Quote Originally Posted by brian 333 View Post
Paladin A rules a land where it is taught that singing and dancing are evil and that people are required to work 12 hours each day and pray 4 hours. Anyone who tries to escape are hunted down and brought back because a good shepherd doesn't allow his lambs to get lost.

Paladin B lives next door and rescues those from Kingdom A who flee oppression and enslavement. That they will inevitably come into conflict is almost guaranteed.

Which one is evil?
Well, one of them can exist by a cursory reading of D&D rules and the other cannot, so...it must be Paladin B, the existent one.

(One day, I will understand why people think "Good doesn't have to actually mean anything if you don't want it to" is a profound observation. The preceding statement is a lie.)