Kickstarter Discussion Thread - How the Paladin Got His Scar (SPOILERS!)

[Peelee]

*shrugs* I dunno, Peelee. It's unlikely that anyone is going to argue for a version of the story- or any other change- that they actively dislike. All I can do is try and explain the reasons for why I (and perhaps a non-trivial subset of other readers) might have preferred a different version. Which I think I did.

Saying "I don't like that this character did this thing," or "I don't like the direction the story is taking," or "I think the story is inconsistent" is one thing. Saying "I think that a character should have had a completely different arc that would have negated the character's entire purpose in the story, and I will argue against anyone who says otherwise" is quite another thing entirely.

Also, I'm incredibly disinterested when people try to shoehorn in "morally justified" arguments, even if veiled enough to skirt on the right side of the ban.