OOTS #844 - The Discussion Thread

[Mantine]

That he believed Soon would break his oath almost immediately.

That Soon's paladins were fascists.

That Soon was a coward who deserved to die.

We don't technically know that he believed Soon would commit torture, but GMantis has a much stronger case here than you do.

Nope. Sorry, still not doing it.
Evaluating someone as a self-righteous bastard doesn't equal thinking that said bastard would do something that goes against what being a self-righteous bastard means in the first place.
Gmantis gave a bunch of "obvious" things which were nothing more than jumping to conclusions. Torturing is an evil act, THIS is a fact, and goes against what even a fascist paladin would do.

You can think of a judge as a "moral, rigid, self-enticed ******", you can expect him to go back on his word for "law's sake", but you still wouldn't imagine him going around burning criminals alive or things like that.