Quote Originally Posted by goodyarn View Post
Apples and oranges, no? Even if you're correctly divining the Giant's plan here, it's not hard to imagine a scenario where OOTS offers that world in good faith, Redcloak accepts but because of Plot Complication X it doesn't end up that way.

We're talking about what Redcloak wants. I can't imagine he'd turn down a planet full of good land for his people because he also needs... what?...the acceptance of the other races?
Maybe, although there's the small problem that so far as Redcloak knows the rift also contains a soul-destroying abomination even deities are helpless against, so you'd first have to convince him that offering him the planet inside the rift isn't just a really weak attempt at getting him to self-destruct.