Balance. Why do we need it?

[Psyren]

The D&D PHB told my players that a Fighter was as good a choice as a Druid.

The D&D PHB lied.

Do people honestly think this? Do the designers really have to write "MAGIC GIVES YOU THINGS" in flaming letters or be seen as dirty swindlers?

Because I have a PHB, and let me tell you, I never came away from it thinking Caramon should be equally capable to Raistlin and Goldmoon. All of them contributing is an admirable goal, sure, but being equals? Really?