Pervy guys playing innocent (?) girls

[BWR]

Spoiler: Episode 2: A wild imouto appears

Show

It's a new school day and after first period Keitaro sits talking to Shuu while the girls crowd around. A beautiful young girl sweeps majestically into class, goes straight over to Keitaro and gives him a big hug. The girls make shocked noises and all the guys hate Keitaro even more now that this new hottie takes a liking to him without even introducing herself.
"Wha... wha... wha...what?" Keitaro stammers looking bewildered.
"Do you not recognize me, onii-chan?" Yuki says, pouting.
"Onii-chan?" the other girls echo as one. "How come we didn't know of this?"
Keitaro haltingly lays out the sad family history.
"And I transferred here to see my onii-chan again!" Yuki says proudly.
"A little sister transfer student: will his luck never end?" come the disgusted mutterings of the other boys in class.
"Onii.chan, show me around school. I am new here and do not want to get lost." Yuki says, grabbing Keitaro's arm.
Instantly seizing the opportunity to score points with Keitaro, Yoshiko grabs his other arm and drags the two away.
Ayano and Naru tag along trying to making spiteful comments at each other on the way. Ayano is quickly waylaid by her fan club that want to introduce her to new members, get selfies with her, etc. She sees Keitaro disappear with the other girls but can only smile and pretend to not notice.
Yoshiko turns on the charm and tries to make friends with Yuki, who is not given an excuse to find fault with her.

During lunch Keitaro has the curry and after trying it Yuki decides that her big brother has poor taste, and is sorely disappointed by the quality and choice of cakes at the school cafeteria . Yoshiko decides to make lunch for him tomorrow. Shuu, Keitaro's BFF, comments that they need to form a study group since Keitaro sucks in English. The girls immediately latch on to the idea and decide that they will have a session at Keitaro's place after club activities that evening.
During musical club after school Ayano continues Keitaro's singing lessons.
"It's a bit embarrassing to stand on stage and sing as poorly as I do," he protests.
"Time for some more private lessons, then" she responds sweetly, ushering Keitaro out to an empty classroom.
Naru seethes but trusts to luck that something will get in the way of Ayano's plans (it doesn't) and Yoshiko tries unsuccessfully to get some measurements from Keitaro.
Yuki observes the machinations of the girls and decides to change the script for "Romeo and Juliette" to sabotage the girls' efforts, but is informed she must be a member of the club to effect changes in the script. She tsks but decides that the Chess Club is more her speed - she'll find some other way to sabotage Ayano's obvious and improper efforts.
Finally alone, Ayano instructs Keitaro in the basics of singing. "Singing is all about breathing properly, Keitaro-kun. Here, feel how my stomach and chest expand," she says, taking his hands and placing them on her. Keitaro blushes furiously and stammers something about how cannot possibly do this.
"Oh, nonsense! Here, put your arms around me and feel the whole thing." She turns and pulls his arms around here, placing his hands on a couple of soft mounds.
Keitaro flees the scene, after a few moments of shock.
"Oh, shoot." she pouts.

After club, Keitaro leads the group to his house and sets everyone in the living room, then goes to the kitchen to get something to drink (so he can run upstairs and quickly clean his room). While Keitaro is busy, Yoshiko sneaks up to his room and starts rumamging around. "Tch. What a boring and bland taste in porn he has," she thinks looking at his poorly hidden hoard. Self-consciously she compares her bust size to the girls in the magazines and takes a few pictures just in case she feels the need to embarrass him a bit some time in the future.
Yuki followed Keitaro to the kitchen to help him carry refreshments. She plans to trip and spill juice all over Ayano, hoping to drive her out. Naru somehow manages to get in the way (Splash Magnet ftw) and gets her bosom all sticky and wet and shows off her assets to great advantage. She borrows the bathroom to clean up and gets one of Keitaro's shirts to wear. Keitaro is rather distracted the rest of the evening by the sight of Naru in his shirt so he doesn't get much work done.
The next day at lunch Yoshiko presents her homemade bento with onigiri and Naru gives more cookies to thank Keitaro for the loan of his shirt. Yuki shows up with a fancy baguette and two slices of cake. The group talks about the upcoming class trip to Kyoto and the onsen they will be staying at. Yuki inwardly seethes at the situation but keeps her pleasant face on.

