Originally Posted by Theoboldi
All I was really concerned with was the canonicity of that "Wall of Mirrors" thing, which seems to have only been in one novel and no setting material beyond that.
I’ve never heard of the Wall of Mirrors outside of this thread, so I don’t think it’s in any of the 3.X setting material.

Originally Posted by PairO’Dice Lost
I don't think I've noticed anyone conflate the two thus far in the thread.
Which is why I specified forums in general rather than this thread in particular.

Originally Posted by PairO’Dice Lost
Certainly people have described being imprisoned in the Wall as an eternal punishment, but if "having your mind and soul dissolved by magically-radioactive mold over bazillions of years" isn't considered a punishment, I don't know what is.
I haven’t said that the wall isn’t a punishment.

I’m quoting the distinction between the punishments received by the False and the Faithless. According to the text on p. 259 of the FRCS, the wall by definition isn’t eternal punishment, while residence within the City of Judgment is.