View Single Post

Thread: Xianxia novels where the MC uses a gun?

  1. - Top - End - #6
    Ogre in the Playground
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location

    Default Re: Xianxia novels where the MC uses a gun?

    Lord of the Mysteries
    - well written: yes
    - xianxia / cultivation: no
    - uses a gun: yes

    I'd say it's a Chinese power fantasy story, more so than a traditional cultivation story. It's a pseudo-Victorian England world with airships, steampunk elements and firearms. The power system draws heavily from Lovecraft's works and horror tropes, such as "things man wasn't mean to know", "death awaits us all", "on a cosmic scale, humanity is puny and weak and meaningless" and so on. The protagonist wakes up in this world, knowing nothing, and soon ends up working as a supernatural cop of sorts - guns are one of the tools they're equipped with.

    It's very well written for a translated Chinese web novel, and with a great translator and editor, I could see it getting published in the West to positive reviews. The translation I read was somewhere between good and alright, and the editing was mostly passable, but it's not quite up to the standards of Cradle.

    Upgrade Specialist in Another World
    - well written: meh
    - xianxia / cultivation: yes
    - uses a gun: yes (sometimes)

    It's a pretty stereotypical xianxia story. A normal nobody dies, has to get revenge for his friendly grandpa, finds out he has a crafting-related cheat, starts traveling to join a crafting sect, eventually gets an opportunity to learn crafting, crafts various items including guns, etc. Guns are one of the weapons he creates once he's already an established crafter, and they're not his primary weapon or his most powerful long-range option, although they are convenient in certain situations.


    40 Millenniums of Cultivation
    - well written: ???
    - xianxia / cultivation: yes
    - uses a gun: ???

    It's a futuristic scifi cultivation mishmash, so guns are a thing. It's not a typical cultivation setting, and I haven't read it. I have heard many people praise it as better than its peers, but I can't tell if it's because it's better, or if it's just that the novel setting makes it stand out.
    Last edited by endoperez; 2020-09-29 at 12:27 PM.