The trip to Kyoto is generally uneventful. The prized seat next to Keitaro is taken by Shuu but the girls bully their way into the seats before and behind. After getting settled in their rooms the gang decide to hit the hot springs before dinner.
"Why don't we try the mixed baths, Keitaro?" Yoshiko suggests.
"M..mm..mixed baths?"
"Of course. It's the old way of doing things and we're in Kyoto - when in Rome."
"It seems a bit weird."
"We'll be wearing bathing suits."
"I guess..."
Yoshiko and Naru are already in the spring when Shuu and Keitaro enter. There is an awkward silence as they hear the noise from the girls and boys in the other springs. Ayano comes in accidentally dropping her towel showing everything (she 'forgot' her swimsuit). Shuu quickly exits the spring leaving a pink spot in the pool and Keitaro crosses his legs and looks very determinedly up to the night sky.
"My, the star is beautiful tonight! Stars. Stars are beautiful."
The other girls make outraged exclamations while Ayano smugly puts her towel on again and gets into the water. It has an unfortunate tendency to come undone, much to everyone else's discomfort.
During dinner Naru manages to get a spot next to Keitaro and gets him talking about his favorite baseball team. While not particularly interested in sports, Naru is good at feigning interest. Ayano and Yoshiko look on enviously, trying to lean over their neighbors to gain Keitaro's attention.

The next day the class visits a temple. The girls notice a luck draw and try their luck. Ayano and Naru get "Average luck" but Yoshiko pulls "Great luck in love" - the red string of fate tying her and her ancient love together.
"What did you get, Keitaro?" Naru asks.
"Um, 'Mixed luck: great complications'"

The girls notice a miko holding a small bow and a padded arrow. "We're celebrating the 300th anniversary of a great love story here. If you hit your heart's desire with the arrow you will be guarenteed a happy marriage."
A brief moment of panicked scrambling for their wallets to pay the fee. Yoshiko grabs the bow first but Ayano and Naru get in the way and spoil her aim. Perhaps Yoshiko will have a long-lasting relationship with a bush. Ayano snatches the bow out of her hands and takes a new arrow and hits Keitaro in the back of his head.
"Ow!" Keitaro rubs his head and looks around. Ayano stands there beaming, bow in hand.
"What's going on?" Keitaro asks.
"Didn't you hear what the miko said? About eternal love?"
"So why did you hit me?"
Ayano stops, looking surprised, then stammers a bit about "If you'd like, I mean, it was sort of a thing that just happened..." she blushes and looks away, her eyes coincidentally falling on Shuu.
Misunderstanding the situation, Keitaro offers to help her get to know Shuu better.
"You idiot! You don't understand anything!" Ayano slaps Keitaro and storms off, leaving the bewildered Protagonist-kun wondering what he did wrong.

As we suspected, U immediately chose Sairenji Yuki, and he seemed a bit weirded out that we had made that character with him in mind. As we also suspected, he is playing the jealous little sister who wants attention after a long period of neglect, not anything more serious. In any case, he fit right in and played the character perfectly. Not being in the same class will limit his opportunities to be in certain scenes, like the school trip. He took the role of Shuu to have something to do, and one of his abilities, "Home turf advantage", was designed to take this into account (once per episode the sister may make an unopposed Allure or Skill roll to win a VP so long as she was not in a scene that granted VPs with the other girls).
This session saw a bit less roleplaying and a bit more "I try to do X", especially by H who is a bit too stuck in the mindset of trying to use his abilities and finding and excuse to use them rather than trying to do stuff and then seeing if his abilities can be used. He also seems to be forgetting the Tsundere and trying to make her into a pervert. He is aware of this and by his own admission is trying to move a bit beyond his usual natural inclination to play the perv. So no need to switch out an archetype, though I did bring the possibility up.
The roleplaying problems are at least as much my fault as everyone else's for not pushing things and leading with a good example - lack of provided detail and roleplay has always been one of my main faults as a GM. Luckily, L often steps in and and tries to help things along.
Still, everyone seemed to have fun and next week we can try to do better.