Originally Posted by
Kish
Look at what I said when I voted for her. I trusted that, with the two of you advancing incompatible claims, one was lying and the liar was a wolf, and that sticking to the "kill Lex-Kat and, if she comes out truthful, kill Fleeing Coward" plan would reveal which was which. If she was the truthful one, well, losing one hunter would have been worth it to kill a duck. If you'd said "don't kill her, she clarified that her Mason network day-baned me, not her personally*," that would have been different than just "Don't kill her because now I'm saying so"--which had the primary effect of making me wonder if you were both wolves and you were counting on the lynch you called on her being too late in the day to actually happen.
To put it another way: I vigilante killed her for the exact same stated reason that I voted to lynch her before that.
*Which would have given me, or made public, the information that she was a Mason, so it's understandable that you didn't, but saying just "don't do it because I say don't do it" carried no weight at all.