Quote Originally Posted by Trask View Post
It is supremely irritating to me when a player just absolutely MUST play this one idea they had, regardless of how poorly it fits or any other circumstances, even if the idea isn't a joke (although it usually is) the total refusal to make concessions is a red flag to me.
This. I had a game I pitched to my players: a politics and intrigue heavy game set in Neverwinter where you are supporting or undermining Lord Dagult’s attempt to become the ruler. Low fantasy adventure.

One player shows up with a planar hopping elf wizard from Sigil who “doesn’t use magic, he uses technology”.