Leveling would just increase defenses, and the ability to dodge.
As to realism - there are flying dragons and the PCs are supposed to be able to fight them. I don't think realism is at the top of the priority list with design goals like that.
-
2008-06-03, 07:12 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2005
- Location
- NJ
- Gender
Re: HP, what it truly means.
Actually, Compleat Arduin managed to do static HP rather well. Each PC starts out with maybe 20 or so HP (less if you're a pansy elf or something like that, much more if you are an ogre or throon) and it never changes under normal circumstances (barring very powerful magiks, divine reward, curses, or horrifying injuries). HP really represented physical durability.
In practice, it works out very nicely, though it does have the habit of making PC's far more breakable.It doesn't matter what game you're playing as long as you're having fun.
-
2008-06-03, 07:29 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2007
Re: HP, what it truly means.
Excuse me, but if my epic barbarian with 20 con is naked, completed tied up with enchanted adamantine chains, pined by a tarrasque monk 20 and has just failed his save against three diferent kinds of hold monster effects(aka no chance in hell of dodging), and mr kobold mook over there pulls out a bow and start shooting at him, he'll need lot of arrows to kill my barbarian, and there's
simply no chance in hell that he can one shot me.
Not to mention lava swiming. You can'd dodge or parry lava when you're inside it.
Honestly, I can't understand. Everybody is twisting the laws of reality with their attacks on one way or another. What is the dificulty to imagine that as they level up, all the supernatural stuff PCs go trough simply makes them much harder, and the fighter can have his guts pulled out and keep fighting?
Why can't the fighter flesh be so toughned up by a thousand combats that when the enemy lands an axe blow in the epic fighter's neck, the blade simply gets stuck in the steel like muscles wich can tear apart rock easily?
-
2008-06-03, 07:33 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2006
- Location
- Norn Iron
- Gender
Re: HP, what it truly means.
In 1ed, he could. Well, actually in that case the kobold would be better of just walking over and slitting your throat, due to a kobold's low attack rating, but that would not apply if he was just standing beside you. Btb, that would be an instant kill.
HP's can be overridden, or they can if the DM's got half a brain.
-
2008-06-03, 07:35 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2006
- Location
- Norn Iron
- Gender
-
2008-06-03, 07:38 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2007
- Location
- Helsinki, Finland
- Gender
-
2008-06-03, 07:59 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2007
-
2008-06-03, 08:02 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2008
- Location
- Orlando, FL
- Gender
Re: HP, what it truly means.
Wrong... and wrong.
Saving Throws
Originally Posted by SRD
Originally Posted by SRDLast edited by SamTheCleric; 2008-06-03 at 08:03 AM.
-
2008-06-03, 08:02 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2007
- Location
- Helsinki, Finland
- Gender
Re: HP, what it truly means.
Sorry, wrong.
And again, wrong.
Originally Posted by SRDLast edited by Attilargh; 2008-06-03 at 08:04 AM.
-
2008-06-03, 09:33 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Nov 2006
- Gender
Re: HP, what it truly means.
I still think the best way to imagine HP is a nebulous combination of physical resilience, luck, avoidance, and sheer willpower. A "hit" may do 20 HP damage, but the character with enough HP emerges with barely a scratch, if even that. However, no one stays lucky, can dodge, and take damage forever so as HP depletes each successful attack has a higher chance of actually slicing something vital. Obviously massive damage can break through this protection, but even that is less and less likely as your character gains more experience (and higher Fort saves.)
I do see the point of people that say that it doesn't make sense for higher level characters to live longer in lava or in pits of acid. It really doesn't. On the other hand, it doesn't make sense for people to survive *at all.* Any player that dives into lava or runs through a burning, crumbling building or swims in acid knowing that they have the HP to survive the trip is gaming the system in the first place. It's RAW, and I won't argue that, but it's cheesy to let player's get away with no penalty for doing something that should kill them automatically.
-
2008-06-03, 09:37 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2006
- Location
- Norn Iron
- Gender
Re: HP, what it truly means.
QFT, as the kids say. Jumping into lava = death, HP notwithstanding. Apart from those few points at the bottom, HP represent your ability to avoid injury. If you actively do something that must injure you then you lose the protection of that portion (possibly the vast majority) of your hit points.
Last edited by nagora; 2008-06-03 at 09:44 AM.