I don't know if this would just make things worse, but maybe there could be a secondary catch-all list that has all the minutia. Sort of like how the MitD thread has a showcase of the best fits, but anything with even a minimal defense has a place for inclusion.

*

To me, the post on Avatar is highly relevant, because it deals with the Giant's theories and attitudes on storytelling. It's a nice look behind the curtain of OotS, even if OotS isn't its direct subject.

I want to know everything he thinks about Aquaman, too (and I DC to hire him to write the book), but that's just me.