This is basically an argument thread about numbers as opposed to opinion.

The "overrated" selections that people are picking are mechanically effective.

"Underrated" picks are personal likes.

Okay I'll play this. Non-Magic classes are rated low because they lack Roll and/or Roleplay versatility.

I don't recommend everything make the same character, but the ideal Player Character has combat ability, skills, and spells. Giving them a distinctive personality is always beneficial, even if you make a "Only Sane Man" to contrast extreme personalities.

Don't commit the Stormwind Fallacy and think you can't game and roleplay at the same time on the same character.