Taz scowls with angry frustration and her cheeks shift to a bright red, "what the...? This doesn't help us at all! I was so sure too!" She stomps her foot and the humidity in the room increases perceptably. She cools her temper a bit (and with it, dries the air) and then says to the others, "what possible reason would Arkley have for keeping a hidden charter list that checks himself off AND those resisting against him. Maybe it was people present? In which case, these five were the ones missing. But then why have it hidden away?"

Spoiler
Show
Perception: (1d20+6)[14] to see if Taz can identify anything about the marking of the charter, particularly whether the checks were made at different times or by different people.