The Index of the Giant's Comments V―On a Saner Forum, We Wouldn't Need this Index

[Keltest]

This is indeed compelling. And I would add that the question was "How is he casting spells? He should be fallen and spell-less!" not "how can he cast evil spells despite not being evil?" Keep.

I don't find it particularly compelling. Circumstances change. Quotes that were useful once aren't particularly any more. The usability of the index to find any specific quote goes down the more we have, so if we have a quote that doesn't tell us anything unique, why would we keep it just because it used to?