Quote Originally Posted by Pelle View Post
Sounds like it went well, and you seem a little overly critical here.

And what did Brian think, did he also realize it wasn't working properly? As long as he tries to imrove, I think you should cut him some slack, even though everything isn't perfect now.

I would be more worried about your fellow party members, and their seemingly lack of buy-in to a group game...
Absolutely agree with everything here.

I am intentionally being critical so we have something to talk about. As I said above, I enjoyed the game and would be happy with the campaign if every session goes as well, although I will probably get pretty frustrated if I have to spend an hour every session watching a condition track bounce back and forth for an hour and then spending another hour trying to talk the other players into going along with the adventure.

Brian made the sailing mini-game on the drive over and admits he didn't think it through, so that's perfectly understandable.