Quote Originally Posted by Red Fel View Post
The problem is as follows.

Let us start with the assumption that any object can qualify as an improvised weapon. If we assume that improvised weapons qualify as weapons for the Quick Draw feat, the following logic emerges:
  1. Quick Draw allows you to draw a weapon as a free action rather than as a move action. This is based upon the RAW of the feat.
  2. Any object is an improved weapon. This is one of our two assumptions.
  3. An improvised weapon counts as a weapon for purposes of Quick Draw. This is another of our assumptions.
  4. Therefore, any object counts as an improvised weapon for purposes of Quick Draw. This is the conclusion we arrive at by combining our two assumptions.
  5. Therefore, Quick Draw allows us to draw any object as a free action rather than as a move action. This is the conclusion we arrive at by combining the RAW of the feat with our assumptions.

The conclusion, while based upon sound logic, is nonetheless invalid because Quick Draw was not designed to allow you to draw any object as a free action. If it was, it would have said "you can remove any object from a storage container you have on hand as a move action." It does not; it specifically applies to drawing a weapon. Note also that, unlike drawing a weapon (which is generally a move action), removing an object from a container is not always a move action, depending on the container and the object.

Because our conclusion is invalid, we know that one of our two assumptions (or both) must be untrue. Either not every object can qualify as an improvised weapon, or improvised weapons do not qualify for Quick Draw, or both.
The problem is that you ignored your point three in deciding its invalid. Your not drawing "any object", your drawing something which would be classified as a weapon.

Of course its still purely academic as no ones really proposing this.