Quote Originally Posted by Cheesegear View Post
Fulgrim had three swords at one point?

The ending of False Gods has Fulgrim clearly in possession of the Anathame.
Fulgrim has Fulgrim with the Laer Blade and the Fireblade.
Short answer: Yes.
Long answer:
Quote Originally Posted by Fulgrim(book), pages 362-363
Vespasian now saw that his lord and master had three swords laid out before him. Fireblade lay pointed at a statue of Marius Vairosean, the ... silver sword of the Laer pointed at one of Julius Kaesoron. A weapon with a glittering grey blade and golden hilt lay in a shattered piece of marble sitting between the two statues...
Given that that last weapon fits the anathame's description, yes. Fulgrim had three swords.