I'm sure you already know my argument for that. Well, the alternate example argument, anyway. That's not even touching my OOC Fluttershy Argument.
But the comparison was Gunter to Fluttershy, not Marceline's Dad to Fluttershy.
... Discord would make a -great- Marceline's Dad. I can imagine half his cracks in character...
"Well, I'm certainly not the guy who's gonna steal your soul."
"So, this next part will be all the more horrifying!"
"That's right! I'm your momma!"
"No! You can't have my soul! I don't even... look, just get in here!"
"Fine! Go! I'm too busy sucking to deal with you."
.... ****, now I can't -not- imagine his dialog with Fluttershy involving him risking -his- soul, since she's the only one that actually knocked him out of his comfort zone.
Too bad that Scootaloo makes for a much better Gunter, though. Heh... who told you you could fly. That still cracks me up!
.... am I failing my detect sarcasm roll? I wonder if I put too much thought into this...