Quote Originally Posted by Skull the Troll View Post
This is what happens when you try to apply a rulebook to ethics. It doesn't work. No set of rules can define ethical behavior in all circumstances. ITs one of those know it when I see it things. Hinjo and Shojo are good. Redcloak is evil. As a DM I would have had Miko fall, and I would have had any paladin who killed a shield on purpose at Redcloaks village fall, but not the ones who killed the High Priest and his underlings. Do I have any rules to back those things up? Nope, don't need 'em. My players would have agreed with me.
Well that is the advantage of tabletop RPGs: There is a living human running things who can decide these sorts of things.