Let's Read The Immortal Handbook Bestiary

[Melcar]

I said "generally accepted", IIRC.

EDIT: It turns out I made a more blanket statement in the OP. I mostly did that because it sounds better in an essay. I did mean it to be "generally accepted" even though that's not what I wrote.

But is it though... at level 15? Could you provide any substantial proof of this statement? Its the first (as in this thread) that I have heard level 15 being "broken".

Considering how broken Core is, I'd say that design decision failed utterly.

Could you clarify exactly what you mean when you say broken? Because I have played many games since year 2000 all using PHB and DMG and MM without anything happening... So what does "broken mean?

That doesn't mean that the system isn't broken, just because you avoid the broken bits.

No, it just means that it doesn't matter. A wizard can be very powerful without cheesing it.. Especially, when hopyfully the DM and players somewhat makes sure the challenge fits to the party... so whats the problem? Is it really a problem that some people think that the rules don't work?