Quote Originally Posted by Kish View Post
Ah. So now "Eugene says Roy was the highest level Good character on the field while referring to the Battle for Azure City, without the words 'until you died,' without so much as a hint that his claim stops when Roy dies, without any indication of how Eugene knows the exact levels--or alignments, for that matter--of everyone-who-is-not-Soon" means "Roy was officially the highest level Good character on the field up until he died."

Is it, in your eyes, in fact possible for Eugene to have been either wrong or lying?
Soon is irrelevant. There is no possibility of the Azure City invasion being Soon's fight to lose, and no possibility that Soon can bear responsibility for how badly it went--even in the part he could control, his ultimate failure was due to Miko's untimely intervention right when he was about to succeed. Since these are the points on which Eugene is needling Roy, neither Eugene nor Roy has any reason to consider Soon in the context of their conversation.